Functional stabilisation and partner selection during repeated co-culivation in a methanotrophic interactome
Background Biological oxidation of methane (CH4) is an essential ecosystem function. Accumulating evidence indicated that this function is mediated by associations of methanotrophic bacteria (MOB) with non-methanotrophic partners; together referred to as a methanotrophic interactome. Given the potency of CH4 as a greenhouse gas, a thorough understanding of how these interactomes exert an effect on methane oxidation is of special interest. Furthermore, MOB - non-MOB associations could be exploited for sustainable biotechnological applications in light of the renewed interest in MOB as natural and cost-efficient biocatalysts. The selectivity of MOB for non-MOB partners, as well as the stimulation of MOB activity (CH4 oxidation rate, MOR) with increasing non-MOB richness have both been recently described for a single batch incubation period. Therefore, we hypothesized that during repeated co-cultivation of MOB with non-MOB, ecological sorting would guide the methanotrophic interactome towards its optimal composition, which could additionally boost functionality (MOR). Methods Co-cultures of 8 non-MOB partners with a single alpha- or a single gammaproteobacterial MOB were repeatedly sub-cultivated. In every cycle, the headspace CH4 concentration was measured to over time to determine the MOR, while headspace CO2 concentrations and total protein in the culture were determined to track the fate of CH4-derived carbon (catabolism and assimilation respectively). Finally, the relative abundance of each co-culture partner was assessed using a 16S rRNA gene-targeted denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis (DGGE). Results and Discussion While no significant improvement of functionality was observed, the biological variability of MOR was stabilized by co-cultivation with non-MOB partners. Overall, higher biomass yields were obtained when MOB were co-cultivated with non-MOB partners and the alphaproteobacterial MOB appeared to be able to support more non-MOB biomass than the gammaproteobacterial MOB, which could be linked to the proposed life-strategies of these clades. A clear partner selection was observed as only 4 out of 8 initial partners were found to persist during repeated cycles of co-cultivation. While 2 of the persisting partners could coexist with either MOB type, the other two were more restricted to a specific MOB. Differential metabolic potential of non-MOB was resolved by genome mining publicly available genomes; our attempt to find clues for the partner selectivity did not reveal a clear link with the potential for C1-compound metabolism. However, genes for sugar metabolism (fructose, mannose, sucrose) were restricted to the persisting partners while genes encoding an ATP-dependent vitamin B12 importer were restricted to the non-persisting partners, underlining the importance of metabolic exchange in the methanotrophic interactome.