scholarly journals Unstable Flow in Repellent and Sub-critically Repellent Soils: Theory and Management Implications

Author(s):  
Rony Wallach ◽  
Tammo Steenhuis ◽  
Ellen R. Graber ◽  
David DiCarlo ◽  
Yves Parlange

Water repellency causes unstable wetting fronts that result in water moving in preferential flowpaths through homogeneous soils as well in structured soils where macropores enhance the preferential flow pattern. Water repellency is typically associated with extended water ponding on the soil surface, but we have found that repellency is important even before the water ponds. Preferential flow fingers can form under conditions where the contact angle is less than 90o, but greater than 0o. This means that even when the soil is considered wettable (i.e., immediate penetration of water), water distribution in the soil profile can be significantly non-uniform. Our work concentrated on various aspects of this subject, with an emphasis on visualizing water and colloid flow in soil, characterizing mathematically the important processes that affect water distribution, and defining the chemical components that are important for determining contact angle. Five papers have been published to date from this research, and there are a number of papers in various stages of preparation.

2008 ◽  
Vol 16 (3) ◽  
pp. 267 ◽  
Author(s):  
K. RASA ◽  
R. HORN ◽  
M. RÄTY

Water repellency (WR) delays soil wetting process, increases preferential flow and may give rise to surface runoff and consequent erosion. WR is commonly recognized in the soils of warm and temperate climates. To explore the occurrence of WR in soils in Finland, soil R index was studied on 12 sites of different soil types. The effects of soil management practice, vegetation age, soil moisture and drying temperature on WR were studied by a mini-infiltrometer with samples from depths of 0-5 and 5-10 cm. All studied sites exhibited WR (R index >1.95) at the time of sampling. WR increased as follows: sand (R = 1.8-5.0) < clay (R = 2.4-10.3) < organic (R = 7.9-undefined). At clay and sand, WR was generally higher at the soil surface and at the older sites (14 yr.), where organic matter is accumulated. Below 41 vol. % water content these mineral soils were water repellent whereas organic soil exhibited WR even at saturation. These results show that soil WR also reduces water infiltration at the prevalent field moisture regime in the soils of boreal climate. The ageing of vegetation increases WR and on the other hand, cultivation reduces or hinders the development of WR.;


2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Emilia Urbanek ◽  
Stefan H. Doerr

Abstract. Soil CO2 emissions are strongly dependent on water distribution in soil pores, which in turn can be affected by soil water repellency (SWR; hydrophobicity). SWR restricts infiltration and movement of water, affecting soil hydrology as well as biological and chemical processes. Effects of SWR on soil carbon dynamics and specifically on soil respiration (CO2 efflux) have been studied in a few laboratory experiments but they remain poorly understood. Existing studies suggest that soil respiration is reduced in water repellent soils, but the responses of soil CO2 efflux to varying water distribution created by SWR are not yet known. Here we report on the first field-based study that tests whether soil water repellency indeed reduces soil respiration, based on in situ field measurements carried out over three consecutive years at a grassland and pine forest site under the humid temperate climate of the UK. CO2 efflux was reduced on occasions when soil exhibited consistently high SWR and low soil moisture following long dry spells. However, the highest respiration rates occurred not when SWR was absent, but when SWR, and thus soil moisture, was spatially patchy, a pattern observed for the majority of the measurement period. This somewhat surprising phenomenon can be explained by SWR-induced preferential flow, directing water and nutrients to microorganisms decomposing organic matter concentrated in hot spots near preferential flow paths. Water repellent zones provide air-filled pathways through the soil, which facilitate soil-atmosphere O2 and CO2 exchanges. This study demonstrates that SWR have contrasting effects on CO2 fluxes and, when spatially-variable, can enhance CO2 efflux. Spatial variability in SWR and associated soil moisture distribution needs to be considered when evaluating the effects of SWR on soil carbon dynamics under current and predicted future climatic conditions.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Rony Wallach ◽  
Naaran Brindt

