Influence of Structural Compliance and Slope Angle on Ice Loads and Dynamic Response of Conical Structures

2015 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gesa Ziemer ◽  
Karl-Ulrich Evers ◽  
Christian Voosen
Keyword(s):  
Natural Frequency ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Slope Angle ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Offshore Wind Turbine ◽  
Worst Case ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Conical Structures

Model tests in ice have been conducted at the Large Ice Basin of HSVA with cylindrical and conical, compliant structures exposed to drifting level ice to investigate the influence of slope and compliance on the ice load and its breaking frequency. Main goal of the test campaign was to study the importance of structural feedback during ice-cone interaction. This is a major issue e.g. for numerical simulation of offshore structures during design phase. Four shapes were tested: 50°, 60°, 80° and 90° slope angle. The cylinder was tested in order to define the worst case scenario regarding magnitude of ice load and severity of ice-induced vibrations. Stiffness and natural frequency of the structure were chosen similar to typical values for offshore wind turbine support structures. All shapes were tested both in a compliant and fixed configuration. The breaking frequency was found to be more pronounced for the lower slope angles where the ice failed in flexural failure only, while a transition to crushing failure as observed on a cylindrical structure takes place at 80° cone angle already. This results in significantly higher ice loads on the 80° cone than on those with lower angles, but a reduced risk of severe ice-structure interaction due to the unsteady nature of the mixed mode breaking process. Although the breaking frequency is rather constant e.g. during ice impact on the 60° cone, it was not possible during the model tests to match the ice drift speed and the dynamics of the structure in a way that causes resonance. However, model test results prove that there is a risk of conical structures with low natural frequencies and low stiffness in ice plane being excited by periodic ice failure in their natural frequency, thus response amplification may take place and pose a risk to the structural integrity of conical offshore structures exposed to sea ice. This paper presents the model test setup, analysis of the results, and general findings.

Velocity Effects on Conical Structure Ice Loads

2002 ◽  
Author(s):  
Dmitri G. Matskevitch
Keyword(s):  
Model Tests ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Empirical Correction ◽  
Conical Structure ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Ice Velocity ◽  
Velocity Effect ◽  
Ice Failure ◽  
Bending Failure ◽  
Conical Structures

Existing design codes and most methods for ice load calculation for conical structures do not take velocity effects into account. They were developed as an upper bound estimate for the load from slow moving ice which fails in bending against the cone. Velocity effects can be ignored when the structure is designed for an area with slow ice movement, for example, the nearshore Beaufort Sea. Sakhalin structures will be exposed to ice moving at velocities up to about 1.5 m/sec. Model tests show that quasi-static methods may underestimate the ice load on a steep cone when the interaction velocity is that high. The present paper summarizes results of published model tests with conical structures that show a velocity effect. An empirical correction factor to the Ralston method is developed to account for the increase in cone load with ice velocity. The paper also discusses velocity effects on ice failure length and possible transition from bending failure to an alternative failure mode when the ice velocity is high.

A Comparison of Ice Loads From Level Ice and Ice Ridges on Sloping Offshore Structures Calculated in Accordance With Different International and National Standards

2006 ◽  
Author(s):  
Per Kristian Bruun ◽  
Ove Tobias Gudmestad
Keyword(s):  
Barents Sea ◽  
Slope Angle ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Interaction Process ◽  
International Standards ◽  
Structure Interaction ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Level Ice

Existing national and international standards for determination of level ice and ice ridge loads on sloping offshore structures recommend different methods for the analysis. The objective of this paper is to review the codes and standards recommendations regarding ice-sloping structures interaction process and highlight the differences between them. Development of offshore hydrocarbon fields in the Eastern Barents Sea is foreseen to take place in the near future while developments already take place in the Pechora Sea and offshore Sakhalin as well as in the Northern Caspian Sea. One of the most difficult issues facing the designer of offshore structures for these areas is how to design for loads from level ice and ice ridges. The ice load considerations will have a major effect on the form and cost of these structures. It is known that different designers use very different ice load estimates (Shkhinek et al., 1994). The standards recommend different methods for determination of the global ice loads on both cone-shaped and sloping rectangular structures. For determination of the global ice loads on these types of structures, it is obvious that the ice-structure interaction process must be identified. Rubble effects must be included in the analysis. The ice-structure interaction process for these geometries depends on many factors, such as; the ice thickness, ice strength, ice-structure friction coefficient, ice velocity, width of the structure and slope angle of the structure. The methods for determination of ice loads recommended by the different standards are very much influenced by local ice conditions and the parameters listed above are given different importance in the different standards. The differences in loads calculated by using the different standards and their validity for the ice-structure interaction process have been investigated and example calculations are presented to show these differences. It is thought that the paper may be of interest for those preparing the new ISO standard (ISO 19906) on Arctic Offshore Structures.

