Ralstonia solanacearum Type III Effector RipAC Targets SGT1 to Suppress Effector-Triggered Immunity

Ralstonia solanacearum injects type III effectors into host cells to cause bacterial wilt in Solanaceae plants. To identify R. solanacearum effectors that suppress effector-triggered immunity (ETI) in plants, we evaluated R. solanacearum RS1000 effectors for their ability to suppress a hypersensitive response (HR) induced by the avirulence (Avr) effector RipAA in Nicotiana benthamiana. Out of the 11 effectors tested, 4 suppressed RipAA-triggered HR cell death. Among them, RipAC contains tandem repeats of the leucine-rich repeat (LRR) motif, which serves as the structural scaffold for a protein–protein interaction. We found that the LRR domain of RipAC was indispensable for the suppression of HR cell death during the recognition of RipAA and another Avr effector RipP1. By yeast two-hybrid screening, we identified N. benthamiana SGT1, an adaptor protein that forms a molecular chaperone complex with RAR1, as a host factor of the RipAC target. RipAC interacted with NbSGT1 in yeast and plant cells. Upon the formation of the molecular chaperone complex, the presence of RipAC markedly inhibits the interaction between NbSGT1 and NbRAR1. The RipAA- and RipP1-triggered HR cell deaths were not observed in NbSGT1-silenced plants. The introduction of RipAC was complementary to the reduced growth of the R. solanacearum mutant strain in N. benthamiana. These findings indicate that R. solanacearum uses RipAC to subvert the NbSGT1-mediated formation of the molecular chaperone complex and suppress ETI responses during the recognition of Avr effectors.

Plant NLR targets P-type ATPase for executing plasma membrane depolarization leading to calcium influx and cell death

Hypersensitive response (HR) is a robust immune response mediated by plant nucleotide-binding and leucine-rich repeat receptor (NLR). However, the early molecular event linking NLR to cell death is obscure. Here we demonstrate that NLR targets plasma membrane H+-ATPases (PMA) generating electrochemical potential across the membrane. CCA309, an autoactive N-terminal domain of pepper coiled-coil NLR (CNL), associates with PMAs and its autoactivity is affected by silencing or overexpression of PMA. CCA309-induced extracellular alkalization accompanied with membrane depolarization is followed by calcium influx and cell death. CCA309 interacts with C-terminal regulatory domain of PMA and 14-3-3 negatively affects CCA309-induced cell death. Moreover, pharmacological experiments with fusicoccin, an irreversible PMA activator, confirmed that CC- and CNL-mediated cell death occurred through inhibiting PMA. We propose PMAs as the primary target of plasma membrane-associated CNL to disrupt electrochemical homeostasis leading to HR cell death.

Single Amino Acid Substitutions in the Cucumber Mosaic Virus 1a Protein Induce Necrotic Cell Death in Virus-Inoculated Leaves without Affecting Virus Multiplication

When Arabidopsis thaliana ecotype Col-0 was inoculated with a series of reassortant viruses created by exchanging viral genomic RNAs between two strains of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV), CMV(Y), and CMV(H), cell death developed in the leaves inoculated with reassortant CMV carrying CMV(H) RNA1 encoding 1a protein, but not in noninoculated upper leaves. In general, cell death in virus-infected plants is a critical event for virus survival because virus multiplication is completely dependent on host cell metabolism. However, interestingly, this observed cell death did not affect either virus multiplication in the inoculated leaves or systemic spread to noninoculated upper leaves. Furthermore, the global gene expression pattern of the reassortant CMV-inoculated leaves undergoing cell death was clearly different from that in hypersensitive response (HR) cell death, which is coupled with resistance to CMV. These results indicated that the observed cell death does not appear to be HR cell death but rather necrotic cell death unrelated to CMV resistance. Interestingly, induction of this necrotic cell death depended on single amino acid substitutions in the N-terminal region surrounding the methyltransferase domain of the 1a protein. Thus, development of necrotic cell death might not be induced by non-specific damage as a result of virus multiplication, but by a virus protein-associated mechanism. The finding of CMV 1a protein-mediated induction of necrotic cell death in A. thaliana, which is not associated with virus resistance and HR cell death, has the potential to provide a new pathosystem to study the role of cell death in virus–host plant interactions.

Genome-wide functional analysis of hot pepper immune receptors reveals an autonomous NLR cluster in seed plants

Plants possess hundreds of intracellular immune receptors encoding nucleotide-binding domain and leucine-rich repeat (NLR) proteins. Autoactive NLRs, in some cases a specific NLR domain, induce plant cell death in the absence of pathogen infection. In this study, we identified a group of NLRs (G10) carrying autoactive coiled-coil (CC) domains in pepper (Capsicum annuum L. cv. CM334) by genome-wide transient expression analysis. The G10-CC-mediated cell death mimics hypersensitive response (HR) cell death triggered by interaction between NLR and effectors derived from pathogens. Sequence alignment and mutagenesis analyses revealed that the intact α1 helix of G10-CCs is critical for both G10-CC- and R gene-mediated HR cell death. The cell death induced by G10-CCs does not require known helper NLRs, suggesting G10-NLRs are novel singleton NLRs. We also found that G10-CCs localize in the plasma membrane as Arabidopsis singleton NLR ZAR1. Extended studies revealed that autoactive G10-CCs are well conserved in other Solanaceae plants, including tomato, potato, and tobacco, as well as a monocot plant, rice. Furthermore, G10-NLR is an ancient form of NLR that present in all tested seed plants (spermatophytes). Our studies not only uncover the autonomous NLR cluster in plants but also provide powerful resources for dissecting the underlying molecular mechanism of NLR-mediated cell death in plants.

