Updraft/Downdraft Constraints for Moist Baroclinic Modes and Their Implications for the Short-Wave Cutoff and Maximum Growth Rate

This paper examines the dynamics of moist baroclinic modes, based on the idealized model of moist baroclinic instability devised by Emanuel et al. These authors found that the finite static stability along the downdraft prevents the explosive short-wave cyclogenesis of the zero stratification limit in the moist problem, and allows only moderate (order 2) changes in the growth rate and short-wave cutoff, even when the moist static stability vanishes. To understand the limiting role of the dry static stability, a constraint is derived in this paper that relates the updraft and downdraft structures. This constraint is based on continuity and implies that a bulk wavenumber (defined in the paper) scales as the relevant deformation radius in each region. Because neutral solutions are separable, the vertical structure can be encapsulated in terms of a single, equivalent wavenumber based on the downdraft width. This allows an interpretation of the results in terms of the equivalent dry mode. As the ratio between moist and dry static stability decreases, the downdraft width takes an increasingly larger fraction of the total wavelength. In the limit of moist neutrality all the wavelength is occupied by the downdraft, so that the short-wave cutoff is halved. The vertical phase tilt makes unstable solutions nonseparable, and prevents defining an equivalent wavenumber in that case. However, the constraint between the bulk wavenumbers still applies. As the moist stability is reduced, the updraft solution becomes more suboptimal; in the limit of moist neutrality, the updraft wavenumber equals the short-wave cutoff. This provides a bound to the maximum growth rate in the moist problem, which is in agreement with the results of Emanuel et al.