scholarly journals Overcoming the comparative confusion of the audit committee’s impact on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks: An international evidence in a framework of agency theory

2021 ◽  
Vol 6 (3) ◽  
pp. 55-90
Author(s):  
Achraf Haddad ◽  
Mohamed Naceur Souissi ◽  
Abdelfattah Bouri
Keyword(s):  
Panel Data ◽  
Financial Performance ◽  
Agency Theory ◽  
Audit Committee ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
International Evidence ◽  
Secondary Role ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
Theoretical Foundations ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Based on the banking and governance literature, the impacts of the audit committee quality on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks are mixed, unstable and sometimes contradictory. In this study, we consulted deeply the theoretical foundations of the audit committee quality on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks to solve the ambiguity of comparison in a framework of agency theory. Measures of financial performance and audit committee determinants are collected from 30 countries. Under the panel data estimations, data were collected from 112 banks of each type that have published their reports regularly during the period (2010-2019). Overall, we obtained 1120 bank-year observations in each sub-sample. The results showed that the audit committee in conventional banks negatively affected their financial performance. However, in Islamic banks, it revealed a vague impact because of his secondary role.

scholarly journals Impact of Audit Committee Quality on the Financial Performance of Conventional and Islamic Banks

2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (4) ◽  
pp. 176
Author(s):  
Achraf Haddad ◽  
Anis El Ammari ◽  
Abdelfattah Bouri
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Audit Committee ◽  
Evaluation Method ◽  
Positive Impact ◽  
Generalized Least Squares ◽  
Audit Committees ◽  
Subprime Crisis ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

A lot of previous research studied the relationship between audit committee quality and the financial performance of conventional banks before and during the subprime crisis, whereas some other investigations analyzed the same association in the framework of Islamic banks. However, no study has compared these two correlations either before, during, or after the subprime crisis. Several reasons explain the differences, such as the audit committee quality of each bank type, the evaluation method of the financial performance, the research peculiarities, the methodology, the data, and the interpretation. This research aims to compare the impacts of the audit committees’ quality on the financial performance of Islamic and conventional banks between 2010 and 2019. The financial performance measures and audit committees’ determinants of the conventional and Islamic banks concerned 112 banks of each type. The collected data covered four continents: America, Asia, Africa, and Europe. Impacts were compared by using the Generalized Least Squares analysis. The results showed that the audit committee reduced the profitability of two bank types. Moreover, it harmed the conventional banks’ efficiency but reported an unclear effect within Islamic banks. Even so, we noticed that the audit committee had a positive impact on the conventional banks’ liquidity, while the same effect was apparently ambiguous for the Islamic banks’ liquidity. For solvency, the audit committee positively influenced conventional banks while it affected that of Islamic banks.

scholarly journals Impacts of ownership structure on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks in the agency theory context

2020 ◽  
Vol 17 (3) ◽  
pp. 46-70 ◽  
Author(s):  
Achraf Haddad ◽  
Anis El Ammari ◽  
Abdelfettah Bouri
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Agency Theory ◽  
Ownership Structure ◽  
Chief Executive ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Differential Analysis ◽  
Two Samples ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
The Impact ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

According to the literature review, the analysis results of the impact of ownership structure quality on financial performance within conventional and Islamic financial institutions are contradictory. In our study, we performed a fine differential analysis aimed at resolving this ambiguity. The financial performance and ownership structure variables of conventional and Islamic banks were collected from 16 countries located in three continents: Europe, Asia, and Africa. Two samples were collected that each of them is composed of 63 banks. By using the OLS method, these panel data were compared to the impact of ownership structure on the financial performance between both types of banks in the agency theory framework during the period 2010-2018, giving us 567 bank-year observations in each sub-sample. Results revealed that the ownership structure of conventional banks has had an explained ambiguous impact on its financial performance, whereas that of Islamic banks has a positive effect. Overall, the impacts of the Chief Executive Officer (CEO) shareholding and the board’s chairman shareholding are more significant on the financial performance of conventional banks than those of impacts related to Islamic banks.

scholarly journals Effect of board quality on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks: Comparative study on the international evidence