RCY1-Mediated Resistance to Cucumber mosaic virus Is Regulated by LRR Domain-Mediated Interaction with CMV(Y) Following Degradation of RCY1

RCY1, which encodes a coiled coil nucleotide-binding site leucine-rich repeat (LRR) class R protein, confers the hypersensitive response (HR) to a yellow strain of Cucumber mosaic virus (CMV[Y]) in Arabidopsis thaliana. Nicotiana benthamiana transformed with hemagglutinin (HA) epitope-tagged RCY1 (RCY1-HA) also exhibited a defense response accompanied by HR cell death and induction of defense-related gene expression in response to CMV(Y). Following transient expression of RCY1-HA by agroinfiltration, the defense reaction was induced in N. benthamiana leaves infected with CMV(Y) but not in virulent CMV(B2)-infected N. benthamiana leaves transiently expressing RCY1-HA or CMV(Y)-infected N. benthamiana leaves transiently expressing HA-tagged RPP8 (RPP8-HA), which is allelic to RCY1. This result suggests that Arabidopsis RCY1-conferred resistance to CMV(Y) could be reproduced in N. benthamiana leaves in a gene-for-gene manner. Expression of a series of chimeric constructs between RCY1-HA and RPP8-HA in CMV(Y)-infected N. benthamiana indicated that induction of defense responses to CMV(Y) is regulated by the LRR domain of RCY1. Interestingly, in CMV(Y)-infected N. benthamiana manifesting the defense response, the levels of both RCY1 and chimeric proteins harboring the RCY1 LRR domain were significantly reduced. Taken together, these data indicate that the RCY1-conferred resistance response to CMV(Y) is regulated by an LRR domain-mediated interaction with CMV(Y) and seems to be tightly associated with the degradation of RCY1 in response to CMV(Y).

Expression of the Baculovirus p35 Protein in Tobacco Affects Cell Death Progression and Compromises N Gene-Mediated Disease Resistance Response to Tobacco mosaic virus

The p35 protein from baculovirus is a broad-range caspase inhibitor and suppresses programmed cell death in animals. We report here the effects of transgenic expression in tobacco of the p35 protein during the hypersensitive response (HR). Expression of p35 causes partial inhibition of nonhost HR triggered by bacteria and gene-for-gene HR triggered by virus. Infection of p35-expressing tobacco plants with Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) disrupts N-mediated disease resistance, causing systemic spreading of the virus within a resistant background. Mutant variants altered in aspartate residues within the loop region of p35 are inefficient substrates for caspases in vitro, and they do not suppress caspase proteolytic activity in animal systems. Tobacco plants expressing these mutant variants of the p35 protein do not show inhibition of HR cell death or enhanced virus systemic movement. Thus, HR inhibition and TMV systemic spreading phenotype in p35-expressing plants correlate with the ability of the p35 protein to suppress caspase activity in animal systems. In addition, a C-terminal truncated variant of p35 is unable to suppress cell death in animals as well as HR cell death in transgenic tobacco. Our results provide evidence for the participation of caspase-like proteases during the HR. In addition, they suggest that timely activation of cell death is necessary for effective TMV containment within the primary infection site.

Cytological Investigation of Resistance to Leptosphaeria maculans Conferred to Brassica napus by Introgressions Originating from B. juncea or B. nigra B Genome

Introgressions into Brassica napus from the B genome, either the B. nigra chromosome B4 or the B. juncea fragment carrying the Jlm1 gene, have given rise to the B. napus-B. nigra addition line (LA4+) and the B. napus-B. juncea recombinant line (MXS), respectively. The resistance of these two lines to Leptosphaeria maculans is characterized by a hypersensitive reaction (HR) on both the cotyledons and leaves, while the collar displays a high degree of resistance. Responses induced in cotyledons of the two lines by L. maculans inoculation were investigated with emphasis on cytological events underlying the HR and on host defense reactions. Features of host cell changes including condensation and lobing of nuclei, fragmentation of chromatin, disruption of the nuclear membranes, and plasma membrane withdrawal were reminiscent of HR cell death in MXS and LA4+ plants. Restriction of pathogen growth to the infection areas in LA4+ was correlated to reinforcement of cell wall barriers, including wall apposition, papillae, and vessel plugging. In MXS, the lower expression of resistance was associated with a delay in plant responses. These results indicate that mechanisms underlying the HR in the B. napus recombinant and addition lines are differently controlled according to the introgressed genes.