Degradation of Film Cooling Performance on a Turbine Vane Suction Side due to Surface Roughness

2005 ◽  
Vol 128 (3) ◽  
pp. 547-554 ◽  
Author(s):  
James L. Rutledge ◽  
David Robertson ◽  
David G. Bogard

After an extended period of operation, the surfaces of turbine airfoils become extremely rough due to deposition, spallation, and erosion. The rough airfoil surfaces will cause film cooling performance degradation due to effects on adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients. In this study, the individual and combined effects of roughness upstream and downstream of a row of film cooling holes on the suction side of a turbine vane have been determined. Adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients were measured for a range of mainstream turbulence levels and with and without showerhead blowing. Using these parameters, the ultimate film cooling performance was quantified in terms of net heat flux reduction. The dominant effect of roughness was a doubling of the heat transfer coefficients. Maximum adiabatic effectiveness levels were also decreased significantly. Relative to a film cooled smooth surface, a film cooled rough surface was found to increase the heat flux to the surface by 30%–70%.

Author(s):  
James L. Rutledge ◽  
David Robertson ◽  
David G. Bogard

After an extended period of operation, the surfaces of turbine airfoils become extremely rough due to deposition, spallation, and erosion. The rough airfoil surfaces will cause film cooling performance degradation due to effects on adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients. In this study, the individual and combined effects of roughness upstream and downstream of a row of film cooling holes on the suction side of a turbine vane have been determined. Adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients were measured for a range of mainstream turbulence levels and with and without showerhead blowing. Using these parameters, the ultimate film cooling performance was quantified in terms of net heat flux reduction. The dominant effect of roughness was a doubling of the heat transfer coefficients. Maximum adiabatic effectiveness levels were also decreased significantly. Relative to a film cooled smooth surface, a film cooled rough surface was found to increase the heat flux to the surface by 30% to 70%.


Author(s):  
Katharine L. Harrison ◽  
John R. Dorrington ◽  
Jason E. Dees ◽  
David G. Bogard ◽  
Ronald S. Bunker

Film cooling adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients for cylindrical holes embedded in a 1d transverse trench on the suction side of a simulated turbine vane were investigated to determine the net heat flux reduction. For reference, measurements were also conducted with standard inclined, cylindrical holes. Heat transfer coefficients were determined with and without upstream heating to isolate the hydrodynamic effects of the trench and to investigate the effects of the thermal approach boundary layer. Also the effects of a tripped versus an un-tripped boundary layer were explored. For both the cylindrical holes and the trench, heat transfer augmentation was much greater with no tripping of the approach flow. A further increase in heat transfer augmentation was caused by use of upstream heating, with as much as a 150% augmentation with the trench. With a tripped approach flow the heat transfer augmentation was much less. The net heat flux reduction for the trench was found to be significantly higher than for the row of cylindrical holes.


2008 ◽  
Vol 131 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Katharine L. Harrison ◽  
John R. Dorrington ◽  
Jason E. Dees ◽  
David G. Bogard ◽  
Ronald S. Bunker

Film cooling adiabatic effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients for cylindrical holes embedded in a 1d transverse trench on the suction side of a simulated turbine vane were investigated to determine the net heat flux reduction. For reference, measurements were also conducted with standard inclined, cylindrical holes. Heat transfer coefficients were determined with and without upstream heating to isolate the hydrodynamic effects of the trench and to investigate the effects of the thermal approach boundary layer. Also, the effects of a tripped versus an untripped boundary layer were explored. For both the cylindrical holes and the trench, heat transfer augmentation was much greater for the untripped approach flow. A further increase in heat transfer augmentation was caused by use of upstream heating, with as much as a 180% augmentation for the trench. The tripped approach flow led to much lower heat transfer augmentation than the untipped case. The net heat flux reduction for the trench was found to be significantly higher than for the row of cylindrical holes.


Author(s):  
Ushio M. Yuki ◽  
David G. Bogard ◽  
J. Michael Cutbirth

This paper presents an experimental study of the heat transfer on the leading edge of a simulated film cooled turbine airfoil. Previous studies have shown that use of film cooling on the leading edge of an airfoil can significantly increase the heat transfer coefficients around the leading edge which counter-acts the benefits of the adiabatic effectiveness provided by the coolant film. These heat transfer results complement our earlier study of the adiabatic effectiveness for this leading edge and film cooling hole geometry. Heat transfer and adiabatic effectiveness results were combined to determine the overall performance of the film cooling in terms of the net heat flux reduction. Heat transfer coefficients were found to be significantly increased by the film cooling flow in a narrow region which followed the path of the coolant flow. However, heat transfer coefficients were maximum to one side of the coolant jet, consistent with a streamwise vortex flow which is believed to be generated by the interaction of the mainstream with the coolant jet. Overall performance in terms of the net heat flux reduction was found to be unaffected by the large heat transfer coefficients in the vicinity of the holes, but was significantly diminished farther downstream.