Model Tests of a Spar-Type Floating Wind Turbine Under Wind/Wave Loads

2015 ◽  
Author(s):  
Fei Duan ◽  
Zhiqiang Hu ◽  
Jin Wang
Keyword(s):  
Wind Turbine ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Wind Wave ◽  
Wave Model ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Wave Loads ◽  
Scaled Model ◽  
Floating Wind Turbine ◽  
Wave Effects

Wind power has great potential because of its clean and renewable production compared to the traditional power. Most of the present researches for floating wind turbine rely on the hydro-aero-elastic-servo simulation codes and have not been exhaustively validated yet. Thus, model tests are needed and make sense for its high credibility to master the kinetic characters of floating offshore structures. The characters of kinetic responses of the spar-type wind turbine are investigated through model test research technique. This paper describes the methodology for wind/wave model test that carried out at Deepwater Offshore Basin in Shanghai Jiao Tong University at a scale of 1:50. A Spar-type floater was selected to support the wind turbine in this test and the model blade was geometrically scaled down from the original NREL 5 MW reference wind turbine blade. The detail of the scaled model of wind turbine and the floating supporter, the test set-up configuration, the mooring system, the high-quality wind generator that can create required homogeneous and low turbulence wind, and the instrumentations to capture loads, accelerations and 6 DOF motions are described in detail, respectively. The isolated wind/wave effects and the integrated wind-wave effects on the floating wind turbine are analyzed, according to the test results.

A Reliability-Based Method for Determining Design Ice Loads on Offshore Structures

2002 ◽  
Author(s):  
X. Wu ◽  
A. T. Wang ◽  
C. E. Heuer ◽  
T. D. Ralston ◽  
G. F. Davenport ◽  
...  
Keyword(s):  
Rational Design ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Type I ◽  
Type Ii ◽  
General Applicability ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Research Company ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Offshore Development ◽  
Systematic Framework

This paper describes a reliability-based methodology that has been developed at ExxonMobil Upstream Research Company (URC) for determining rational design ice loads on offshore structures. The URC methodology provides a systematic framework to account for Type I (aleatory) and Type II (epistemic) uncertainties in assessing global probabilistic ice hazards. Specifically, a logic-tree based approach is developed to model Type II uncertainties in the assessment of ice hazards. Although the method has general applicability, the present work considers a wide, vertical-sided, gravity-based structure (GBS) in a dynamic, annual ice environment. Both FORM/SORM methods and Monte Carlo simulation are used in the analyses. Results obtained from this reliability-based approach indicate that the modeling of Type II uncertainties plays a significant role in quantifying the ice hazards for determining the design ice load. Further, this effort may potentially reduce over-conservatism in typical deterministic ice load calculations. The probabilistic methodology developed in this study has broad applicability and can provide a rational framework for calculating design ice loads on other types of structures for arctic offshore development.

Methodology to Evaluate Sea Ice Loads for Seasonal Operations

2015 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jan Thijssen ◽  
Mark Fuglem
Keyword(s):  
Sea Ice ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Ice Thickness ◽  
Safety Level ◽  
Site Specific ◽  
Design Load ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Ice Conditions ◽  
Design Loads ◽  
Ice Loads

Offshore structures designed for operation in regions where sea ice is present will include a sea ice load component in their environmental loading assessment. Typically ice loads of interest are for 10−2, 10−3 or 10−4 annual probability of exceedance (APE) levels, with appropriate factoring to the required safety level. The ISO 19906 standard recommends methods to determine global sea ice loads on vertical structures, where crushing is the predominant failure mode. Fitted coefficients are proposed for both Arctic and Sub-Arctic (e.g. Baltic) conditions. With the extreme ice thickness expected at the site of interest, an annual global sea ice load can be derived deterministically. Although the simplicity of the proposed relation provides quick design load estimates, it lacks accuracy because the only dependencies are structure width, ice thickness and provided coefficients; no consideration is given to site-specific sea ice conditions and the corresponding exposure. Additionally, no term is provided for including ice management in the design load basis. This paper presents a probabilistic methodology to modify the deterministic ISO 19906 relations for determining global and local first-year sea ice loads on vertical structures. The presented methodology is based on the same ice pressure data as presented in ISO 19906, but accounts better for the influence of ice exposure, ice management and site-specific sea ice data. This is especially beneficial for ice load analyses of seasonal operations where exposure to sea ice is limited, and only thinner ice is encountered. Sea ice chart data can provide site-specific model inputs such as ice thickness estimates and partial concentrations, from which corresponding global load exceedance curves are generated. Example scenarios show dependencies of design loads on season length, structural geometry and sea ice conditions. Example results are also provided, showing dependency of design loads on the number of operation days after freeze-up, providing useful information for extending the drilling season of MODUs after freeze-up occurs.

