A Reply to Mr. Nygaard
I have read, with ever increasing incredulity, an article in the October (1941) issue of The Mathematics Teacher entitled “A Functional Revision of Plane Geometry” by P. H. Nygaard. Mr. Nygaard's article is such a glaring example of the type of discussion which finds its way into print today to the mortal harm of sound instruction in mathematics that I can not let it pass unchallenged. We have here at Winthrop a student chapter of the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics into the hands of whose members there comes each month during the school year a copy of The Mathematics Teacher. Since I am the faculty sponsor of this group I can for them correct the enors in Mr. Nygaard's essay. The effect of this correction is, however, limited by the range of my voice; therefore, I hope that my reply may have full publicity in The Mathematics Teacher to the end that I may reach the audience afforded to Mr. Nygaard.