Why Bare Demonstratives Need Not Semantically Refer
2012 ◽
Vol 42
(1)
◽
pp. 43-66
◽
Keyword(s):
I-theories of bare demonstratives take the semantic referent of a demonstrative to be determined by an inner state of the utterer. These states are typically taken to be states that constitute having certain referential intentions. E-theories take the referent to be determined by factors external to the utterer. These are typically taken to be criteria like salience, conversational relevance and the like. The issue has recently flared up again in an exchange between Gauker (2008), who defends an E-theory, and Åkerman (2009; 2010), who defends an I-theory.
Keyword(s):
2018 ◽