T cell competition profoundly reduces the effect of initial precursor frequency on the generation of CD4 T cell memory

SummaryProtective immune responses are accompanied by increases in the frequency of high affinity T cells, which contribute to subsequent immunological memory. There is evidence that the fold-change in T cell number during the immune response is inversely related to initial precursor frequency, but the size of this effect remains poorly defined. Indeed, in many reports precursor frequency has been considered as directly proportional to the magnitude of the response. We have determined the effect of initial precursor frequency over the course of an in vivo antigen-specific response, in an experimental setting in which the other variables, TCR affinity and antigen dose, are kept constant. A major effect of precursor frequency was apparent in both the expansion and contraction phases; low initial precursor frequency in the physiological range was associated with greater initial expansion in T cell numbers, and also with preferential retention of memory cells. The effect was seen continuously across a 1000-fold naïve cell frequency range, leading to memory cell frequencies that differed by only 3-fold. These results are consistent with the existence of ongoing competition for antigen throughout the course of the immune response and explain the paradoxical ability of populations of genetically diverse individuals to make appropriate protective immune responses despite the large differences in initial repertoire that result from semi-random thymic TCR repertoire generation and selection.

B cells expressing authentic naive human VRC01-class BCRs can be recruited to germinal centers and affinity mature in multiple independent mouse models

Animal models of human antigen-specific B cell receptors (BCRs) generally depend on “inferred germline” sequences, and thus their relationship to authentic naive human B cell BCR sequences and affinities is unclear. Here, BCR sequences from authentic naive human VRC01-class B cells from healthy human donors were selected for the generation of three BCR knockin mice. The BCRs span the physiological range of affinities found in humans, and use three different light chains (VK3-20, VK1-5, and VK1-33) found among subclasses of naive human VRC01-class B cells and HIV broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs). The germline-targeting HIV immunogen eOD-GT8 60mer is currently in clinical trial as a candidate bnAb vaccine priming immunogen. To attempt to model human immune responses to the eOD-GT8 60mer, we tested each authentic naive human VRC01-class BCR mouse model under rare human physiological B cell precursor frequency conditions. B cells with high (HuGL18HL) or medium (HuGL17HL) affinity BCRs were primed, recruited to germinal centers, and they affinity matured, and formed memory B cells. Precursor frequency and affinity interdependently influenced responses. Taken together, these experiments utilizing authentic naive human VRC01-class BCRs validate a central tenet of germline-targeting vaccine design and extend the overall concept of the reverse vaccinology approach to vaccine development.

B cells expressing authentic naive human VRC01-class BCRs can be primed and recruited to germinal centers in multiple independent mouse models

ABSTRACTAnimal models of human antigen-specific B cell receptors (BCR) generally depend on “inferred germline” sequences, and thus their relationship to authentic naive human B cell BCR sequences and affinities is unclear. Here, BCR sequences from authentic naive human VRC01-class B cells from healthy human donors were selected for the generation of three new BCR knock-in mice. The BCRs span the physiological range of affinities found in humans, and use three different light chains (VK3-20, VK1-5, and VK1-33) found among subclasses of naive human VRC01-class B cells and HIV broadly neutralizing antibodies (bnAbs). The germline-targeting HIV immunogen eOD-GT8 60mer is currently in clinical trial as a candidate bnAb vaccine priming immunogen. To attempt to model human immune responses to the eOD-GT8 60mer, we tested each authentic naive human VRC01-class BCR mouse model under rare human physiological B cell precursor frequency conditions. B cells with high (HuGL18HL) or medium (HuGL17HL) affinity BCRs were primed, recruited to germinal centers, accrued substantial somatic hypermutation, and formed memory B cells. Precursor frequency and affinity interdependently influenced responses. Taken together, these experiments utilizing authentic naive human VRC01-class BCRs validate a central tenet of germline-targeting vaccine design and extend the overall concept of the reverse vaccinology approach to vaccine development.

