The Budyko functions under non-steady state conditions: new
approach and comparison with previous formulations
Abstract. The Budyko functions relate the evaporation ratio E / P (E is evaporation and P precipitation) to the aridity index Φ = Ep / P (Ep is potential evaporation) and are valid on long timescales under steady state conditions. A new formulation physically based (noted ML) is proposed to extend the Budyko framework under non-steady state conditions taking into account the change in soil water storage S. The ML formulation introduces an additional parameter S* = S / Ep and can be applied with all classical Budyko functions. In the standard Budyko space (Ep / P, E / P), and for the particular case where the Fu-Zhang equation is used as a Budyko function, the ML formulation yields similar results to the analytical solution of Greve et al. (2016), and a simple relationship can be established between their respective parameters. Then, the ML formulation is extended to the space [(Ep / (P + S), E / (P + S)] and compared to the formulations of Chen et al. (2013) and Du et al. (2016). We show that the ML and Greve et al. formulations have similar upper feasible domain but their lower feasible domain is different from those of Chen et al. (2103) and Du et al. (2016). Moreover, the domain of variation of Ep / (P + S) differs: it is bounded by an upper limit 1 / S* in the ML formulation, while it is bounded with a lower limit in Chen et al.'s and Du et al.'s formulations.