Use of Perspective Plots To Aid in Determining Factors Affecting Interfacial Tensions Between Surfactant Solutions and Crude Oil

1982 ◽  
Vol 22 (03) ◽  
pp. 350-352
Author(s):  
G.E. Kellerhals

Abstract In surfactant flooding, low interfacial tensions (IFT's) are required for recovery of additional significant quantities of crude oil from a reservoir rock. This paper indicates the usefulness of perspective plots to facilitate comparison of sets of IFT data. Such perspective plots simplify the process of screening various surfactant systems for enhanced oil recovery. Introduction Numerous articles have been written about the effects and/or importance of IFT between oil and aqueous phases in determining ultimate oil recovery during a phases in determining ultimate oil recovery during a secondary (waterflooding) or tertiary oil-recovery process. In the area of micellar/polymer or surfactant process. In the area of micellar/polymer or surfactant flooding, IFT has been studied extensively both by industrial and by academic investigators. A simplistic summary of this work is that low IFT's (generally corresponding to high capillary numbers ( are required for recovery of additional significant quantities of crude oil from a reservoir rock. Method Development Several variables influence between an oil-rich phase and a surfactant-containing aqueous phase. During phase and a surfactant-containing aqueous phase. During a surfactant flood, variations in surfactant concentration and salt concentration will occur as a result of mixing of the chemical slug with the pre flush (or formation brine) and polymer drive (" rear mixing" ). Nelson investigated salt concentrations required during a chemical flood to achieve efficient oil displacement. Since these variables (and others) change during the progress of a flood, it is desirable to determine the impact of these changes on the IFT between the oil- and water-rich phases. To assess the importance of changes in these two key variables (surfactant concentration and salinity) on IFT, an x-y plot may be constructed with values of each variable along the axes. The IFT for a particular surfactant concentration and salinity then is obtained experimentally and the numerical value placed at the corresponding (x, y) point on the plot. The resultant figure/table can be referred to as an IFT map. Points of equal, or about equal, IFT can be connected to produce an IFT contour map. In the investigation of the effect(s) of temperature on a given surfactant system and crude oil, IFT maps might be constructed for each of the pertinent temperatures. IFT's might be determined at six different sodium chloride concentrations (e.g., 1.0, 1.5, 2.0, 3.0, 4.0, and 5.0 wt%) and four surfactant concentrations (e.g., 0.085, 0.064, 0.042, and 0.021 meq/mL), resulting in IFT maps (for each temperature) each consisting of 24 IFT values. A comparison of the values of one map to the values of a second map (measurements made at different temperature) then is required to determine the impact of the temperature change. A single value for IFT for a given salinity and surfactant concentration assumes that the system is two-phase, because two IFT's can be measured for a three-phase system consisting of an oil-rich phase, a water-rich phase, and a microemulsion phase. phase. A method to allow easier comparison for the relatively large number of IFT data points that may be obtained during the study/screening of various surfactant systems at various conditions is described in this paper. The technique consists of interpolating between IFT values and then plotting the data with a perspective plotting routine. The method allows comparisons of IFT values for different crude oils, temperatures, cosolvent types, surfactant types, hardness ion concentrations, etc., through visual scanning of a perspective plot ranter than through trying to judge or compare numerical IFT values of an IFT map. SPEJ p. 350

Author(s):  
Ayako Fukumoto ◽  
Christine Dalmazzone ◽  
Didier Frot ◽  
Loïc Barré ◽  
Christine Noïk

Surfactant flooding is a chemical enhanced oil recovery (EOR) process which consists in injecting optimized formulations of surfactants in the reservoir in order to remobilize the residual oil trapped in the pores of the rock. To do that, it is necessary to design specific formulations in order to get so-called Winsor III systems of very low interfacial tensions with the crude oil. Unfortunately, there is no well-established way to characterize and understand the physical properties and structures of microemulsions composed of crude oil and industrial surfactants due to their extreme complexity. In a previous work, we have developed a methodology based on the use of several techniques (DLS, MLS, SAXS, cryo-SEM, DSC, interfacial measurements, etc.) allowing physico-chemical and morphological characterization of these microemulsions in the case of a model system. In this article, we will demonstrate how DSC can be used to provide information on the physico-chemical composition of complex microemulsions (water and oil content, salinity, etc.) and on their morphology (continuous phase, dispersed phase, etc.).


