A laboratory study of the vulnerability of prey to predation by three aquatic insects
The vulnerability of three different prey (Baetis spp., Ephemerella spp., and Simulium spp.) to predation by Nigronia serricornis (Megaloptera) and Paragnetina media and Agnetina capitata (both Plecoptera) was studied in recirculating Plexiglas chambers. When each prey was tested individually, Simulium was least vulnerable to predation by A. capitata and equally vulnerable with Ephemerella to P. media and N. serricornis. Baetis was the most vulnerable to predacious stoneflies while Baetis and Ephemerella were equally vulnerable to N. serricornis. When prey were tested in mixed assemblages, similar trends in prey vulnerability were seen, except that Ephemerella was more vulnerable than Simulium to P. media and N. serricornis. Our data suggest that Ephemerella is less vulnerable than Baetis to predation by stoneflies; however, they were equally vulnerable to N. serricornis, possibly because of differences in feeding behavior and morphology between stoneflies and N. serricornis. Significantly more Simulium larvae moved to the sides and ceiling plates of the experimental chambers versus the control chambers; this differential movement suggests that the presence of predators may have stimulated escape to an apparently predator-free refuge.