Effect of Unsteadiness on the Performance of a Transonic Centrifugal Compressor Stage

2009 ◽  
Vol 131 (4) ◽  
Author(s):  
Isabelle Trébinjac ◽  
Pascale Kulisa ◽  
Nicolas Bulot ◽  
Nicolas Rochuon

Numerical and experimental investigations were conducted in a transonic centrifugal compressor stage composed of a backswept splittered unshrouded impeller and a vaned diffuser. The characteristic curves of the compressor stage resulting from the unsteady simulations and the experiments show a good agreement over the whole operating range. On the contrary, the total pressure ratio resulting from the steady simulations is clearly overestimated. A detailed analysis of the flow field at design operating point led to identify the physical mechanisms involved in the blade row interaction that underlie the observed shift in performance. Attention was focused on the deformation in shape of the vane bow shock wave due its interaction with the jet and wake flow structure emerging from the impeller. An analytical model is proposed to quantify the time-averaged effects of the associated entropy increase. The model is based on the calculation of the losses across a shock wave at various inlet Mach numbers corresponding to the moving of the jet and wake flow in front of the shock wave. The model was applied to the compressor stage performance calculated with the steady simulations. The resulting curve of the overall pressure ratio as a function of the mass flow is clearly shifted toward the unsteady results. The model, in particular, enhances the prediction of the choked mass flow.

Author(s):  
Isabelle Tre´binjac ◽  
Pascale Kulisa ◽  
Nicolas Bulot ◽  
Nicolas Rochuon

Numerical and experimental investigations were conducted in a transonic centrifugal compressor stage composed of a backswept splittered unshrouded impeller and a vaned diffuser. The characteristic curves of the compressor stage resulting from the unsteady simulations and the experiments show a good agreement over the whole operating range. On the contrary, the total pressure ratio resulting from the steady simulations is clearly overestimated. A detailed analysis of the flow field at design operating point led to identify the physical mechanisms involved in the blade row interaction that underlie the observed shift in performance. Attention was focused on the deformation in shape of the vane bow shock wave due its interaction with the jet and wake flow structure emerging from the impeller. An analytical model is proposed to quantify the time-averaged effects of the associated entropy increase. The model is based on the calculation of the losses across a shock wave at various inlet Mach numbers corresponding to the moving of the jet and wake flow in front of the shock wave. The model was applied to the compressor stage performance calculated with the steady simulations. The resulting curve of the overall pressure ratio as a function of the mass flow is clearly shifted towards the unsteady results. The model in particular enhances the prediction of the choked mass flow.


Author(s):  
Isabelle Tre´binjac ◽  
Nicolas Bulot ◽  
Xavier Ottavy ◽  
Nicolas Buffaz

Numerical and experimental investigations were conducted in a transonic centrifugal compressor stage composed of a backswept splittered unshrouded impeller and a vaned diffuser. Unsteady 3D simulations were performed with the code elsA that solves the turbulent averaged Navier-Stokes equations, at three operating points: choked flow, peak efficiency and near surge. Unsteady pressure measurements up to 150 kHz were carried out in the entry zone of the vaned diffuser (in the vaneless space and in the semi-vaneless space) when the compressor came into surge. These static pressure sensors were mounted on the shroud enwall. The paper focuses on the vaneless and semi-vaneless space where the surge originates. A detailed analysis of the flow pattern coming from the unsteady computations from choked flow towards surge led to identify the physical mechanisms involved in the surge inception. It is shown that, when approaching surge, the flow is destabilized by a severe modification of the shock system in the vaned diffuser inlet. The first perturbation is acquired from the transducer located just upstream of the shock foot (i.e. on the vane suction side surface), indicating a movement of the shock towards the vaneless space. This perturbation travels upstream and leads to the strongest short-wavelength perturbation acquired from the transducer located just upstream of the vane leading edge. This strongest short-wavelength perturbation which level may reach almost four times the mean exit pressure value triggers the full scale instability.


Author(s):  
T. Ch. Siva Reddy ◽  
G. V. Ramana Murty ◽  
Prasad Mukkavilli ◽  
D. N. Reddy

Numerical simulation of impeller and low solidity vaned diffuser (LSD) of a centrifugal compressor stage is performed individually using CFX- BladeGen and BladeGenPlus codes. The tip mach number for the chosen study was 0.35. The same configuration was used for experimental investigation for a comparative study. The LSD vane is formed using standard NACA profile with marginal modification at trailing edge. The performance parameters obtained form numerical studies at the exit of impeller and the diffuser have been compared with the corresponding experimental data. These parameters are pressure ratio, polytropic efficiency and flow angle at the impeller exit where as the parameters those have been compared at the exit of diffuser are the static pressure recovery coefficient and the exit flow angle. In addition, the numerical prediction of the blade loading in terms of blade surface pressure distribution on LSD vane has been compared with the corresponding experimental results. Static pressure recovery coefficient and flow angle at diffuser exit is seen to match closely at higher flows. The difference at lower flows could be due to the effect of interaction between impeller and diffuser combinations, as the numerical analysis was done separately for impeller and diffuser and the effect of impeller diffuser interaction was not considered.