1981 ◽  
Vol 59 (13) ◽  
pp. 1938-1943 ◽  
Author(s):  
Graham Neale ◽  
Vladimir Hornof ◽  
Christopher Chiwetelu

This paper reviews the potential importance of aqueous lignosulfonate solutions in the recovery of petroleum from existing partially depleted oil fields. The surfactant qualities of lignosulfonates are described and their ability to interact synergistically with petroleum sulfonate surfactants (which are currently popular in the industry) to produce ultra-low interfacial tensions with crude oil is discussed. The phase behaviour characteristics and oil recovery efficacies of these mixed surfactant systems are also examined.


1979 ◽  
Vol 19 (03) ◽  
pp. 183-193 ◽  
Author(s):  
C.J. Glover ◽  
M.C. Puerto ◽  
J.M. Maerker ◽  
E.L. Sandvik

Glover, C.J.,* SPE-AIME, Exxon Production Research Puerto, M.C., SPE-AIME, Puerto, M.C., SPE-AIME, Exxon Production Research Co. Maerker, J.M., SPE-AIME, Exxon Production Research Co. Sandvik, E.L., SPE-AIME, Exxon Production Research Co. Abstract Surfactant retention in reservoir rock is a major factor limiting effectiveness of oil recovery using microemulsion flooding processes. Effects of salinity and surfactant concentration on microemulsion phase behavior have a significant impact on relative phase behavior have a significant impact on relative magnitudes of retention attributed to adsorption vs entrapment of immiscible microemulsion phases.Surfactant retention levels were determined by effluent sample analyses from microemulsion flow tests in Berea cores. Data for single surfactant systems containing NaCl only and multicomponent surfactant systems containing monovalent and divalent cations are included. Retention is shown to increase linearly with salinity at low salt concentrations and depart from linearity with higher retentions above a critical salinity. This departure from linearity is shown to correlate with formation of upper-phase microemulsions. The linear trend, therefore, is attributed to surfactant adsorption, and retention levels in excess of this trend are attributed to phase trapping.Divalent cations are shown to influence microemulsion phase behavior strongly through formation of divalent-cation sulfonate species. A useful method for predicting phase behavior in systems containing divalent cations is described. This method combines equilibrium expressions with a relationship defining the contribution of each surfactant component to optimal salinity. Observed experimental data are compared with predicted data. Introduction Two essential criteria that must be met for successful recovery of residual oil by chemical flooding arevery low interfacial tensions between the chemical bank and residual oil and between the chemical bank and drive fluid andsmall surfactant retention losses to reservoir rock. If retention is excessive, interfacial tensions eventually will become high enough to retrap residual oil in the remainder of the reservoir.Previous studies have described several mechanisms responsible for surfactant retention in porous media. These include adsorption, porous media. These include adsorption, precipitation, partitioning into a residual oil phase, precipitation, partitioning into a residual oil phase, and entrapment of immiscible microemulsion phases. Of particular interest is Trushenski's discussion of microemulsion phase trapping as a consequence of surfactant-polymer interaction, and a supporting statement that similar behavior often was observed when microemulsions were diluted with polymer-free brine. Here, we attempt to provide some understanding of this surfactant dilution phenomenon by examining phase behavior as a function of salinity, divalent-ion content, and surfactant concentration. Experimental Procedures Surfactant Systems Two surfactant systems were used in this study. (Specific microemulsion compositions are discussed later.) One system was the 63:37 volumetric mixture of the monoethanol amine salt of dodecylorthoxylene sulfonic acid and tertiary amyl alcohol (MEAC12OXS/TAA) described by Healy et al. The oil component for these microemulsions was a mixture of 90% Isopar M TM and 10% Heavy Aromatic Naptha.(TM)** The brine contained NaCl only. SPEJ P. 183


Energies ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (19) ◽  
pp. 6234
Author(s):  
Xu Jiang ◽  
Ming Liu ◽  
Xingxun Li ◽  
Li Wang ◽  
Shuang Liang ◽  
...  

