Evolutionarily stable disequilibrium: endless dynamics of evolution in a stationary population

Evolution is often conceived as changes in the properties of a population over generations. Does this notion exhaust the possible dynamics of evolution? Life is hierarchically organized, and evolution can operate at multiple levels with conflicting tendencies. Using a minimal model of such conflicting multilevel evolution, we demonstrate the possibility of a novel mode of evolution that challenges the above notion: individuals ceaselessly modify their genetically inherited phenotype and fitness along their lines of descent, without involving apparent changes in the properties of the population. The model assumes a population of primitive cells (protocells, for short), each containing a population of replicating catalytic molecules. Protocells are selected towards maximizing the catalytic activity of internal molecules, whereas molecules tend to evolve towards minimizing it in order to maximize their relative fitness within a protocell. These conflicting evolutionary tendencies at different levels and genetic drift drive the lineages of protocells to oscillate endlessly between high and low intracellular catalytic activity, i.e. high and low fitness, along their lines of descent. This oscillation, however, occurs independently in different lineages, so that the population as a whole appears stationary. Therefore, ongoing evolution can be hidden behind an apparently stationary population owing to conflicting multilevel evolution.

Multilevel Evolution: The Fate of Duplicated Genes

Biological evolution is a multilevel process and should be studied as such. A first, important step in studying evolution in this way has been the work of Peter Schuster and co-workers on RNA evolution. For RNA the genotype-phenotype mapping can be calculated explicitly. The resulting evolutionary dynamics is dominated by neutral paths, and the potential of major change by a single point mutation.Examining whole genomes, of which about 60 are now available, we see that gene content of genomes is changing relatively rapidly: gene duplication, gene loss and gene generation is ubiquitous. In fact, it seems that point-mutations play a relatively minor role, relative to changes in gene regulation and gene content in adaptive evolution.Large scale micro-array studies, in which the expression of every gene can be measured simultaneously, give a first glimpse of the `division of labor´ between duplicated genes. A preliminary analysis suggests that differential expression is often the primary event which allows duplicated genes to be maintained in a genome, but alternate routes also exist, most notably on the one hand the mere need of a lot of product, and on the other hand differentiation within multi-protein complexes consisting of homologous genes.I will discuss these results in terms of multilevel evolution. in particular in terms of information integration and the alternatives of `individual based´