Homoploid hybridization signals due to ancestral subdivision: a case study on the D lineage in wheat

Homoploid hybrid speciation has been reported in a wide range of species since the exploitation of genome sequences in evolutionary studies. However, the interference of ancestral subdivision has not been adequately considered in many such investigations. Using the D lineage in wheat as an example, we showed clearly that ancestral subdivision has led to false detection of homoploid hybridization signals. We develop a novel statistical framework by examining the changes in shared ancestral variations and infer on the likelihood of speciation due to genuine homoploid hybridization or ancestral subdivisions. Applying this to wheat data, we found that homoploid hybridization was not involved in the origin of the D lineage contrary to the now widely held belief. This example indicates that the significance of homoploid hybrid speciation is likely exaggerated. The underlying methodology developed in this study should be valuable for clarifying whether homoploid hybridization has contributed to the speciation of many other species.

Multiple species of wild tree peonies gave rise to the ‘king of flowers’, Paeonia suffruticosa Andrews

The origin of cultivated tree peonies, known as the ‘king of flowers' in China for more than 1000 years, has attracted considerable interest, but remained unsolved. Here, we conducted phylogenetic analyses of explicitly sampled traditional cultivars of tree peonies and all wild species from the shrubby section Moutan of the genus Paeonia based on sequences of 14 fast-evolved chloroplast regions and 25 presumably single-copy nuclear markers identified from RNA-seq data. The phylogeny of the wild species inferred from the nuclear markers was fully resolved and largely congruent with morphology and classification. The incongruence between the nuclear and chloroplast trees suggested that there had been gene flow between the wild species. The comparison of nuclear and chloroplast phylogenies including cultivars showed that the cultivated tree peonies originated from homoploid hybridization among five wild species. Since the origin, thousands of cultivated varieties have spread worldwide, whereas four parental species are currently endangered or on the verge of extinction. The documentation of extensive homoploid hybridization involved in tree peony domestication provides new insights into the mechanisms underlying the origins of garden ornamentals and the way of preserving natural genetic resources through domestication.