Abstract
Natural killer (NK) cells are innate lymphoid cells that mediate anti-tumor responses and exhibit innate memory following stimulation with IL-12, IL-15, and IL-18, thereby differentiating into cytokine-induced memory-like (ML) NK cells. ML NK cells have well-described enhanced anti-tumor properties; however, the molecular mechanisms underlying their enhanced functionality are not well-understood. Initial reports of allogeneic donor ML NK cellular therapy for relapsed/refractory (rel/ref) acute myeloid leukemia (AML) demonstrated safety and a 47% CR/CRi rate (PMID32826231). In this setting, allogeneic ML NK cells are rejected after 3 weeks by recipient T cells, which precludes long-term evaluation of their biology. To address this limitation, we conducted a clinical trial for rel/ref AML patients that added adoptive transfer of same-donor ML NK cells on day +7 of a reduced-intensity conditioning (RIC) MHC-haploidentical HCT, followed by 4 doses of IL-15 (N-803) over 2 weeks (NCT02782546). Since the ML NK cells are from the HCT donor, they are not rejected, but remain MHC-haploidentical to the patient leukemia. Using samples from these patients, we profiled the single cell transcriptomes of NK cells using multidimensional CITE-seq, combining scRNAseq with a custom NK panel of antibodies.
To identify donor ML NK cells in an unbiased fashion, we developed a CITE-seq ML NK classifier from in vitro differentiated paired conventional NK (cNK) and ML NK cells. This classifier was applied via transfer learning to CITE-seq analyzed samples from the donor (cNK cells) and patients at days +28 and +60. This approach identified 28-40% of NK cells as ML at Day +28 post-HCT. Only 1-6% of donor peripheral blood NK cells and 4-7% of NK cells in comparator leukemia patients at day +28 after conventional haplo-HCT alone were identified as ML NK cells (Fig 1A). These ML NK cells had a cell surface receptor profile analogous to a previously reported mass cytometry phenotype. Within the CITE-seq data, ML NK cells expressed a transcriptional profile consistent with enhanced functionality (GZMK, GZMA, GNLY), secreted proteins (LTB, CKLF), a distinct adhesome, and evidence of prior activation (MHC Class II and interferon-inducible genes). ML NK cells had a unique NK receptor repertoire including increased KIR2DL4, KLRC1(NKG2A), CD300A, NCAM1(CD56) , and CD2 with decreased expression of the inhibitory receptor KLRB1(CD161). Furthermore, ML NK cells upregulated HOPX, a transcription factor implicated in memory T cells and murine CMV adaptive NK cells. Additionally, ML NK cells downregulated transcription factors related to terminal maturation (ZEB2) and exhaustion (NR4A2).
We next sought to identify changes during ML differentiation in patients post-HCT from day +28 to +60 post-HCT. Trajectory analysis identified a ML NK cell state distinct from cNK cells that was present at least 60 days post-HCT (Fig 1B). The ML transcriptional phenotype continued to modulate during late differentiation, including downregulation of GZMK and NCAM1, and upregulation of maturation related transcription factors, while maintaining high expression of HOPX. ML NK cells retained their enhanced functionality during in vivo differentiation, as patient ML NK cells had significantly increased IFNγ production compared to cNK cells after restimulation with leukemia targets or cytokines using mass cytometry (Fig. 2). Subsequently, we confirmed the ML CITE-seq profile in an independent clinical trial treating pediatric AML relapsed after allogenic HCT with same-donor ML NK cells (NCT03068819). In this setting, ML NK cells expressed a similar transcriptional signature and persisted for at least 2 months in the absence of exogenous cytokine support. Thus, ML NK cells possess a distinct transcriptional and surface proteomic profile and undergo in vivo differentiation while persisting within patients for at least 2 months. These findings reveal novel and unique aspects of the ML NK cell molecular program, as well as their prolonged functional persistence in vivo in patients, assisting in future clinical trial design.
Figure 1 Figure 1.
Disclosures
Foltz: Kiadis: Patents & Royalties: TGFbeta expanded NK cells; EMD Millipore: Other: canine antibody licensing fees. Berrien-Elliott: Wugen: Consultancy, Patents & Royalties: 017001-PRO1, Research Funding. Bednarski: Horizon Pharmaceuticals: Membership on an entity's Board of Directors or advisory committees. Fehniger: Wugen: Consultancy, Current equity holder in publicly-traded company, Patents & Royalties: related to memory like NK cells, Research Funding; ImmunityBio: Research Funding; Kiadis: Other; Affimed: Research Funding; Compass Therapeutics: Research Funding; HCW Biologics: Research Funding; OrcaBio: Other; Indapta: Other.
Phenotypic Characterization by Single-Cell Mass Cytometry of Human Intrahepatic and Peripheral NK Cells in Patients with Hepatocellular Carcinoma