&lt;p&gt;Quantitative and Qualitative description of infiltration into soils in general and initially dry soils in particular those in which the hydraulic properties vary spatial and temporal have been challenging soil physicists and hydrologists. Water repellent soils, whose contact angle is higher than 40&amp;#176; and can even reach values that are greater than 90&amp;#176; (noted as hydrophobic soils) are an example of such challenge cases. Infiltration in these soils takes usually place along preferential flow pathways (noted as gravity-induced fingering), rather than in a laterally uniform moving wetting front. The water content and capillary pressure distributions along these fingers are non-monotonic with water accumulation behind the moving wetting front (noted as saturation overshoot) and a decreasing water content toward the soil surface. Being a parabolic-type partial differential equation, the Richards equation that is commonly used to model flow in soils can't handle such water content/pressure distributions. Many attempts have been made to modify the Richards equation to enable it to model the non-monotonic water content profiles. These attempts that are not based on the measurable soil properties that can highlight the physics that induces the formation of such non-monotonic distribution. &amp;#160;&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p&gt;A new conceptual modelling approach, noted as the moving-boundary approach, will be presented. This approach overcomes the existing theoretical gaps in the quantitative descriptions that have been suggested for the non-monotonic water content distribution in the gravity-induced fingers. The moving-boundary approach is based on the presumption that non-monotonicity in water content is formed by an intrinsic higher-than-zero contact angle. Note that non-zero contact angle have been rarely incorporated in models used for quantifying infiltration into field soils, in spite of the findings that most soils feature some degree of repellency. The verified moving-boundary solution will be used to demonstrate the synergistic effect of contact angle and incoming flux on the stability of 2D flow and its associated plume shapes. The physically-based moving-boundary approach fulfils several criteria raised by researchers to adequately describe gravity-driven unstable flow.&lt;/p&gt;&lt;p&gt;&amp;#160;&lt;/p&gt;


2013 ◽  
Vol 61 (1) ◽  
pp. 3-8 ◽  
Author(s):  
Joerg Bachmann ◽  
Marc-O. Goebel ◽  
Susanne K. Woche

Abstract Research of the last years pointed out that most soils are neither completely hydrophilic nor hydrophobic, but exhibit a subcritical level of water repellency (i.e. contact angle, CA > 0° and < 90°). Soil water repellency (SWR) is mainly caused by organic compounds of different origin and structure, showing the relevance of biofilms and organic coatings present at many particle surfaces. Despite the importance of SWR for hydraulic processes like preferential flow phenomena, generation of heterogeneous moisture patterns, or surface run-off generation, detailed investigations on the spatial variability of SWR at various scales have rarely been carried out. We introduce a new and easy-to-apply operation for measuring the spatial distribution of SWR using a modified sessile drop method for direct optical assessment of CA at a small scale. The specific objectives of this paper are to apply a sampling and preparation technique that preserves the original spatial arrangement of soil particles and to characterize soil wettability in terms of CA at a high spatial resolution. Results revealed that the sampling and preparation technique allows determination of CA at the millimeter scale using droplets of 1 μL volume. Direct measurement on grain surfaces of the sand fraction is possible for grain sizes > 300 μm using drop volumes down to 0.1 μL. Geostatistical evaluation showed that the measurement grid scale is below the range of spatial dependency for droplets of 1 μL volume, but not for measurements on single grains (pure nugget effect). Results show further that the small-scale differences in wettability, especially for CA < 90°, cannot be detected by the conventional WDPT test. From these findings it can be concluded that the proposed technique allows the identification of small-scale variations in wettability that may promote the formation of heterogeneous flow fields and moisture patterns in soil under unsaturated conditions.


2007 ◽  
Vol 23 (3) ◽  
pp. 238-244 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. Bryant ◽  
S. H. Doerr ◽  
G. Hunt ◽  
S. Conan

2017 ◽  
Vol 43 (4) ◽  
pp. 1831
Author(s):  
A. Papafotiou ◽  
C. Schütz ◽  
P. Lehmann ◽  
P. Vontobel ◽  
D. Or ◽  
...  

Infiltration and evaporation are governing processes for water exchange between soil and atmosphere. In addition to atmospheric supply or demand, infiltration and evaporation rates are controlled by the material properties of the subsurface and the interplay between capillary, viscous and gravitational forces. This is commonly modeled with semi-empirical approaches using continuum models, such as the Richards equation for unsaturated flow. However, preferential flow phenomena often occur, limiting or even entirely suspending the applicability of continuum-based models. During infiltration, unstable fingers may form in homogeneous or heterogeneous porous media. On the other hand, the evaporation process may be driven by the hydraulic coupling of materials with different hydraulic functions found in heterogeneous systems. To analyze such preferential flow processes, water distribution was monitored in infiltration and evaporation lab experiments using neutron transmission techniques. Measurements were performed in 2D and 3D, using homogeneous and heterogeneous setups. The experimental findings demonstrate the fingering effect in infiltration and how it is influenced by the presence of fine inclusions in coarse background material. During evaporation processes, the hydraulic coupling effect is found to control the evaporation rate, limiting the modeling of water balances between soil and surface based on surface information alone.


