The Ecosystem of Detection and Blocklisting of Domain Generation

Malware authors use domain generation algorithms to establish more reliable communication methods that can avoid reactive defender blocklisting techniques. Network defense has sought to supplement blocklists with methods for detecting machine-generated domains. We present a repeatable evaluation and comparison of the available open source detection methods. We designed our evaluation with multiple interrelated aspects, to improve both interpretability and realism. In addition to evaluating detection methods, we assess the impact of the domain generation ecosystem on prior results about the nature of blocklists and how they are maintained. The results of the evaluation of open source detection methods finds all methods are inadequate for practical use. The results of the blocklist impact study finds that generated domains decrease the overlap among blocklists; however, while the effect is large in relative terms, the baseline is so small that the core conclusions of the prior work are sustained. Namely, that blocklist construction is very targeted, context-specific, and as a result blocklists do no overlap much. We recommend that Domain Generation Algorithm detection should also be similarly narrowly targeted to specific algorithms and specific malware families, rather than attempting to create general-purpose detection for machine-generated domains.