Evolution of Fatigue-Resistant Steel Bridges

Author(s):  
John W. Fisher

Fatigue cracking was seldom found in welded highway and railroad bridges from the time of their introduction in the 1950s until the late 1960s. The fatigue design specifications used in that era were developed from a limited knowledge base and largely with small-scale specimens that simulated welded details. During the AASHO Road Test in 1960 fatigue cracks were observed to develop in cover-plated steel bridge beams as a result of the heavy loads and high stress ranges. This observation subsequently resulted in a series of experimental studies supported by NCHRP starting in 1967. The laboratory studies with full-scale details were designed to evaluate the significance of many factors thought to influence fatigue resistance, including loading history (and associated stress states including residual stresses), type of steel, design details, and quality of fabrication. These studies indicated that small-scale specimens overestimated fatigue resistance and that only the stress range for a given detail was critical. As a result fatigue resistance design provisions in use since the 1950s were inadequate and overly optimistic, particularly at longer lives, because the assumption of a fatigue limit of 2 million cycles proved to be incorrect. The results of laboratory studies with full-size specimens and their impact on changing the concept of fatigue design and the bridge fatigue design provisions used for highway and railroad bridges today are reviewed. During the 1970s and 1980s fatigue cracking associated with low-fatigue-strength details (Categories E and E′), such as cover plates and lateral gusset plates, increased. Cracks were also found in transverse groove welds, particularly in attachments such as longitudinal stiffeners, gusset plates and even flange splices. These groove weld cracks generally occurred because large defects were inadvertently fabricated into the welded joint. The occurrence of these cracks was found to be predictable and in agreement with the laboratory fatigue resistance results. The 1970s also exposed an unexpected source of cracking due to the distortion of small web gaps that were frequently used in welded bridge structures. Web gap cracking continues to develop in a wide range of bridge types. It is the source of most fatigue cracks in steel bridges. Existing bridges that are susceptible to fatigue cracks or that develop fatigue cracks at primary details or from web gap distortion are easily repaired or retrofitted to ensure long-term performance. Examples of such repairs are reviewed. The future is bright for welded bridges because the knowledge base and current design provisions make it possible to design and build fatigue-resistant bridges.

Author(s):  
Hiroyuki Takamori ◽  
John W. Fisher

Two large-scale fatigue test studies of plate girders are reported on. One study involved a series of coverplated bridge girders with small fatigue cracks that were retrofitted in 1976 as described in NCHRP Report 206. The second study involved plate girders fabricated from HPS-485W (HPS-70W) steel with welded attachments. The Category E’ coverplated beams that were removed from the I-95 Yellow Mill Pond Bridge in 1997 had been retrofitted in 1976 by either air hammer peening or gas tungsten arc (GTA) remelting. All details had small fatigue cracks at the time of retrofit. No further fatigue cracking was observed at the coverplate ends after 20 years of service and an estimated 56 million truck passages. The beams were tested at a stress range of 69 MPa (10 ksi). Cracks developed from the root of the transverse end weld and propagated through the weld throat. The fatigue resistance of the treated weld toe details improved to Category C except for one GTA-remelted detail, which exceeded Category D. Another study was carried out on large-scale HPS-485W plate girders with as-welded and ultrasonic-impact treatment (UIT) details. UIT was applied to the weld toe of transverse stiffeners welded to the web and flanges (Category C) and to coverplated ends (Category E’). The as-welded details cracked at their expected fatigue resistance. The UIT transverse stiffeners improved to Category B fatigue resistance, whereas the UIT coverplated details improved to Category C fatigue resistance.


Metals ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 10 (1) ◽  
pp. 101 ◽  
Author(s):  
Siyuan Ma ◽  
Ti Zhou ◽  
Hong Zhou ◽  
Geng Chang ◽  
Benfeng Zhi ◽  
...  

