Children's Strategies for Solving Compositional Problems with Peers
This article reports some of the findings of a qualitative study of musical learning processes. The data were drawn from analysis of videotapes and audiotapes that shadowed the classroom experiences of two target students in a fifth-grade general music class over a period of 5 months. A portion of the curriculum in the study class involved small-group composition projects. Findings reported here characterize the group composition process in terms of the nature of the strategies the children used as they worked together with peers to solve those compositional problems. Children who were successful in completing class assignments used strategies that seemed to follow a pattern of moving from whole (initial planning) to part (development of motivic ideas) and back to whole (reassembling and practicing). The children's decisions seemed to stem from a holistic viewpoint, reflecting a preconceived vision of the final product from the outset. In contrast, there were very few instances of random exploration.