Dynamic Compression of Rigid and Flexible Risers: Part II — Comparison of Theoretical and Experimental Results
In a previous paper, experimental results on the dynamic compression of rigid (steel catenary) and flexible risers were presented. Tests considered different combinations of amplitude and frequencies of top motion and distinct current velocities. In this paper, dynamic tension estimations obtained through finite element analysis and analytical formulation are compared to the experimental results. Tension amplitude and critical compression load values are evaluated and compared both for the steel catenary (SCR) and flexible models. Comparisons have shown, in general, a fair agreement between theory and experiments, reassuring the reliability of numerical models. The results also demonstrate that the analytical formulation applied provides reasonable predictions of maximum tension loads and is able to cope well with the variation of critical load with the frequency of motion.