Calcium Sensitive Allostery Regulates the PI(4,5)P2 Binding Site of the Dysferlin C2A Domain

C2 domains are the second-most abundant calcium binding module in the proteome. Activity of the muscular dystrophy associated protein dysferlin is dependent on the C2A domain at the N-terminus of the protein, which couples calcium and PI(4,5)P2 binding through an unknown mechanism. Using solution state nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy we confirm the phosphoinositide binding site for the domain and find that calcium binding attenuates millisecond to microsecond motions at both in the calcium binding loops and the concave face of the C2A, including a portion of the phosphoinositide binding site. Our results support a model whereby increasing calcium concentrations shift the phosphoinositide binding pocket of C2A into a binding-competent state, allowing for calcium dependent membrane targeting. This model contrasts with the canonical mechanism for C2 domain-phosphoinositide interaction and provides a basis for how pathogenic mutations in the C2A domain result in loss of function and disease.

Calcium binds and rigidifies the dysferlin C2A domain in a tightly coupled manner

The membrane protein dysferlin (DYSF) is important for calcium-activated plasma membrane repair, especially in muscle fibre cells. Nearly 600 mutations in the DYSF gene have been identified that are causative for rare genetic forms of muscular dystrophy. The dysferlin protein consists of seven C2 domains (C2A–C2G, 13%–33% identity) used to recruit calcium ions and traffic accessory proteins and vesicles to injured membrane sites needed to reseal a wound. Amongst these, the C2A is the most prominent facilitating the calcium-sensitive interaction with membrane surfaces. In this work, we determined the calcium-free and calcium-bound structures of the dysferlin C2A domain using NMR spectroscopy and X-ray crystallography. We show that binding two calcium ions to this domain reduces the flexibility of the Ca2+-binding loops in the structure. Furthermore, calcium titration and mutagenesis experiments reveal the tight coupling of these calcium-binding sites whereby the elimination of one site abolishes calcium binding to its partner site. We propose that the electrostatic potential distributed by the flexible, negatively charged calcium-binding loops in the dysferlin C2A domain control first contact with calcium that promotes subsequent binding. Based on these results, we hypothesize that dysferlin uses a ‘calcium-catching’ mechanism to respond to calcium influx during membrane repair.

Multivalent lipid targeting by the calcium-independent C2A domain of synaptotagmin-like protein 4/ granuphilin

Synaptotagmin-like protein 4 (Slp-4), also known as granuphilin, is a Rab effector responsible for docking secretory vesicles to the plasma membrane before exocytosis. Slp-4 binds vesicular Rab proteins via an N-terminal Slp homology domain, interacts with plasma membrane SNARE complex proteins via a central linker region, and contains tandem C-terminal C2 domains (C2A and C2B) with affinity for phosphatidylinositol-(4,5)-bisphosphate (PIP2). The Slp-4 C2A domain binds with low nanomolar apparent affinity to PIP2 in lipid vesicles that also contain background anionic lipids such as phosphatidylserine (PS), but much weaker when either the background anionic lipids or PIP2 are removed. Through computational and experimental approaches, we show that this high affinity membrane binding arises from concerted interaction at multiple sites on the C2A domain. In addition to a conserved PIP2-selective lysine cluster, a larger cationic surface surrounding the cluster contributes substantially to the affinity for physiologically relevant lipid compositions. Although the K398A mutation in the lysine cluster blocks PIP2 binding, this mutated protein domain retains the ability to bind physiological membranes in both a liposome binding assay and MIN6 cells. Molecular dynamics simulations indicate several conformationally flexible loops that contribute to the nonspecific cationic surface. We also identify and characterize a covalently modified variant that arises through reactivity of the PIP2-binding lysine cluster with endogenous bacterial compounds and binds weakly to membranes. Overall, multivalent lipid binding by the Slp-4 C2A domain provides selective recognition and high affinity docking of large dense-core secretory vesicles to the plasma membrane.

Synaptotagmin-1 membrane binding is driven by the C2B domain and assisted cooperatively by the C2A domain

Synaptotagmin interaction with anionic lipid (phosphatidylserine/phosphatidylinositol) containing membranes, both in the absence and presence of calcium ions (Ca2+), is critical to its central role in orchestrating neurotransmitter release. The molecular surfaces involved, namely the conserved polylysine motif in the C2B domain and Ca2+-binding aliphatic loops on both C2A and C2B domains, are known. Here we use surface force apparatus combined with systematic mutational analysis of the functional surfaces to directly measure Syt1-membrane interaction and fully map the site-binding energetics of Syt1 both in the absence and presence of Ca2+. By correlating energetics data with the molecular rearrangements measured during confinement, we find that both C2 domains cooperate in membrane binding, with the C2B domain functioning as the main energetic driver, and the C2A domain acting as a facilitator.

Multivalent lipid targeting by the calcium-independent C2A domain of Slp-4/granuphilin

ABSTRACTSynaptotagmin-like protein 4 (Slp-4), also known as granuphilin, is a Rab effector responsible for docking secretory vesicles to the plasma membrane before exocytosis. Slp-4 binds vesicular Rab proteins via an N-terminal Slp homology (SHD) domain, interacts with plasma membrane SNARE complex proteins via a central linker region, and contains tandem C-terminal C2 domains (C2A and C2B) with affinity for phosphatidylinositol-(4,5)-bisphosphate (PIP2). The Slp-4 C2A domain binds with low nanomolar apparent affinity to PIP2 in lipid vesicles that also contain background anionic lipids such as phosphatidylserine (PS), but much weaker when either the background anionic lipids or PIP2 are removed. Through computational and experimental approaches, we show that this high affinity membrane interaction arises from concerted interaction at multiple sites on the C2A domain. In addition to a conserved PIP2-selective lysine cluster, there exists a larger cationic surface surrounding the cluster which contributes substantially to the affinity for physiologically relevant lipid compositions. While mutations at the PIP2-selective site decrease affinity for PIP2, multiple mutations are needed to decrease binding to physiologically relevant lipid compositions. Docking and molecular dynamics simulations indicate several conformationally flexible loops that contribute to the nonspecific cationic surface. We also identify and characterize a covalently modified variant in the bacterially expressed protein, which arises through reactivity of the PIP2-binding lysine cluster with endogenous bacterial compounds and has a low membrane affinity. Overall, multivalent lipid binding by the Slp-4 C2A domain provides selective recognition and high affinity docking of large dense-core secretory vesicles to the plasma membrane.