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Achraf HADDAD ◽  
Anis EL AMMARI ◽  
Abdelfattah BOURI
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Board Of Directors ◽  
Positive Impact ◽  
Cylindrical Panel ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
International Evidence ◽  
The Board Of Directors ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
The Impact ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Abstract This article provides the first logical analysis that detailed the process of comparative analysis between the correlation of board determinants’ quality and the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks. However, in previous research, we have never encountered rewarding studies that compared these impacts. In our study, we distinguished between the impact of the board of directors on the financial performance in conventional and Islamic banks. Settings of the financial performance and board of directors of the conventional and Islamic banks are collected from 30 countries located in four continents: America, Europe, Asia, and Africa. Two equal samples were collected that each of them is composed of 112 banks. By using the cylindrical panel method, data were used to explore the impact of the board of directors on the financial performance between both types of banks over the period 2010-2018, giving us 1008 bank-year observations in each sub-sample. On the whole, empirical results have shown that in conventional banks the board of directors has negatively affected the financial performance, while the impact of the board on the financial performance of Islamic banks is ambiguous. Nevertheless, the degree of the positive impact on financial performance is more significant in Islamic banks.

scholarly journals The effect of audit committee quality on the conventional and Islamic banks' financial performance between subprime and Corona crises

2021 ◽  
Vol ahead-of-print (ahead-of-print) ◽  
Author(s):  
Achraf Haddad ◽  
Anis El Ammari ◽  
Abdelfattah Bouri
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Audit Committee ◽  
Evaluation Method ◽  
Positive Impact ◽  
Annual Reports ◽  
Subprime Crisis ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Content Type ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

PurposeThis study aims to test empirically the differences between Islamic and conventional banks in terms of impacts of the audit committees' quality on financial performance between Subprime and Corona crises.Design/methodology/approachThe variables are articulated in four hypotheses tested by the GLS analysis. The data were collected via DATASTREAM and from banks' annual reports. The collected data covered four continents: America, Asia, Africa and Europe. The financial performance measures and audit committee's determinants of the conventional and Islamic banks concerned 112 banks of each type after the Subprime crisis and before the Corona crisis (2010–2019).FindingsResults showed that the audit committee reduced the profitability of two bank types. Moreover, it harmed the conventional banks' efficiency, but reported an unclear effect within Islamic banks. Even so, the authors noticed that the audit committee had a positive impact for the conventional banks' liquidity, while the same effect was apparently ambiguous on the Islamic banks' liquidity. For solvency, the audit committee positively influenced conventional banks, while it affected that of Islamic banks.Research limitations/implicationsEmpirically, the authors’ results can serve as a reference for decision-makers allowing to clarify the data on the financial competitiveness of two bank types to facilitate the planning of strategic performance programs based on the audit committee quality. Theoretically, researchers found that the differences between the results are due to the audit committee quality of each bank type or to the financial performance evaluation method. However, there are further factors that are related to the research peculiarities, the methodology, the data and the interpretation.Originality/valueBased on the comparative literature review between conventional and Islamic banks, this study is the first conditional and comparative research between the audit committee quality and the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks in a specific period (after Subprime and before Corona crises).

Does the country’s religion affect the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks? Comparative study in the international framework

2021 ◽  
Vol ahead-of-print (ahead-of-print) ◽  
Author(s):  
Achraf Haddad ◽  
Achraf Haddad
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Generalized Method Of Moments ◽  
Developed Countries ◽  
Emerging Countries ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Governance Mechanism ◽  
Content Type ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
The Impact ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Purpose The purpose of this study is to compare the impact of religion on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks in the framework of stakeholders’ theory. Design/methodology/approach Few studies have focused on studying the impact of religion on banking performance. Although religion represents an external governance mechanism for financial institutions, by using the generalized method of moments (GMM), this topic constitutes a research opportunity. The already modeled variables are collected from 76 countries located on 5 continents. The data were collected from DATASTREAM, banks’ annual reports, WIKIPEDIA and World Bank. It concerns 210 banks of each type during the period (2010–2020). Findings The author retained that religion negatively affects the financial performance of both conventional and Islamic banks. More specifically, results showed that religion affected the liquidity and solvency of two bank types. It also affected conventional banks’ profitability and efficiency of conventional banks. Research limitations/implications I summarized the theoretical contribution in the integration of a new original governance category to enhance its presence with impacts directly affecting the banks’ financial performance. Empirically, the study can be seen as a compass for all stakeholders to consider environmental, behavioral and doctrinal factors in studying the financial performance evolution and to become more competitive in the banking market. Originality/value Although conventional banks located in developed countries are different from those existing in emerging countries and Islamic banks located in developed countries are different from those existing in emerging countries, I carried out a diversified study in the global context. Referring to the comparative literature review between conventional and Islamic banks, the study was the first conditional research that compared the impacts of religion on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks.

scholarly journals Effect of board quality on the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks in a stable financial context: Comparative study on the international evidence

