Analysis of Semi-Submersible Under Combined High Waves and Current Conditions Compared With Model Tests

Author(s):  
Limin Yang ◽  
Arne Nestegård ◽  
Erik Falkenberg

Viscous effects on the low-frequency excitation force on column based platforms are significant in extreme waves. The wave drift force as calculated by a zero-current potential flow radiation/diffraction code becomes negligible for such waves. In the present study, the effect of current and viscous contributions on the slowly varying wave forces are adjusted by a formula developed in the Exwave JIP, see e.g. [1], which is validated against model test results. This paper presents numerical predictions of low frequency horizontal motions of a semi-submersible in combined high waves and current condition. In the simulation model, frequency dependent wave drift forces from radiation/diffraction code are modified by the formula. Static current forces and viscous damping are modelled by the drag term in Morison load formula using relative velocity between current and floater and with force coefficients as recommended by DNVGL-RP-C205 [2]. Low frequency surge responses calculated by the simulation model are compared with model tests for waves only and for combined collinear and noncollinear wave and current conditions.

Author(s):  
Kjell Larsen ◽  
Tjerand Vigesdal ◽  
Rune Bjørkli ◽  
Oddgeir Dalane

This paper presents results from extensive small-scale model testing of three semi submersibles together with an overview of damping contributions of low frequency motions. The objectives of the model tests were to verify empirical correction formulas for viscous wave drift forces and to recommend and validate theoretical low frequency damping models. The main parameters of the semis such as displacement, number of columns and diameter of columns were intentionally varied in order to assess the effects on total wave drift forces and corresponding damping. The results show that viscous effects significantly increase the total wave drift forces in extreme sea states. The presence of current increases the effect. As expected, the viscous contribution to wave drift is especially important for semis with slender columns. A revised empirical correction formula for wave drift forces is proposed based on model test results. An overview of the different low frequency damping effects is given. Damping from viscous forces on the hull and damping from the mooring system are the most important sources of damping for the moored semis. A simplified model to calculate mooring system damping is proposed. For accurate prediction of low frequency motions of moored semi submersibles in extreme sea states, a damping level in the range 40–70% of critical damping should be applied for surge and sway when the empirical correction formulas for wave drift forces are applied.


1982 ◽  
Vol 22 (04) ◽  
pp. 563-572
Author(s):  
J.A. Pinkster

Abstract Mean- and low-frequency wave drift forces on moored structures are important with respect to low-frequency motions and peak mooring loads. This paper addresses prediction of these forces on semisubmersible-type structures by use of computations based on three-dimensional (3D) potential theory. The discussion includes a computational method based on direct integration of pressure on the wetted part of the hull of arbitrarily shaped structures. Results of computations of horizontal drift forces on a six-column semisubmersible are compared with model tests in regular and irregular waves. The mean vertical drift forces on a submerged horizontal cylinder obtained from model tests also are compared with results of computations. On the basis of these comparisons, we conclude that wave drift forces on semisubmersible-type structures in conditions of waves without current can be predicted with reasonable accuracy by means of computations based on potential theory. Introduction Stationary vessels floating or submerged in irregular waves are subjected to large first-order wave forces and moments that are linearly proportional to the wave height and that contain the same frequencies as the waves. They also are subjected to small second-order mean- and low- frequency wave forces and moments that are proportional to the square of the wave height. Frequencies of second-order low-frequency components are associated with the frequencies of wave groups occurring in irregular waves.First-order wave forces and moments cause the well-known first-order motions with wave frequencies. First-order wave forces and motions have been investigated for several decades. As a result of these investigations, methods have been developed to predict these forces and moments with reasonable accuracy for many different vessel shapes.For semisubmersibles, which consist of a number of relatively slender elements such as columns, floaters, and bracings, computation methods have been developed to determine the hydrodynamic loads on those elements without accounting for interaction effects between the elements. For the first-order wave loads and motion problem, these computations give accurate results.This paper deals with the mean- and low-frequency second-order wave forces acting on stationary vessels in regular and irregular waves in general and presents a method to predict these forces on the basis of computations.The importance of mean- and low-frequency wave drift forces, from the point of view of motion behavior and mooring loads on vessels moored at point of view of motion behavior and mooring loads on vessels moored at sea, has been recognized only within the last few years. Verhagen and Van Sluijs, Hsu and Blenkarn, and Remery and Hermans showed that the low-frequency components of wave drift forces in irregular waves-even though relatively small in magnitude-can excite large-amplitude low- frequency horizontal motions in moored structures. It was shown for irregular waves that the drift forces contain components with frequencies coinciding with the natural frequencies of the horizontal motions of moored vessels. Combined with minimal damping of low-frequency horizontal motions of moored structures, this leads to large-amplitude resonant behavior of the motions (Fig. 1). Remery and Hermans established that low-frequency components in drift forces are associated with the frequencies of wave groups present in an irregular wave train.The vertical components of the second-order forces sometimes are called suction forces. SPEJ p. 563