Anti–HIV-1 B cell responses are dependent on B cell precursor frequency and antigen-binding affinity

The discovery that humans can produce potent broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) to several different epitopes on the HIV-1 spike has reinvigorated efforts to develop an antibody-based HIV-1 vaccine. Antibody cloning from single cells revealed that nearly all bNAbs show unusual features that could help explain why it has not been possible to elicit them by traditional vaccination and instead would require a sequence of different immunogens. This idea is supported by experiments with genetically modified immunoglobulin (Ig) knock-in mice. Sequential immunization with a series of specifically designed immunogens was required to shepherd the development of bNAbs. However, knock-in mice contain superphysiologic numbers of bNAb precursor-expressing B cells, and therefore how these results can be translated to a more physiologic setting remains to be determined. Here we make use of adoptive transfer experiments using knock-in B cells that carry a synthetic intermediate in the pathway to anti–HIV-1 bNAb development to examine how the relationship between B cell receptor affinity and precursor frequency affects germinal center (GC) B cell recruitment and clonal expansion. Immunization with soluble HIV-1 antigens can recruit bNAb precursor B cells to the GC when there are as few as 10 such cells per mouse. However, at low precursor frequencies, the extent of clonal expansion is directly proportional to the affinity of the antigen for the B cell receptor, and recruitment to GCs is variable and dependent on recirculation.

Anti-HIV-1 B cell responses are dependent on B cell precursor frequency and antigen binding affinity

The discovery that humans can produce potent broadly neutralizing antibodies (bNAbs) to several different epitopes on the HIV-1 spike has reinvigorated efforts to develop an antibody based HIV-1 vaccine. Antibody cloning from single cells revealed that nearly all bNAbs show unusual features that could help explain why it has not been possible to elicit them by traditional vaccination, and instead that it would require a sequence of different immunogens. This idea is supported by experiments with genetically modified immunoglobulin knock-in mice. Sequential immunization with a series of specifically designed immunogens was required to shepherd the development of bNAbs. However, knock-in mice contain super-physiologic numbers of bNAb precursor expressing B cells and therefore how these results can be translated to a more physiologic setting remains to be determined. Here we make use of adoptive transfer experiments using knock-in B cells that carry a synthetic intermediate in the pathway to anti-HIV-1 bNAb development to examine how the relationship between B cell receptor affinity and precursor frequency affects germinal center B cell recrutiment and clonal expansion. Immunization with soluble HIV-1 antigens can recruit bNAb precursor B cells to the germinal center when there are as few as 10 such cells per mouse. However, at low precursor frequencies the extent of clonal expansion is directly proportional to the affinity of the antigen for the B cell receptor, and recruitment to germinal centers is variable and dependent on re-circulation.Significance statementAn essential requirement for an HIV-vaccine is to elicit antibodies to conserved regions of the spike protein (Env) becasue these antibodies can protect against infection. Although broadly neutralizing antibodies develop naturally in rare individuals after prolongued HIV infection, eliciting them by vaccination has only been possible in artificial knock-in mouse models wherein the number of B cells expressing the antibody precursor is super-physiologic. To understand the relationship between precursor frequency, antigen affinity and germinal center recruitment we have performed adoptive transfer experiments in which fixed numbers of precursor cells are engrafted in wild type mice. Our results provide a framework for understanding how precursor frequency and antigen affinity shape humoral immunity to HIV.

Hepatic T Cell Tolerance Induction in An Inflammatory Environment

For the development of autoimmune hepatitis (AIH), genetic predisposition and environmental triggers are of major importance. Although experimental AIH can be induced in genetically susceptible mice, the low precursor frequency of autoreactive T cells hampers a deeper analysis of liver-specific T cells. Here, we established a system where the model antigen hemagglutinin (HA) is expressed exclusively in hepatocytes of Rosa26-HA mice following administration of a replication deficient adenovirus expressing Cre recombinase (Ad-Cre). Under these conditions, hepatocytes mimic the generation of altered-self neoantigens. To follow autoreactive T cells during AIH, we adoptively transferred HA-­specific Cl4-TCR and 6.5-TCR T cells into Ad-Cre infected ­Rosa26-HA mice. Alternatively, Rosa26-HA mice have been crossed with TCR transgenic mice that were infected with Ad-Cre to break hepatic tolerance and induce the expression of the HA antigen as a hepatic self-antigen. Surprisingly, neither adoptive transfer nor a very high precursor frequency of autoreactive T cells was able to break tolerance in the context of adenoviral infection. The low proliferation of the antigen experienced autoreactive T cells despite the presence of the autoantigen and inflammation points to anergy as a potential tolerance mechanism. This model underscores the crucial importance of genetic susceptibility to break tolerance against hepatic autoantigens.