Psychiatric Interviewing Techniques II. Naturalistic Study: Eliciting Factual Information

1981 ◽  
Vol 138 (4) ◽  
pp. 283-291 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. Cox ◽  
K. Hopkinson ◽  
M. Rutter

SummaryA naturalistic study was undertaken of 36 video and audio taped interviews made by 7 different psychiatric trainees. The interviews studied were those conducted in the ordinary course of clinic work for diagnostic and therapeutic planning purposes by trainees when first seeing the parent or parents of a child newly referred to a psychiatric clinic. It was found that a directive style with specific probes and requests for detailed descriptions was associated with the obtaining of better-quality factual information than that associated with a more free-style approach. Interviewers who talked less and who made more use of open questions and checks tended to have more talkative informants. Double questions were liable to result in ambiguous answers, but multiple-choice questions did not appear to cause distortion and in some circumstances might be helpful.

1981 ◽  
Vol 138 (5) ◽  
pp. 406-415 ◽  
Author(s):  
K. Hopkinson ◽  
A. Cox ◽  
M. Rutter

SummaryA naturalistic study was undertaken of 36 video and audio-taped interviews undertaken by 7 different psychiatric trainees. The interviews studied were those conducted in the ordinary course of clinic work for diagnostic and therapeutic planning purposes by trainees when first seeing the parent or parents of a child newly referred to a psychiatric clinic. It was found that a variety of rather different interview techniques seemed to facilitate emotional expression. These included a low level of interview talk with few interruptions, a high rate of open rather than closed questions, direct requests for feelings, interpretations and expressions of sympathy. The issue of how far these associations reflected causal influences is discussed.


Blood ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 132 (Supplement 1) ◽  
pp. 4752-4752
Author(s):  
Beatrice Manghisi ◽  
Lorenza Maria Borin ◽  
maria Rosaria Monaco ◽  
Raffaele Mantegazza ◽  
Carlo Gambacorti-Passerini

Abstract Introduction The diagnosis of a hematological neoplastic disease (HND) bears a great impact on the patient family, which suffers abrupt changes in living patterns because of prognosis, prolonged hospitalization and therapy related adverse events. Parents often believe that the best way to protect their children from suffering is to avoid communications about the disease, as "they wouldn't understand". Many hospitals offer family support, usually managed by psychologists; we hypothesized that the hematologist can play a key role in this process, being the one who primarily takes care of the patient, possesses the scientific skills necessary to explain the disease and is viewed by the family members as the key player. Since 2010, patients admitted to the Hematology Division at San Gerardo Hospital in Monza - Italy, who have minors in their family can participate in the "Emanuela Project" (see below). Methods The aim of this pilot study is to evaluate the impact of this intervention on children health status as perceived by their parents either affected or unaffected by HND. Ten hospitalized patients with a HND disease diagnosed between November 2017 and May 2018, with at least one child aged 0-18 years were recruited after signing an informed consent. Intervention: children can visit their parents in a dedicated hospital room in the days after diagnosis and an informal talk with a hematologist and a psychologist is organized; the hematologist, using simple images and metaphors (e.g. "flowered garden" to represent the normal bone marrow), explains the illness and answers questions, while the psychologist helps children to express emotions about the situation. A questionnaire, administered 30-60 days after the intervention to all parents, explores their perceptions about changes in each child; itconsists of 18 multiple choice questions and 15 open questions. Data were analyzed with statistical software STATA. Open questions were fully read and interpreted by authors; T-LAB software was used to evaluate relevant recurring words . Results All 10 patients that were offered the intervention consented to it; 9 out of 10 patients have returned their questionnaires by July 2018 Five of them were fathers (55.56%) and 4 mothers (44.44%), with a mean age 50.22+/- 9.19 (SD). Diagnoses were Acute Leukemia (5), Lymphoma (2) and Multiple Myeloma (2). Mean duration of hospital stay was 26.2 days (+/- 12.8 SD) . The study included 16 children, aged 4 to 18 (mean 10 +/- 5 SD). We analyzed 28 questionnaires. Data from multiple choice questions exploring changes in children behavior suggest that, according to both parents there was no substantial worsening in school performance, appetite, sleep patterns (see table 1). These findings suggest that talking to children about the disease didn't traumatize them, and gave some concrete and reassuring answers to unexpressed fears. An interesting finding is that 44% of children increased their need to be in contact with the ill parent, showing a strengthening of relationships inside the family. One relevant finding concerns the possibility to talk about HND inside the family: 93% of parents gave a score of 3 (=often) or 4(=always) to this question. 100% of parents stated that it was never necessary to keep clinic visits or hospital admissions hidden from their children; 80% never had to hide side effects of therapies. All healthy parents and 87.5% of sick ones found that communicating with their children was a correct strategy, and that this intervention by hematologist and psychologist was useful. According to 88% of them, such a difficult task is responsibility of parents and of a specific professional figure, the hematologist. The use of simple images and metaphors helped 85.7% of healthy parents and 62.5% of ill ones to understand the illness better. According to 75% of parents, the intervention also played a key role in improving their relationship with doctors. The T-Lab analysis of recurring words is presented in Tab 2. Conclusions Data indicate that for parent it is important to be supported by their hematologist in the difficult task of explaining their illness to their children. The Emanuela Project allows parents to retain a parental role despite their illness; communication contributes also to increase trust in the medical staff and compliance to physically and emotionally demanding treatments. These data will be compared to those obtained in nearby hospitals who do not offer such a service. Disclosures Gambacorti-Passerini: BMS: Consultancy; Pfizer: Consultancy, Honoraria, Research Funding.