Author(s):  
Chaolei Zhang ◽  
Qinghua Deng ◽  
Zhenping Feng

This paper describes the aerodynamic redesign and optimization of a typical single stage centrifugal compressor, in which the total pressure ratio was improved from the original 4.0 to final 5.0 with the restrictions of keeping the impeller tip diameter, the design rotational speed and the design mass flow rate unchanged. Firstly the backsweep angle and the outlet blade height of the impeller were adjusted and the vaned diffuser was redesigned. Then a sensitivity analysis of the aerodynamic performance correlated to the primary redesign centrifugal compressor stage with respect to the chosen redesign variables was conducted, according to the parameterized results of the impeller and the vaned diffuser. Secondly the impeller and the vaned diffuser were optimized respectively under the stage environment at the design operation condition to improve the stage isentropic efficiency by using a global optimization method which coupled Evolutionary Algorithm (EA) and Artificial Neural Network (ANN), provided by the commercial software NUMECA DESIGN-3D. Subsequently the detailed performance maps of the centrifugal compressor stage corresponding to the primary redesign configuration and the optimum configuration were presented by Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) simulation. Finally the flow fields correlated to the centrifugal compressor configurations before and after optimization at the design operation condition were also compared and analyzed in detail. As a result the design target was achieved after the primary redesign, as a 2.7% gain in stage efficiency and a 3.6% increase in stage pressure ratio were obtained when compared with the primary redesign configuration after optimization. Moreover, the aerodynamic performance of the optimum configuration at the off-design operation conditions was also improved.


Author(s):  
Kishore Ramakrishnan ◽  
Simon K. Richards ◽  
Franc¸ois Moyroud ◽  
Vittorio Michelassi

Previous experimental and CFD investigation of a GE Oil and Gas centrifugal compressor stage with a vaneless diffuser revealed a complex excitation mechanism caused by an aero-acoustic interaction between three blade rows. In stages with vaned diffusers, additional sources of aeromechanical excitation on the impeller can be expected. This unsteady CFD investigation is a follow-up from the previous vaneless diffuser study to identify any additional sources of excitation that arise in the presence of a vaned diffuser in preparation for aeromechanic tests to be conducted later. The study confirms that excitation from impeller-diffuser interaction generated acoustic modes can dominate the potential field excitation from the diffuser vanes. In addition, a significant aero-acoustic excitation to the impeller at a vane pass frequency corresponding to the sum of the vane counts in the two downstream vane rows is observed, and its origination is discussed. The latter excitation is different from that observed in the vaneless diffuser stage where the vane pass frequency observed by the impeller corresponds to the sum of the vane counts in the upstream and downstream vane rows.


Author(s):  
Yangwei Liu ◽  
Baojie Liu ◽  
Lipeng Lu

In this paper, unsteady impeller-diffuser interaction in a transonic centrifugal compressor stage, which is composed of an impeller with splitter blade and a vaned diffuser, was studied numerically. The unsteady interaction has a significant impact on the time-averaged flow, which are presented by the so-called deterministic correlations in the average-passage equation system (APES) proposed by Adamczyk. Both steady and unsteady simulations were carried out at the design and off-design conditions. Results from the steady and unsteady simulations were compared to highlight the importance of the unsteady interactions and to help assess the shortcomings of simple mixing-plane methods. The comparisons indicate that the unsteady interactions should be considered in the simulations since the differences between the time averaged unsteady results and steady simulation results are significant especially at off-design conditions. Then the interactions between impeller and diffuser were studied in detail to advance the understanding of the flow physics involved. The results show that the impeller/diffuser interaction can affect a range of 30% impeller chord from impeller trailing edge on impeller performance, while whole chord length on diffuser performance. The potential effects of the diffuser cause an unsteady pressure disturbance at the impeller exit, leading to the unsteadiness of impeller load, tip leakage flow and losses. While the unsteadiness of impeller exit flow cause period varieties of inlet flow conditions for the diffuser and have large impacts on diffuser performance. Based on the unsteady results, deterministic correlations in the APES framework were computed and analyzed in order to reveal some shortcomings of present deterministic correlations models and to make some contributions to the modeling development. The distribution characteristics of deterministic correlations were studied. The study indicates that the deterministic correlations in the impeller and diffuser have the similar magnitudes, and that the correlations in the passages have large gradients in circumferential direction and decrease rapidly in flow direction especially in the vaneless space. The deterministic correlations at the impeller/diffuser interface were compared with their spatial correlations using the framework of the deterministic decomposition. The comparisons show that the spatial correlations have some discrepancies with the total deterministic correlations at the impeller/diffuser interface.