Surfactants and nanoparticles play crucial roles in controlling the oil-water interfacial phenomenon. The natural oil-wet mineral nanoparticles that exist in crude oil could remarkably affect water-oil interfacial characteristics. Most of recent studies focus on the effect of hydrophilic nanoparticles dispersed in water on the oil-water interfacial phenomenon for the nanoparticle enhanced oil recovery. However, studies of the impact of the oil-wet nanoparticles existed in crude oil on interfacial behaviour are rare. In this study, the impacts of Span 80 surfactant and hydrophobic SiO2 nanoparticles on the crude oil-water interfacial characteristics were studied by measuring the dynamic and equilibrium crude oil-water interfacial tensions. The results show the existence of nanoparticles leading to higher crude oil-water interfacial tensions than those without nanoparticles at low surfactant concentrations below 2000 ppm. At a Span 80 surfactant concentration of 1000 ppm, the increase of interfacial tension caused by nanoparticles is largest, which is around 8.6 mN/m. For high Span 80 surfactant concentrations, the less significant impact of nanoparticles on the crude oil-water interfacial tension is obtained. The effect of nanoparticle concentration on the crude oil-water interfacial tension was also investigated in the existence of surfactant. The data indicates the less significant influence of nanoparticles on the crude oil-water interfacial tension at high nanoparticle concentration in the presence of Span 80 surfactant. This study confirms the influences of nanoparticle-surfactant interaction and competitive surfactant molecule adsorption on the nanoparticles surfaces and the crude oil-water interface.


2012 ◽  
Vol 529 ◽  
pp. 560-563
Author(s):  
Hui Lu ◽  
Sheng Lai Yang ◽  
Yan Bin Zhang ◽  
Li Xie ◽  
Ke Hou Zhou ◽  
...  

In this paper, the main factors that affect the displacement efficiency were experimental studied by means of the physical cylinder model filled with sand, based on the high efficiency of oil displacing water in the process of hydrocarbon accumulation. After eliminating of some factors that affect displacement efficiency, such as viscosity ratio, wettability and reservoir heterogeneity and so on, the research founds that the crude oil unit connectivity, that is continuity of displaced phase, has a significant impact on the displacement efficiency. The experimental results show that the crude oil unit connectivity is more than wettability, and not less than viscosity, as the factors of the impact of displacement efficiency. If the crude oil unit connectivity is serious damaged, even if the wettability of reservoir rocks was changed by improving the viscosity of injected water, its effect of enhanced oil recovery should not be obvious. In fact, this is main reason that the effect of current the EOR method such as polymer flooding, surfactant flooding and stuff was not obvious. It is expected that the research results will be useful in the displacement efficiency of waterflooding that is controlled by the crude oil unit connectivity.


1978 ◽  
Vol 18 (04) ◽  
pp. 242-252 ◽  
Author(s):  
W.H. Wade ◽  
James C. Morgan ◽  
R.S. Schechter ◽  
J.K. Jacobson ◽  
J.L. Salager

Abstract The conditions necessary for optimum low tension and phase behavior at high surfactant concentrations are compared with those required at low surfactant concentrations, where solubilization effects are not usually visible. Major differences in tension behavior between the high and low concentration systems may be observed when the surfactant used contains a broad spectrum of molecular species, or if a higher molecular weight alcohol is present, but not otherwise in the systems studied. We compared the effects of a number of aliphatic alcohols on tension with phase behavior. An explanation of these results, and also of other observed parameter dependences, is proposed in terms of changes in surfactant chemical potential. Surfactant partitioning data is presented that supports this concept. Introduction Taber and Melrose and Brandner established that tertiary oil recovery by an immiscible flooding process should be possible at low capillary process should be possible at low capillary numbers. In practice, the required capillary number, which is a measure of the ratio of viscous to capillary forces governing displacement of trapped oil, may be achieved by lowering the oil/water interfacial tension to about 10(-3) dyne/cm, or less. Subsequent research has identified a number of surfactants that give tensions of this order with crude oils and hydrocarbon equivalents. Interfacial tension studies tended to fall into two groups. Work at low surfactant concentrations, typically 0.7 to 2 g/L, has established that a crude oil may be assigned an equivalent alkane carbon number. Using pure alkanes instead of crude oil has helped the study of system parameters affecting low tension behavior. Important parameters examined include surfactant molecular structure, and electrolyte concentration, surfactant concentration, surfactant molecular weight, and temperature. At higher surfactant concentrations, interfacial tension has been linked to the phase behavior of equilibrated systems. When an aqueous phase containing surfactant (typically 30 g/L), electrolyte, and low molecular weight alcohol is equilibrated with a hydrocarbon, the surfactant may partition largely into the oil phase, into the aqueous phase, or it may be included in a third (middle) phase containing both water and hydrocarbon. Low interfacial tensions occur when the solubilization of the surfactant-free phase (or phases) into the surfactant-containing phase is maximized. Maximum solubilization and minimum tensions have been shown to be associated with the formation of a middle phase. Both the high and low surfactant concentration studies have practical importance because even though a chemical flood starts at high concentration, degradation of the injected surfactant slug will move the system toward lower concentrations. This study investigates the relationship between tension minima found with low concentration systems, and low tensions found with equivalent systems at higher surfactants concentrations, particularly those in which third-phase formation occurs. Many of the systems studied here contain a low molecular weight alcohol, as do most surfactant systems described in the literature or proposed for actual oil recovery. Alcohol originally was added to surfactant systems to help surfactant solubility, but can affect tensions obtained with alkanes, and with refined oil. Few systematic studies of the influence of alcohol on tension behavior exist. Puerto and Gale noted that increasing the alcohol Puerto and Gale noted that increasing the alcohol molecular weight decreases the optimum salinity for maximum solubilization and lowest tensions. The same conclusions were reached by Hsieh and Shah, who also noted that branched alcohols had higher optimum salinities than straight-chain alcohols of the same molecular weight. Jones and Dreher reported equivalent solubilization results with various straight- and branched-chain alcohols. In this study, we fix the salinity of each system and instead vary the molecule; weight of the hydrocarbon phase. SPEJ P. 242