1981 ◽  
Vol 138 (6) ◽  
pp. 456-465 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Rutter ◽  
A. Cox ◽  
S. Egert ◽  
D. Holbrook ◽  
B. Everitt

SummaryThe development and definition of four contrasting interview styles is described. The four styles were designed using different permutations of techniques which, on the basis of an earlier naturalistic study, appeared to be most effective in eliciting either factual information or feelings. A ‘sounding board’ style utilized a minimal activity approach; an ‘active psychotherapy’ style actively sought to explore feelings and to bring out emotional links and meanings; a ‘structured’ style adopted an active cross-questioning approach; and a ‘systematic exploratory’ style aimed to combine a high use of both fact-oriented and feeling-oriented techniques. Quantitative measures based on video-tape and audio-tape analysis showed that two experienced interviewers could be trained to adopt these four very different styles and yet remain feeling and appearing natural. An experimental design to compare the four styles is described.


2021 ◽  
Vol 5 (2) ◽  
pp. 106-113
Author(s):  
Iwan Ridwan Yusup ◽  
Sumiyati Sa'adah ◽  
Milla Listiawati ◽  
Idad Suhada

Online and offline learning will have a different impact on the level of understanding of students about learning materials. In this study the researchers tried to find out how the learning activities of Biology Education students at UIN Sunan Gunung Djati Bandung during the pandemic were related to changes in routine during the pandemic which affected the enthusiasm for learning and understanding of lecture material during the pandemic compared to before the pandemic. This research uses descriptive research method because in its implementation it includes data, analysis and interpretation of the meaning and data obtained. This study uses a questionnaire, the list of questions is structured in the form of multiple-choice questions and open questions (multiple choice questions and open questions). This method is used to obtain data about the effect of changes in the routine of Biology Education students during the pandemic on learning enthusiasm and understanding the material from respondents. Biology education students admit that there have been significant changes in their routine during the pandemic period. These changes have an impact on student learning activities.


1981 ◽  
Vol 138 (4) ◽  
pp. 273-282 ◽  
Author(s):  
M. Rutter ◽  
A. Cox

SummaryAn account is given of the overall strategy and measures used in a three-phase study of styles and techniques employed in the initial diagnostic interviews with the parents of children referred to a child psychiatric clinic. The measures of interview style included interviewer activity and talkativeness, directiveness, types of questions and statements, interventions designed to elicit or to respond to feelings, and non-verbal qualities. The informant's response and the interview ‘outcome’ were assessed through measures of the quantity and quality of factual information obtained, and of the extent of expression of emotional feelings by the informant. Good inter-rater reliability was achieved with most measures. Some difficulties were experienced in achieving comparable thresholds for the recognition of expressed emotions.


Informatica ◽  
2017 ◽  
Vol 28 (4) ◽  
pp. 609-628
Author(s):  
Ali Fahmi ◽  
Cengiz Kahraman

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document