2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Achraf HADDAD ◽  
Anis EL AMMARI ◽  
Abdelfattah BOURI
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Board Of Directors ◽  
Positive Impact ◽  
Main Role ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
The Board Of Directors ◽  
Internal Mechanism ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
The Impact ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Abstract Returning to the literature of finance and banking governance, our article provides the first logical analysis that detailed the process of comparative analysis between the correlation of board determinants’ quality and the financial performance of conventional and Islamic banks. Previous research has always discussed the main role of the board as an internal mechanism of governance on the financial performance separately in each bank type. However, we have never encountered rewarding studies that compared these impacts. In our study, we distinguished between the impact of the board of directors on the financial performance in conventional and Islamic banks. Settings of the financial performance and board of directors of the conventional and Islamic banks are collected from 30 countries located in four continents: America, Europe, Asia, and Africa. Two equal samples were collected that each of them is composed of 112 banks. By using the GLS method, data were used to explore the impact of the board of directors on the financial performance between both types of banks over the period 2010-2018, giving us 1008 bank-year observations in each sub-sample. On the whole, empirical results have shown that in conventional banks the board of directors has negatively affected the financial performance, while the impact of the board on the financial performance of Islamic banks is ambiguous. Nevertheless, the degree of the positive impact on financial performance is more significant in Islamic banks.

Does anti-corruption disclosure affect banking performance?

2020 ◽  
Vol 27 (4) ◽  
pp. 1161-1172
Author(s):  
Haitham Nobanee ◽  
Osama F. Atayah ◽  
Charilaos Mertzanis
Keyword(s):  
Data Analysis ◽  
Panel Data ◽  
Panel Data Analysis ◽  
Dynamic Panel Data ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Dynamic Panel ◽  
Content Type ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
Dynamic Panel Data Analysis ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Purpose This paper aims to test the levels of anti-corruption disclosure and its implication on the banking performance of both conventional and Islamic banks listed on the Abu Dhabi Securities Exchange and Dubai Financial Market. Design/methodology/approach The authors have used the content analysis to identify the levels of anti-corruption disclosure in the banks’ annual reports. They have also used the two-steps generalized method of moments (GMM) regression applied to dynamic panel data analysis to examine the effect of the anti-corruption disclosure on the banking performance. Findings The empirical results show that the anti-corruption disclosure is at low levels for all banks and conventional and Islamic banks samples. The results also show no significant differences in the anti-corruption disclosure between Islamic and conventional banks. The results of the two-steps GMM regression applied to dynamic panel data analysis show a negative and significant impact of the levels of anti-corruption disclosure on the bank’s performance for both all banks and conventional banks; the results of the dynamic panel data analysis show an insignificant impact of anti-corruption discloser for the Islamic banks' sample. Practical implications The findings recommended a comprehensive framework of anti-corruption disclosure to the central banks and financial market regulators to enhance anti-corruption practices within the financial institutions to increase transparency and enhance their performance. Originality/value Fighting against anti-corruption is essential for financial institutions. This paper is the first study that examined the extent of anti-corruption levels and their effect on banking performance for both Islamic and conventional banks operates in the UAE. The findings help in enhancing reporting practices in terms of anti-corruption to improve transparency and performance in the banking sector.

Risk, efficiency and financial performance in the GCC banking industry: Islamic versus conventional banks

2021 ◽  
Vol ahead-of-print (ahead-of-print) ◽  
Author(s):  
Sutan Emir Hidayat ◽  
Muhammad Rizky Prima Sakti ◽  
Raqiya Ali Abdullah Al-Balushi
Keyword(s):  
Adverse Effects ◽  
Credit Risk ◽  
Financial Performance ◽  
Risk Sharing ◽  
Banking Industry ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Content Type ◽  
Bank Managers ◽  
Conventional Banks ◽  
Conventional And Islamic Banks