1977 ◽  
Vol 17 (02) ◽  
pp. 122-128 ◽  
Author(s):  
W.H. Wade ◽  
J.C. Morgan ◽  
J.K. Jacobson ◽  
R.S. Schechter

Abstract The interfacial tension of surfactant mixtures with hydrocarbons obeys a simple scaling rule. Many apparently inert surfactants give low tensions when in mixtures; the scaling rule still applies to these mixtures. The influence of surfactant structure and molecular weight on low-tension behavior is examined, and the application of these results to the optimization of surfactant flooding systems is discussed. Introduction It has been shown that the interfacial-tension behavior of a given crude oil with a surfactant solution of the sulfonate type may be modeled by replacing the crude oil with one particular alkane. The number of carbon atoms in the alkane is referred to as the equivalent alkane carbon number (EACN) of the crude oil, and this EACN is independent of the surfactant used (at fixed standard conditions). This equivalency of a crude oil and an alkane is a result of the simple averaging behavior of hydrocarbons when mixed. Any hydrocarbon may be assigned an EACN value. For instance, when homologous series of alkyl benzenes and alkanes are run against the petroleum sulfonate TRS 10-80 at 2 gm/liter of surfactant with 10 gm/liter NaCl present, heptyl benzene and heptane, respectively, give minimum interfacial tensions, a. The EACN of heptyl benzene is 7, since it is equivalent to heptane. A simple averaging rule will give the EACN of a hydrocarbon mixture : (1) where x is the mole fraction of the ith component. Thus, an equimolar mixture of undecane (EACN 11) and heptyl benzene (EACN 7) has an EACN of 9. If a surfactant gives a low (minimum) sigma against nonane (EACN 9), it will also give a low sigma against the above mixture. Eq. 1 implies that a crude oil, which is a multicomponent hydrocarbon mixture, may be assigned an EACN. This has been verified experimentally. For example, Big Muddy field crude oil has an EACN of 8.5. Therefore, any surfactant phase giving a minimum tension against an equimolar mixture of octane and nonane gives a low tension against Big Muddy crude. All crude oils rested to date have EACN's ranging from 6 to 9. For a given surfactant, the alkane of minimum tension (min) may be affected by the electrolyte concentration or type, the temperature, the surfactant concentration, or the presence of a cosurfactant. These system variables may be adjusted until the nmin for a surfactant matches exactly the EACN of a crude oil. For any particular surfactant, many different combinations of variables will give the same n min value; therefore, there are many possible systems, each with n = EACN, available for crude oil recovery. In practice, however, the system variables may be manipulated to a limited extent only. The temperature of an oil field is fixed, and the surfactant concentration is limited by considerations of solubility and expense. The electrolyte concentration and type is partly determined by oilfield conditions and is limited by the effect on surfactant solubility. These limitations mean that many of the surfactants presently available on a large enough scale for use in low-tension flooding will not give minimum tensions in the range required (n of 6 to 9). This paper shows how minimal sigma's in the required range may be found for some of these "off-scale" surfactants when they are used in surfactant mixtures. The hypothesis tested here is that surfactant mixtures average in a manner analogous to the averaging of hydrocarbons in the oil phase. It will be shown that each surfactant component may be assigned an n value and that the alkane of minimum tension of a mixture of surfactants, (n), is then given by (2) where x is now the mole fraction of the ith component of the surfactant mixture. This greatly extends the number of surfactants that may be considered as candidates for use in low interfacial-tension flooding. SPEJ P. 122


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document