Author(s):  
Frans Quadvlieg ◽  
Rink Hallmann ◽  
Greg Hughes ◽  
Rick Harris

Jo Pinkster made the first attempt to estimate 2nd order wave drift forces. In his PhD thesis from 1980, the first practical application of wave feed forward in DP was demonstrated both theoretically and in model tests. Knowledge of the local wave field was used to estimate the 2nd order wave drift forces. The local wave field was converted in wave forces and fed back in the DP system. The use of this knowledge in a DP system should lead to a better position keeping. Since Pinksters’ thesis 30 years ago, this technique has been tried several times with varying success. However, in 2009, the ‘nut was cracked’ and a good success was undoubtedly demonstrated. In 2008–2009, this method has been developed and applied in DP model tests on a ship equipped with azimuthing thrusters. The use of Wave Feed Forward resulted in a reduction of the watch circle by a factor of two. Important for the success of wave feed forward was the filtering of the measured wave signals to predict the wave forces with a limited delay. The performance is demonstrated during model tests in MARIN’s Seakeeping and Manoeuvring Basin at two speeds of 0 knots and 4 knots, uni-directional and multidirectional seas. Besides the application of wave feed forward for a single ship, wave feed forward is used in a side-by-side condition at zero speed and ahead speed. For both speeds, wave feed forward did not provide a significant improvement in DP accuracy. The objective was to make wave feed forward applicable to: zero and forward speed; on a ship alone and on ships sailing side-by-side; in unidirectional and multi-directional waves, with a realistic amount of sensors and as target wave heights, sea state 3 and 4 were envisaged. To measure the local wave height, wave height measurement sensors as well as pressure sensors were used. The pressure sensors can be mounted below the waterline and deliver an accurate estimation for the wave drift forces as well.


Author(s):  
Elin Marita Hermundstad ◽  
Jan Roger Hoff ◽  
Carl Trygve Stansberg ◽  
Rolf Baarholm

Wave-current interaction effects may significantly influence the mean wave drift forces on a structure as well as the motion responses and wave elevation around the structure. Additionally, the drift force may be used to estimate the wave drift damping of a moored structure. A new numerical potential theory code for industry applications (MULDIF) has been recently developed, where the hydrodynamic interaction between waves and current of arbitrary direction with large volume structures is consistently included. The code also handles multiple bodies and finite water depth including wave-current interaction effects. The aim has been to create a robust and easy-to-use practical tool. Initial validation studies against model tests have been conducted. The numerical results show a strong heave-pitch coupling due to the presence of the current. Preliminary results for a semi-submersible show good agreement for the motions provided that the mooring used in the model tests are accounted for. The free surface elevation around the semi-submersible is presented in contour plots.


Author(s):  
Nuno Fonseca ◽  
Carl Trygve Stansberg ◽  
Kjell Larsen ◽  
Rune Bjørkli ◽  
Tjerand Vigesdal ◽  
...  

Model tests have been performed with four mobile offshore drilling units (MODUs) with the aim of identifying wave drift forces and low frequency damping. The MODUs configuration is different, namely on the number and diameter of columns, therefore the sample is representative of many of the existing concepts. The model scale is the same as well as the wave and current conditions. The experimental program includes irregular waves with systematic variations of the significant wave height, wave peak period, current velocity and vessel heading. The test data is post-processed to identify the surge and sway quadratic transfer functions (QTFs) of the slowly varying excitation, together with the linearized low frequency damping. The post-processing applies a nonlinear data analysis technique known as “cross-bi-spectral analysis” to estimate characteristics of second-order (quadratic) responses from the measured motions and undisturbed incident wave elevation. The empirical QTFs are then compared with numerical predictions to conclude on the role of viscous drift and the applicability of Newman’s approximation for calculation of drift forces in irregular waves. Finally, the empirical drift forces, empirical low frequency damping coefficients and low frequency motions statistics are compared for the three MODUs to conclude on the relation between the Semi configuration and the low frequency responses.