Author(s):  
Bingran Li ◽  
Cunliang Liu ◽  
Lin Ye ◽  
Huiren Zhu ◽  
Fan Zhang

Abstract To investigate the application of ribbed cross-flow coolant channels with film hole effusion and the effects of the internal cooling configuration on film cooling, experimental and numerical studies are conducted on the effect of the relative position of the film holes and different orientation ribs on the film cooling performance. Three cases of the relative position of the film holes and different orientation ribs (post-rib, centered, and pre-rib) in two ribbed cross-flow channels (135° and 45° orientation ribs) are investigated. The film cooling performances are measured under three blowing ratios by the transient liquid crystal measurement technique. A RANS simulation with the realizable k-ε turbulence model and enhanced wall treatment is performed. The results show that the cooling effectiveness and the downstream heat transfer coefficient for the 135° rib are basically the same in the three position cases, and the differences between the local effectiveness average values for the three are no more than 0.04. The differences between the heat transfer coefficients are no more than 0.1. The “pre-rib” and “centered” cases are studied for the 45° rib, and the position of the structures has little effect on the film cooling performance. In the different position cases, the outlet velocity distribution of the film holes, the jet pattern and the discharge coefficient are consistent with the variation in the cross flow. The related research previously published by the authors showed that the inclination of the ribs with respect to the holes affects the film cooling performance. This study reveals that the relative positions of the ribs and holes have little effect on the film cooling performance. This paper expands and improves the study of the effect of the internal cooling configuration on film cooling and makes a significant contribution to the design and industrial application of the internal cooling channel of a turbine blade.


Author(s):  
M. Gritsch ◽  
A. Schulz ◽  
S. Wittig

Detailed measurements of heat transfer coefficients in the nearfield of three different film-cooling holes are presented. The hole geometries investigated include a cylindrical hole and two holes with a diffuser shaped exit portion (i.e. a fan-shaped and a laidback fanshaped hole). They were tested over a range of blowing ratios M = 0.25…1.75 at an external crossflow Mach number of 0.6 and a coolant-to-mainflow density ratio of 1.85. Additionally, the effect of the internal coolant supply Mach number is addressed. Temperatures of the diabatic surface downstream of the injection location are measured by means of an infrared camera system. They are used as boundary conditions for a finite element analysis to determine surface heat fluxes and heat transfer coefficients. The superposition method is applied to evaluate the overall film-cooling performance of the hole geometries investigated. As compared to the cylindrical hole, both expanded holes show significantly lower heat transfer coefficients downstream of the injection location, particularly at high blowing ratios. The laidback fanshaped hole provides a better lateral spreading of the injected coolant than the fanshaped hole which leads to lower laterally averaged heat transfer coefficients. Coolant passage crossflow Mach number affects the flowfield of the jet being ejected from the hole and, therefore, has an important impact on film-cooling performance.


Author(s):  
S. Baldauf ◽  
M. Scheurlen ◽  
A. Schulz ◽  
S. Wittig

Heat transfer coefficients and the resulting heat flux reduction due to film cooling on a flat plate downstream a row of cylindrical holes are investigated. Highly resolved two dimensional heat transfer coefficient distributions were measured by means of infrared thermography and carefully corrected for local internal testplate conduction and radiation effects [1]. These locally acquired data are processed to lateral average heat transfer coefficients for a quantitative assessment. A wide range variation of the flow parameters blowing rate and density ratio as well as the geometrical parameters streamwise ejection angle and hole spacing is examined. The effects of these dominating parameters on the heat transfer augmentation from film cooling are discussed and interpreted with the help of highly resolved surface results of effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients presented earlier [2]. A new method of evaluating the heat flux reduction from film cooling is presented. From a combination of the lateral average of both the adiabatic effectiveness and the heat transfer coefficient, the lateral average heat flux reduction is processed according to the new method. The discussion of the total effect of film cooling by means of the heat flux reduction reveals important characteristics and constraints of discrete hole ejection. The complete heat transfer data of all measurements are used as basis for a new correlation of lateral average heat transfer coefficients. This correlation combines the effects of all the dominating parameters. It yields a prediction of the heat transfer coefficient from the ejection position to far downstream, including effects of extreme blowing angles and hole spacing. The new correlation has a modular structure to allow for future inclusion of additional parameters. Together with the correlation of the adiabatic effectiveness it provides an immediate determination of the streamwise heat flux reduction distribution of cylindrical hole film cooling configurations.


