Reply — Studies of beaver activity and body temperature: a historical perspective
Bovet claims that Smith et al. (D.W. Smith, R.O. Peterson, T.D. Drummer, and D.S. Sheputis, 1991. Can. J. Zool. 69: 2178–2182) and Dyck and MacArthur (A.P. Dyck and R.A. MacArthur, 1992. Can. J. Zool. 70: 1668–1672) analyzed their data on activity and body temperature of beavers (Castor canadensis) incorrectly because they ignored the likelihood that northern beavers in winter have activity rhythms with periods >24 h. The analysis by Smith et al. was in fact appropriate for demonstrating seasonal changes in body temperature and its correlation with activity. These are important issues because researchers have obtained conflicting results and because seasonal changes in activity and body temperature have implications for colony energetics in the context of food-hoarding behavior and social organization.