COMPARISON OF CRITICAL NUTRIENT CONCENTRATIONS WITH DRIS FOR ASSESSING NUTRIENT DEFICIENCIES OF POTATOES ON IRRIGATED CHERNOZEMIC SOILS
Best fit quadratic response curves relating tuber yields with fertilizer treatment rates from a 3-yr 4 × 4 factorial field experiment provided the bases for diagnosing nutrient deficiencies of N and P. These curves were compared with similar response curves of leaf nutrient concentrations and for deficiency indices calculated by the Diagnosis and Recommendation Integrated System (DRIS). Critical nutrient concentrations (CNCs) of 5.93 and 5.44% of N and 0.47 and 0.35% of P were associated with estimated yield decrements of < 5% and > 15% of the maxima. Corresponding DRIS indices were −2.1 and −6.7 for N and −10 and −26 for P. Although there were no yield responses to applied K in 10 field experiments, 4 and 3% were selected as CNCs possibly indicative of K-supplying potential. Corresponding DRIS values were 5.6 and −17. When these CNC values were applied to 372 commercial fields sampled over an 8-yr period, there were 30, 44, and 12% in the top class for N, P, and K, respectively, while 34, 8, and 7% were in the bottom deficiency class. The DRIS system placed 41, 76, and 76% of the fields in the same deficiency classes for N, P, and K, respectively, but only 13, 0, and 0% differed by more than one class. There appeared to be limited potential advantages for the DRIS method of diagnosis.Key words: Solanum tuberosum L., leaf analysis, fertilizer rates, potato.