Author(s):  
Dara Williams ◽  
Patrick Ashton

As has been noted in industry publications and conferences in the recent past the use of more modern deepwater capable 5th and 6th generation semisubmersible drilling rigs in relatively shallow water applications (when compared to design water depth) is likely to become more commonplace. Water depths of 500m or less will necessitate the use of mooring systems in order to maintain position close to the well centre whilst drilling. For fatigue assessments of moored MODUs, the current industry practice to estimate fatigue damage in the drilling riser and the wellhead, using global riser analysis techniques, is to consider both wave and VIV fatigue effects. Standard wave fatigue analysis considers two key response parameters, firstly the impact of the hydrodynamic loading on the riser joints due to drag forces, inertia and added mass effects, and secondly the effects of vessel motions on the riser system and wellhead loading. Standard practice for wave fatigue analysis is to consider only first order motion effects as described by the vessel RAO (response amplitude operator). However, for a moored MODU low frequency (100s-200s period) vessel response can have a significant impact on the overall vessel motions. The actual response and magnitude of MODU motion will be influenced by the size and displacement of the vessel in addition to the configuration of the mooring system. First order lateral motions for a semisubmersible tend to increase as wave period is increased and therefore at lower periods first order motions can be quite low. However, the opposite can be said of wave drift forces that contribute to second order response. Although the wave drift forces are largest for lower wave periods, these low period drift forces have a significant influence on the resulting long period second order response of a moored MODU. This has important implications for drilling riser and wellhead fatigue analysis as in many cases the critical seastates for fatigue damage are low period seastates with a large number of occurrences. Thus the current global analysis techniques for fatigue calculations may lead to an underestimation of fatigue damage contribution from low period seastates. The purpose of this paper is to present the key conclusions and findings of a study carried out in order to determine the effects of low frequency moored MODU motions on wellhead fatigue. These results are derived from a case study of a moored 6th generation semi-submersible drilling vessel in 500m water depth.


Author(s):  
Carl Trygve Stansberg

Low-frequency pitch motions of a moored semisubmersible in irregular sea states are analyzed. Physical mechanisms and significance to air-gap problems are addressed. Excitation from wave drift and from moorings/risers is primarily considered, Effects from current and wind are also addressed. Related challenges in deepwater model testing of semis with truncated moorings are discussed. Motion and air-gap data from two previously performed model tests are analysed. Catenary moorings in 335m water depth and in 1100m water depth, respectively, are considered. Model scales are 1:55 and 1:150, respectively. Observed slow-drift pitch components are of the same magnitude level as the wave-frequency components. Comparisons to coupled numerical analysis models are made. Wave drift moment coefficients calibrated empirically according to experiments were used, since the original coefficients gave too low results. The final comparisons show good agreement for the 1:55 case. For the 1:150 case, fairly good agreement is found, but some deviations are observed and believed to be due to poorer wave repeatablity. Tests with truncated moorings at half of the two actual depths were also included, for a check of methods for deepwater model tests performed at reduced depths and combine with numerical analysis (hybrid verification). The importance of proper experimental reproduction at reduced depths, of full-depth pitch and air-gap, is addressed. The results show that with the actual truncation designs, reasonable agreements are obtained, but use of the scale 1:150 seems to give too large uncertainties due to the poorer wave repeatability.


Author(s):  
Limin Yang ◽  
Erik Falkenberg ◽  
Arne Nestegård ◽  
Jørn Birknes-Berg

Standard analysis models applied for motions of moored floaters are based on potential flow perturbation methods with wave frequency response governed by first order wave forces and low-frequency response governed by second-order difference frequency wave forces. These models have been shown to have limitations in extreme sea states where nonlinear wave excitation and viscous drag forces above still water level may dominate. This effect is particularly visible for the low frequency excitation since the potential flow contribution goes to zero for long waves. In the present study non-linear wave excitation and viscous drag contributions on a semi-submersible is modelled by Morison’s load formula since the columns and pontoons are slender elements. A numerical simulation model is developed using SIMO [6], in which viscous forces and damping are included by the drag term of Morison equation and with drag coefficients recommended from DNV-RP-C205 [1]. Low frequency surge responses calculated by the combined potential flow drift forces and viscous drag from Morison load model are compared with model tests for waves only and for combined wave and current conditions. A simplified formula for current and viscous effects on wave drift force, generalized to non-collinear conditions is presented and compared with model test results.


Author(s):  
Alessio Pistidda ◽  
Harald Ottens ◽  
Richard Zoontjes

During offshore installation operations, floating bodies are often moored using soft mooring which are designed to withstand the environmental forces. Large amplitude motions often occur due to excitation by slowly varying wind and wave drift forces. To analyze these motions the dynamic system has to be accurately described, which includes an estimation of the added mass and damping coefficients. In general, the added mass can be accurately calculated with traditional potential theory. However for the damping this method is not adequate because viscous effects play an important role. Generally these data are obtained using model tests. This paper validates the CFD methodology as an alternative to model tests to evaluate the viscous damping. The aim is to define a standard procedure to derive viscous damping coefficients for surge, sway and yaw motion of floating bodies. To estimate viscous damping in CFD, a 3D model of the launch and float-over barge H-851 was used. For this barge, model test data is available which could be compared with the results of the CFD analysis. For the simulations, the commercial package STAR-CCM+ with the implicit unsteady solver for Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations was used. The turbulence model implemented was the k-Omega-SST. Numerical errors have been assessed performing sensitivity analysis on time step and grid size. Damping has been investigated by performing decay simulations as in the model tests, taking the effect of coupling among all motions into account. The P-Q fitting method has been used to determine the linear and quadratic component of the damping. Numerical results are validated with those obtained from the towing tank. Results show that CFD is an adequate tool to estimate the low frequency damping in terms of equivalent damping. More investigations are required to determine the linear and quadratic component.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document