Author(s):  
D. H. Zhang ◽  
L. Sun ◽  
Q. Y. Chen ◽  
M. Lin ◽  
M. Zeng ◽  
...  

Embedding a row of typical cylindrical holes in a transverse slot can improve the cooling performance. Rectangular slots can increase the cooling effectiveness but is at the cost of decreasing of discharge coefficients. An experiment is conducted to examine the effects of an overlying transverse inclined trench on the film cooling performance of axial holes. Four different trench configurations are tested including the baseline inclined cylindrical holes. The influence of the geometry of the upstream lip of the exit trench and the geometry of the inlet trench on cooling performance is examined. Detailed film cooling effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients are obtained separately using the steady state IR thermography technique. The discharge coefficients are also acquired to evaluate the aerodynamic performance of different hole configurations. The results show that the film cooling holes with both ends embedded in slots can provide higher film cooling effectiveness and lower heat transfer coefficients; it also can provide higher discharge coefficients whilst retaining the mechanical strength of a row of discrete holes. The cooling performance and the aerodynamic performance of the holes with both ends embedded in inclined slots are superior to the holes with only exit trenched. To a certain extent, the configuration of the upstream lip of the exit trench affects the cooling performance of the downstream of the trench. The filleting for the film hole inlet avail the improvement of the cooling effect, but not for the film hole outlet. Comparing film cooling with embedded holes to unembedded holes, the overall heat flux ratio shows that the film holes with both ends embedded in slots and filleting for the film hole inlet can produce the highest heat flux reduction.


Author(s):  
Hans Reiss ◽  
Albin Bölcs

Film cooling and heat transfer measurements were carried out on a cooled nozzle guide vane in a linear cascade, using a transient liquid crystal technique. Three flow conditions were realized: the nominal operating condition of the vane with an exit Reynolds number of 1.47e6, as well as two lower flow conditions: Re2L = 1.0e6 and 7.5e5. The vane model was equipped with a single row of inclined round film cooling holes with compound angle orientation on the suction side. Blowing ratios ranging form 0.3 to 1.5 were covered, all using foreign gas injection (CO2) yielding an engine-representative density ratio of 1.6. Two distinct states of the incoming boundary layer onto the injection station were compared, an undisturbed laminar boundary layer as it forms naturally on the suction side, and a fully turbulent boundary layer which was triggered with a trip wire upstream of injection. The aerodynamic flow field is characterized in terms of profile Mach number distribution, and the associated heat transfer coefficients around the uncooled airfoil are presented. Both detailed and spanwise averaged results of film cooling effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients are shown on the suction side, which indicate considerable influence of the state of the incoming boundary layer on the performance of a film cooling row. The influence of the mainstream flow condition on the film cooling behavior at constant blowing ratio is discussed for three chosen injection regimes.


2002 ◽  
Vol 124 (4) ◽  
pp. 699-709 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. Baldauf ◽  
M. Scheurlen ◽  
A. Schulz ◽  
S. Wittig

Heat transfer coefficients and the resulting heat flux reduction due to film cooling on a flat plate downstream a row of cylindrical holes are investigated. Highly resolved two-dimensional heat transfer coefficient distributions were measured by means of infrared thermography and carefully corrected for local internal testplate conduction and radiation effects. These locally acquired data are processed to lateral average heat transfer coefficients for a quantitative assessment. A wide range variation of the flow parameters blowing rate and density ratio as well as the geometrical parameters streamwise ejection angle and hole spacing is examined. The effects of these dominating parameters on the heat transfer augmentation from film cooling are discussed and interpreted with the help of highly resolved surface results of effectiveness and heat transfer coefficients presented earlier. A new method of evaluating the heat flux reduction from film cooling is presented. From a combination of the lateral average of both the adiabatic effectiveness and the heat transfer coefficient, the lateral average heat flux reduction is processed according to the new method. The discussion of the total effect of film cooling by means of the heat flux reduction reveals important characteristics and constraints of discrete hole ejection. The complete heat transfer data of all measurements are used as basis for a new correlation of lateral average heat transfer coefficients. This correlation combines the effects of all the dominating parameters. It yields a prediction of the heat transfer coefficient from the ejection position to far downstream, including effects of extreme blowing angles and hole spacing. The new correlation has a modular structure to allow for future inclusion of additional parameters. Together with the correlation of the adiabatic effectiveness it provides an immediate determination of the streamwise heat flux reduction distribution of cylindrical hole film-cooling configurations.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document