Strains Comparisons of Unbound Base/Subbase Layer Using Three Elasto-Plastic Models under Repeated Loads

The constitutive model is the crucial part for the finite element analyses. To study the elasto-plastic properties of unbound granular materials (UGMs) under repeated vehicular loads, an elasto-plastic constitutive model called revised spatially mobilized plane (SMP) was proposed and validated. In this study, the revised SMP model was used for the plastic strain analyses of a typical three-layer pavement structure. To make comparisons, the Mohr-Coulomb and Druck-Prager models were employed for the numerical computation. The results show that plastic tensile and compressive strains in the horizontal and vertical directions appear on the top surface of UGM using the revised SMP model, but no plastic strains are produced by the Mohr-Coulomb and Druck-Prager models. The distribution of plastic strains in the revised SMP model had a good relationship with the actual loading areas under the vehicular loading, which related to the rutting. With the Mohr-Coulomb and Druck-Prage models, a great plastic strain was produced during the first several loading cycles and hardly increased in the following loading cycles, while the plastic strain in the revised SMP model presented an obvious increasing tendency with increased loading cycles. The predicted permanent deformations of the revised SMP, Mohr-Coulomb and Druck-Prage models were 0.557 mm, 0.78 mm and 0.155 mm, respectively. Our work reveals that the Mohr-Coulomb model may over-predict and Druck-Prage model may under-predict the rutting of pavement in early loading stage and the results proved that the revised SMP model had advantages in the description of the plastic strain of UMG under repeated loads.