1992 ◽  
Vol 267 ◽  
Author(s):  
Guido Biscontin ◽  
P. Maravelaki ◽  
E. Zendri ◽  
A. Glisenti

The aim of the present work is to compare the protective effect of solvent and water dispersed products on marble, Lecce and Istria stones. This choice is justified by the need of products effective also from the ecological and toxicological point of view. To obtain these informations two tests have been chosen: contact angle and water absorption. The contact angle may, in theory, be considered a measure of the water repellency, since complete wetting implies a contact angle of 0° and absolutely no wetting an angle of 180°. This does not apply to the water absorption by capillarity test because the absorption variation may be caused by either the water repellency action of the treatments or by the pore filling. However this test may give practical information about the general effect of the treatments. Moreover, the effect of treatments on permeability was investigated by vapour permeability test. Protective effect was studied after application of the products and at various stages of artificial weathering.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
John Koestel ◽  
Lorenzo Garbari ◽  
Daniel Iseskog

&lt;p&gt;While the basic processes of water infiltration into soil are well understood, their details are difficult to quantify due to the opaque nature of soil. In this study, we investigated the potential and limitations of X-ray radiography to measure the water front progression in a narrow sample (15 &amp;#215; 15 &amp;#215; 1 cm) filled with dry soil under simulated rainfall of high intensity (53 mm/h). The temporal resolution of the acquired infiltration movies was 133 milliseconds. We evaluated three different kinds of soil samples. i) Bare samples filled with a 1:1 mixture of a sandy loam and peat. ii) The same soil-peat mixture, but cropped with &lt;em&gt;Trifolium incarnatum&lt;/em&gt;, &lt;em&gt;Trifolium repens&lt;/em&gt;, &lt;em&gt;Lathyrus odoratus&lt;/em&gt; and &lt;em&gt;Lupinus regalis&lt;/em&gt;, all of them plants that have been reported to induce water repellency; prior to the experiments, the plants were harvested and only the roots remained in place. iii) Sandy loam soil that had been incubated for four weeks in an outside garden plot. Due to time limitations of the project, the incubation period was in early spring, which meant that plant growth in the samples was negligible. All three sample types were replicated five times, resulting in 15 individual samples. We carried out the infiltration experiments in four-fold replications, from which it follows that we collected 60 individual infiltration movies. After each infiltration round, the samples were placed in a drying room to reset them to a similar initial moisture content. The experiments aimed at testing i) whether the infiltration patterns of the four consecutive infiltration runs conducted on each sample remained identical and ii) to document differences in infiltration patterns between bare, cropped and incubated samples. We found that increasing X-ray scattering with increasing soil water contents made it challenging to evaluate the image data quantitatively. Advantages of our setup are that X-ray captures the complete water content at a specific depth and that sample boxes with irregularly shaped walls can be used to prevent preferential flow along the walls. Preliminary analyses of the data showed that the infiltration fronts in the bare and the incubated samples were less uniform than the ones for the cropped samples. In contrast, the likelihood of observing the same infiltration pattern in all four consecutive infiltration runs was larger for the bare and the incubated samples. The latter fact may have been caused by the interaction with root exudates in the cropped samples that may have been redistributed or mineralized during the wetting-drying cycles. We conclude that the here presented setup has large potential to investigate unstable infiltration phenomena into soil after an image correction approach has been developed that removes X-ray scattering artifacts. Alternatively, scattering may be suppressed by using a collimator during image acquisition.&lt;/p&gt;


2008 ◽  
Vol 3 (Special Issue No. 1) ◽  
pp. S155-S164 ◽  
Author(s):  
N.A Wahl

Soil water repellency has important consequences for ecological and hydrological properties of soils and usually retards infiltration capacity and induces preferential flow. This phenomenon has been known to occur on a wide range of sites under a variety of climatic conditions. The objective of this study was to investigate and characterize soil water repellency on forest sites with identical substrate and climatic conditions, differing in tree age and species. In the Vester Torup Klitplantage, an area comprising a conifer dominated forest plantation stocking on sandy deposits in a coastal setting near the Jammer Bay in north-western Jutland/Denmark, four different forest plots were investigated for water repellency effects four times in 2005. To measure soil water repellency, the water drop penetration time test and the critical surface tension test were carried out. Both tests revealed a seasonal variability in water repellency, exhibiting the highest water repellency for the upper 10 cm of the soil during the summer months, whereas the variability between the different plots seems to be less significant. There was no coherence between humus forms, thickness of litter layer and water repellency.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document