Benchmark Study Between CFD and Model Tests on a Semi-Submersible Crane Vessel

2009 ◽  
Author(s):  
Harald Ottens ◽  
Radboud van Dijk ◽  
Geert Meskers
Keyword(s):  
Test Data ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Lessons Learned ◽  
Data Sets ◽  
General Acceptance ◽  
Heavy Lift ◽  
Semi Empirical ◽  
Proven Method

Accurate assessment of current loads on offshore vessels is required to determine operability of heavy lift and pipe lay operations. Whereas in the past only semi-empirical methods or model tests were suitable to obtain these data, CFD has recently become available as engineering tool to assess current loads on offshore structures. CFD has the potential to assess current loads more flexible in a numerical manner. Although the application of CFD has proven its value in assessment of ships resistance and VIV calculations, CFD is still not yet a fully proven method to calculate the current loads on offshore structures. Therefore validation of the results is further required to reach general acceptance of this method for offshore applications. HMC took the initiative to compare and validate CFD results with its model test data of current loads on one of its semi-submersible crane vessels. In this paper a comparison of CFD results with model test data of the current loads of a semi-submersible crane vessel is presented. The CFD calculations are performed as blind computations, so the model tests results were unknown. Afterwards the CFD results are compared with the results of the model tests. Based on both data sets lessons learned are addressed to improve the CFD computations as well as practical aspects and limitations of current load model testing. Furthermore, the possibilities to use CFD to scale the results of the model tests to full scale are explored. Based on this comparison CFD appears to be a complementary, flexible and reliable tool in assessing the current loads on mission critical vessel operations.

Results From Model Testing of Ice Protection Piles in Shallow Water

2006 ◽  
Author(s):  
Arne Gu¨rtner ◽  
Joachim Berger
Keyword(s):  
Model Test ◽  
Oil And Gas ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Full Scale ◽  
Offshore Structure ◽  
Oil And Gas Fields ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Drifting Ice ◽  
Ice Model Test ◽  
Gas Fields

The development of oil and gas fields in shallow icy waters, for instance in the Northern Caspian Sea, have increased the awareness of protecting offshore structures by means of ice barriers from the impacts of drifting ice. Protection could be provided by Ice Protection Piles (IPPs), installed in close vicinity to the offshore structure to be protected. Piles then take the main loads from the drifting ice by pre-fracturing the advancing ice sheet. Hence, the partly shielded offshore structure could be designed according to significant lower global design ice loads. In this regard, various configurations of pile arrangements have been model tested during the MATRA-OSE research project in the Ice Model Test Basin of the Hamburg Sip Model Basin (HSVA). The main objective was to analyse the behaviour of ice interactions with the protection piles together with the establishment of design ice loads on an individual pile within the pile arrangement. The pile to pile distances within each arrangement were varied from 2 to 8 times the pile diameter for both, vertical and inclined (30° to the horizontal) pile arrangements. Two test runs with 0.1 m and 0.5 m thick ice (full scale values) were conducted respectively. The full scale water depth was 4 m. Based on the model test observations, it was found that the rubble generation increases with decreasing pile to pile distances. Inclined piles were capable to produce more rubble than vertical piles and considerable lower ice loads were measured on inclined arrangements compared to vertical arrangements. As initial rubble has formed in front of the arrangements, the rubble effect accelerated considerable. Subsequent to the build-up of rubble accumulations, no effect of the pile inclination on the exerted ice loads could be observed. If piles are used as ice barriers, the distance between the piles should be less than 4D for inclined piles and 6D for vertical piles to allow sufficient rubble generation. Larger distances only generated significant ice rubble after initial grounding of the ice had occurred.

scholarly journals A Simulation of Non-Simultaneous Ice Crushing Force for Wind Turbine Towers with Large Slopes