Purpose The purpose of this study is to critically evaluate how conventional and Islamic banks trade off risk, efficiency and financial performance in their business models, to investigate how patterns of risk and efficiency vary between conventional and Islamic banks and to critically evaluate how the profitability of conventional and Islamic banks varies following the financial crisis. Design/methodology/approach This study uses univariate and multivariate statistical techniques by investigating 12 Islamic banks and 34 conventional banks operating in the Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) region has been studied over the period 2011–2018. Findings The results suggest that Islamic and conventional banks differ not in the levels of efficiency, risk and profitability, but rather in how risk and efficiency influence banks’ financial performance. Islamic banks are found to be less influenced by the adverse effects of credit risk, which is consistent with the risk-sharing nature of Islamic financing. However, the results only hold for return on assets (ROA) and return on equity (ROE) while the net interest margin is observed to be negatively influenced by credit risk. Lower cost-income efficiency is also found to boost ROA and ROE of Islamic banks which could be attributed to a larger share of non-interest revenues due to Sharīʿah-compliance. Research limitations/implications From a theoretical point of view, this study helps to understand the risk, efficiency and financial performance of Islamic banks in comparison with conventional banks. Practical implications The results of this study can serve bank managers, regulators and shareholders. Policymakers should encourage a more risk-sharing structure of Islamic financing as it brings less adverse effects of credit risk and increases income sustainability for Islamic banks. The present study may help bank managers to improve the financial performance of their firms by controlling risk and efficiency. The study results also have implications for shareholders and depositors of Islamic and conventional banks as they should have a predetermined position about the level of credit risk and efficiency in each banking system. Originality/value The foremost contribution is that this is one of the few studies to compare risk, efficiency and financial performance of Islamic and conventional banks in the GCC region. By using the latest data, this paper hopes that the findings will be more relevant than previous studies to the current situation of the banking industry in the region.

scholarly journals ISLAMIC BANKING PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT: A CONCEPTUAL REVIEW OF TWO DECADES

2021 ◽  
Vol 5 (1) ◽  
pp. 16-33
Author(s):  
Elyanti Rosmanidar ◽  
Abu Azam Al Hadi ◽  
Muhamad Ahsan
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Intellectual Capital ◽  
Social Performance ◽  
Meta Analysis ◽  
Jel Classification ◽  
Research Trend ◽  
Islamic Banking ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
The Past ◽  
Conventional Banks

This article aims to provide an overview of the development of research on the measurement of Islamic banking performance over the past 20 years from 89 selected papers with Scopus-indexed journals ranked Q4 to Q1 or accredited with Sinta 2 to Sinta 1. This study used a qual-quantitative meta-analysis approach using the Mendeley citation application. The distribution of the topic and the depth of research in paper samples based on keywords in publications were analyzed using the VOSviewer application. The results of the analysis showed that the research trend of Islamic banking performance in reputable journals is increasing in recent years. Most of the studies performed in the last two decades have focused on the practice and corporate governance of Islamic banks and comparisons between Islamic and conventional banks based on financial performance ratios and aspect of maqasid al-Shariah; Only a few studies that discuss efficiency, social performance on Islamic banks, regulation, intellectual capital and stability of the financial performance of Islamic banks were found. The further discussion is an empirical exposure without theoretical exploration or analysis which is supposed to become the direction of banking research in the future.  JEL Classification Codes: G21, L25, P17, P47.

scholarly journals Analisis Kinerja Keuangan Bank Umum Syariah Sebelum dan Sesudah Pengalihan Dana Haji pada Bank Syariah

2021 ◽  
Vol 1 (2) ◽  
pp. 309-331
Author(s):  
Lisa Erliana Marwan ◽  
Iwan Setiawan ◽  
Ine Mayasari
Keyword(s):  
Financial Performance ◽  
Rank Test ◽  
Positive Contribution ◽  
Islamic Banks ◽  
Fund Management ◽  
Financial Report ◽  
Signed Rank ◽  
Before And After ◽  
Signed Rank Test ◽  
Conventional Banks

Government policy through UU No 34 Thn 2014 about Hajj Fund Management said that the Hajj Fund Management should with the principle of sharia. Then in 2014, there was a transfer Hajj Fund from Conventional banks to Islamic banks. Hajj Fund that transferred to Islamic banks have a large value so it can give positive contribution to the  financial performance such as DPK.The aim of this study was to find out the financial performance of 6 BPS BPIH before and after the transfer of Hajj Fund from conventional banks to Islamic banks. Taking case studies at PT. Bank Syariah Mandiri, PT. Bank BRI Syariah, PT. Bank BNI Syariah, PT. Bank Mega Syariah, PT. Bank Panin Dubai Syariah, and PT. Bank Muamalat.  The Data that used in this study is Return On Assets (ROA) and Financing to Deposit Ratio (FDR) in Quarterly Financial Report of 6 BPS BPIH,4 years before the transfer of hajj fund that started 2010 until 2013, and 4 years after the transfer of hajj fund that started from 2015 until 2018. The method of data analysis in this study uses a different samples in non parametrik, which is Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test. The result of this  study  shows us that there was a difference in ROA and FDR of BPS BPIH before and after the transfer of  hajj  fund  from  conventional  banks  to Islamic banks.

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document