Competition between Calamagrostiscanadensis and Epilobiumangustifolium under different soil temperature and nutrient regimes
The relative competitive abilities of Calamagrostiscanadensis (Michx.) Beauv. and Epilobiumangustifolium L. were tested in two sets of replacement series experiments. Both species were grown in monocultures and a range of mixtures in 25-cm pots. In the first set, substrates were held at either 9 or 21 °C; in the second set the pots were fertilized at high or low rates. In the 21 °C treatment C. canadensis was more competitive than E. angustifolium (relative crowding coefficient for C. canadensis towards E. angustifolium was 2.88), while there were little competition differences in the cool soil conditions. Under the cool soil temperatures, however, E. angustifolium showed higher vegetative reproduction than under the warm soil conditions. In the high nutrient conditions, C. canadensis was more competitive than E. angustifolium (relative crowding coefficient for C. canadensis towards E. angustifolium was 5.84). There was little competition in the low nutrient experiment. These experiments indicate that if both species colonize a site simultaneously, C. canadensis will outcompete E. angustifolium under most conditions, as suggested from field observations of earlier researchers.