Energies ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 12 (13) ◽  
pp. 2608 ◽  
Author(s):  
Li Zhou ◽  
Shifeng Ding ◽  
Ming Song ◽  
Junliang Gao ◽  
Wei Shi
Keyword(s):  
Numerical Model ◽  
Wind Turbine ◽  
Ice Sheet ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Offshore Wind ◽  
Offshore Wind Turbine ◽  
Foundation Design ◽  
Cold Regions ◽  
Crushing Force ◽  
Ice Loads

When the offshore wind energy industry attempts to develop in cold regions, ice load becomes the main technological challenge for offshore wind turbine foundation design. Dynamic ice loads acting on wind turbine foundations should be calculated in a reasonable way. The scope of this study is to present a numerical model that considers the non-simultaneous ice crushing failure acting on the vertical structure of a wind turbine’s foundation. The local ice crushing force at the contact surface between the ice sheet and structure is calculated. The boundary of the ice sheet is updated at each time step based on the indentation length of the ice sheet according to its structure. Ice loads are validated against two model tests with three different structure models developed by other researchers. The time series of the ice forces derived from the simulation and model tests are compared. The proposed numerical model can capture the main trends of ice–wind turbine foundation interaction. The simulation results agree well with measured data from the model tests in terms of maximum ice force, which is a key factor for wind turbine design. The proposed model will be helpful for assisting the initial design of wind turbine foundations in cold regions.

scholarly journals Experimental and Numerical Analysis of a 10 MW Floating Offshore Wind Turbine in Regular Waves

Energies ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 13 (10) ◽  
pp. 2608
Author(s):  
Hyeonjeong Ahn ◽  
Hyunkyoung Shin
Keyword(s):  
Wind Turbine ◽  
Model Test ◽  
Model Tests ◽  
Offshore Wind ◽  
East Sea ◽  
Irregular Waves ◽  
Offshore Wind Turbine ◽  
Regular Waves ◽  
Floating Offshore Wind Turbine ◽  
Floating Offshore Wind Turbines

Floating offshore wind turbines (FOWTs) experience fluctuations in their platforms, owing to the various wave and wind conditions. These fluctuations not only decrease the output of the wind power generation system, but also increase the fatigue load of the structure and various equipment mounted on it. Therefore, when designing FOWTs, efficient performance with respect to waves and other external conditions must be ensured. In this study, a model test was performed with a 10 MW floating offshore wind turbine. The model test was performed by scaling down a 10 MW FOWT model that was designed with reference to a 5 MW wind turbine and a semisubmersible platform by the National Renewable Energy Laboratory and the DeepCwind project. A scale ratio of 1:90 was used for the model test. The depth of the East Sea was considered as 144 m and, to match the water depth with the geometric similarity of mooring lines, mooring tables were installed. The load cases used in the model test are combined environmental conditions, which are combined uniform wind, regular waves and uniform current. Especially, Model tests with regular waves are especially necessary, because irregular waves are superpositions of regular waves with various periods. Therefore, this study aimed to understand the characteristics of the FOWTs caused by regular waves of various periods. Furthermore, in this model test, the effect of current was investigated using the current data of the East Sea. The results obtained through the model tests were the response amplitude operator (RAO) and the effective RAO for a six degrees-of-freedom motion. The results obtained from the model tests were compared with those obtained using the numerical simulation. The purpose of this paper is to predict the response of the entire system observed in model tests through simulation.

Review of Ice Load Standards and Comparison With Measurements

2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Leon Kellner ◽  
Hauke Herrnring ◽  
Michael Ring
Keyword(s):  
Sea Ice ◽  
Offshore Structures ◽  
Classification Rules ◽  
Empirical Formulas ◽  
Ice Load ◽  
Ice Coverage ◽  
Ice Loads ◽  
Full Scale Tests ◽  
The Given

Sea ice can interact with offshore structures in regions with at least seasonal ice coverage. Therefore the prediction of ice loads on offshore structures is required by many standards or classification rules and guidelines. In order to do this, empirical formulas are often prescribed. These are based on assumptions in combination with model or full scale tests. Yet there are very few publications where the results of the formulas are actually compared to measurements. A case study is made for ice loads on the Norströmsgrund lighthouse. First of all current empirical formulas given by standards bodies or classification societies are reviewed with focus on applicability. Secondly, the ice loads predicted by the empirical formulas are compared to measurements. It was found that for the given case most methods significantly overestimate the load. The applicability of some methods is disputable.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document