Author(s):  
I Trébinjac ◽  
N Bulot ◽  
N Buffaz

Numerical and experimental investigations were conducted in a transonic centrifugal compressor stage composed of a backswept splittered unshrouded impeller and a vaned diffuser. Unsteady three-dimensional simulations were performed with the code elsA that solves the turbulent-averaged Navier–Stokes equations, at three operating points: choked flow, peak efficiency, and near surge. Numerical results were validated with experimental data coming from laser Doppler anemometry and unsteady pressure measurements. This article focuses on the change in flow structures when the operating point moves from choke to surge. The main changes in the impeller consist in an enlargement of the wake (of the jet-wake flow structure) and an increase in the exit time-averaged flow angle. Consequently, in the diffuser passage, the main flow trajectory moves towards the vane pressure side, and the boundary layer separation transfers from pressure side to suction side. The interaction between the vane bow shock wave and the impeller blade leads to pressure waves α+, which propagate in the diffuser passage. These pressure waves generate alternately opposite and favourable pressure gradients, which drive the boundary layers to periodic separation. From choke to surge, the intensity of the pressure waves α+ increases. The interaction also leads to subsonic pockets Г, which are torn out from the vane-leading edge bow shock and swept along the vane suction side. The induced change in the shock shape and location combined with the severe hub/suction side corner separation are thought to be at the origin of the surge inception.


2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (15) ◽  
pp. 6980
Author(s):  
Shuai Li ◽  
Yan Liu ◽  
Hongkun Li ◽  
Mohammad Omidi

The influence of different diffuser configurations on the flow stability and aerodynamic performance of a centrifugal compressor stage with a mass flow coefficient of 0.196 is numerically investigated. Research results show that the performance of a traditional full-height vaned diffuser (TVD) deteriorates rapidly, and a shroud-side partial vaned diffuser (SVD) displays better adaptability in off-design conditions. SVD can suppress the development of vortices generating at the diffuser leading-edge. Therefore, it can reduce the flow loss inside the stage and improve the flow stability of the stage at low mass flow rates. The unsteady analysis for TVD and SVD shows that the stall cell propagates at about 35.7% of impeller rotational speed in the semi-vaneless space and diffuser passages. Furthermore, the internal flow in TVD and SVD is studied by employing the proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) methods. The flow loss and instability mechanism in the stage are consequently revealed more comprehensively.


2013 ◽  
Vol 30 (2) ◽  
pp. 113-121 ◽  
Author(s):  
L. H. Jawad ◽  
S. Abdullah ◽  
R. Zulkifli ◽  
W. M. F. W. Mahmood

ABSTRACTThis paper is a numerical simulation that was made in the three-dimensional flow, carried out in a modified centrifugal compressor, having vaned diffuser stage, used as an auto-motive turbo charger. Moreover, the performance of the centrifugal compressor was dependent on the proper matching between compressor impeller and vaned diffuser, influencing significantly surge and the efficiency of centrifugal compressor stages. In addition, a modified compressor impeller, coupled with vane and vaneless diffuser, has been found to have similar internal flow patterns for both the vaneless and vaned diffuser design. The vaned diffuser effect has been paid particular attention in terms of better analysis where the diffuser was designed for high sub-sonic inlet conditions. Another aim of this research was to study and simulate the effect of vaned diffuser on the performance of a centrifugal compressor. The simulation was undertaken by using a commercial software, the so-called ANSYS CFX, to predict numerically the performance in terms of pressure ratio, poly tropic efficiency and mass flow rate for the centrifugal compressor stage. The results were generated from CFD and were analyzed for better understanding of the fluid flow through centrifugal compressor stage. Conclusively, it was observed that the effect of the vaned diffuser is to convert the kinetic energy into a high static pressure after analyzing the results of the simulation.


Author(s):  
Venkateswara Rao Pothuri ◽  
Venkata Ramana Murty Govindaraju ◽  
Venkata Rao Ganapathiraju

This paper describes the computational results on the performance of a centrifugal compressor stage with twisted vaned diffuser by varying the speed of the impeller and direction of twist for the diffuser vane. The centrifugal compressor stage configuration consists of a 2-D impeller (no twist is provided for the impeller vanes) with various configurations of diffusers. Diffuser configurations considered are Vaneless Diffuser (VLD), Low Solidity Vaned Diffuser (LSVD) and Twisted Vaned Diffuser (TVD). The analysis was carried at four different rotational speeds with corresponding mass flow rates of the impeller. 9° twist is given to the diffuser vane from hub to shroud by providing rotation at the leading edge, keeping the profile at hub as reference in the direction of rotation of the impeller and opposite to the direction of rotation of the impeller. The off-design cases considered includes operation at 80%, 90%, 110% and 120% of the design mass flow rate. CFD results are validated with experimental results for stages with VLD and LSVD for certain chosen performance parameters such as head coefficient, stage input power and exit flow angle. The computational results indicate that variations in impeller speed will cause changes in all significant performance parameters like the total pressure rise, power coefficient and efficiency of the stage and static pressure recovery coefficient of the diffuser. Contour plots were generated from CFD results and analyzed for better understanding of effect of rotational speed of the impeller on the performance of the centrifugal compressor. As a result of this study, it can be concluded that twisted vaned diffuser improves the performance in comparison to low solidity vaned diffuser for all the chosen impeller rotational speeds. The performance of the compressor stage is superior when diffuser vane twist is provided in the direction opposite to the rotation of impeller.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document