Nodular iron brake discs typically fail due to serious thermal fatigue cracking, and the presence of graphite complicates the repair of crack defects in ductile iron. This study presents a novel method for remanufacturing ductile iron brake discs based on coupled bionics to repair thermal fatigue cracks discontinuously using bio-inspired crack blocking units fabricated by laser remelting at various laser energy inputs. Then, the ultimate tensile force and thermal fatigue crack resistance of the obtained units were tested. The microhardness, microstructure, and phases of the units were characterized using a digital microhardness meter, optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and X-ray diffraction. It was found that the units without defects positively impacted both the thermal fatigue resistance and tensile strength. The unit fabricated at a laser energy of 165.6 − 15 + 19 J/ mm 2 had sufficient depth to fully close the crack, and exhibited superior anti-cracking and tensile properties. When the unit distance is 3 mm, the sample has excellent thermal fatigue resistance. In addition, the anti-crack mechanism of the units was analysed.


2017 ◽  
Vol 1 (20) ◽  
pp. 63-74 ◽  
Author(s):  
Arkadiusz Rychlik ◽  
Krzysztof Ligier

This paper discusses the method used to identify the process involving fatigue cracking of samples on the basis of selected vibration signal characteristics. Acceleration of vibrations has been chosen as a diagnostic signal in the analysis of sample cross section. Signal characteristics in form of change in vibration amplitudes and corresponding changes in FFT spectrum have been indicated for the acceleration. The tests were performed on a designed setup, where destruction process was caused by the force of inertia of the sample. Based on the conducted tests, it was found that the demonstrated sample structure change identification method may be applied to identify the technical condition of the structure in the aspect of loss of its continuity and its properties (e.g.: mechanical and fatigue cracks). The vibration analysis results have been verified by penetration and visual methods, using a scanning electron microscope.


Metals ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (5) ◽  
pp. 709
Author(s):  
Uwe Zerbst ◽  
Mauro Madia ◽  
Giovanni Bruno ◽  
Kai Hilgenberg

The safe fatigue design of metallic components fabricated by additive manufacturing (AM) is still a largely unsolved problem. This is primarily due to (a) a significant inhomogeneity of the material properties across the component; (b) defects such as porosity and lack of fusion as well as pronounced surface roughness of the as-built components; and (c) residual stresses, which are very often present in the as-built parts and need to be removed by post-fabrication treatments. Such morphological and microstructural features are very different than in conventionally manufactured parts and play a much bigger role in determining the fatigue life. The above problems require specific solutions with respect to the identification of the critical (failure) sites in AM fabricated components. Moreover, the generation of representative test specimens characterized by similar temperature cycles needs to be guaranteed if one wants to reproducibly identify the critical sites and establish fatigue assessment methods taking into account the effect of defects on crack initiation and early propagation. The latter requires fracture mechanics-based approaches which, unlike common methodologies, cover the specific characteristics of so-called short fatigue cracks. This paper provides a discussion of all these aspects with special focus on components manufactured by laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF). It shows how to adapt existing solutions, identifies fields where there are still gaps, and discusses proposals for potential improvement of the damage tolerance design of L-PBF components.


1977 ◽  
Vol 103 (5) ◽  
pp. 1179-1181
Author(s):  
Roman Wolchuk ◽  
Ronald M. Mayrbaurl

Materials ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (18) ◽  
pp. 5277
Author(s):  
Shiqi Wang ◽  
Huanyun Zhou ◽  
Xianhua Chen ◽  
Minghui Gong ◽  
Jinxiang Hong ◽  
...  

Semi-flexible pavement (SFP) is widely used in recent years because of its good rutting resistance, but it is easy to crack under traffic loads. A large number of studies are aimed at improving its crack resistance. However, the understanding of its fatigue resistance and fatigue-cracking mechanism is limited. Therefore, the semi-circular bending (SCB) fatigue test is used to evaluate the fatigue resistance of the SFP mixture. SCB fatigue tests under different temperature values and stress ratio were used to characterize the fatigue life of the SFP mixture, and its laboratory fatigue prediction model was established. The distribution of various phases of the SFP mixture in the fracture surface was analyzed by digital image processing technology, and its fatigue cracking mechanism was analyzed. The results show that the SFP mixture has better fatigue resistance under low temperature and low stress ratio, while its fatigue resistance under other environmental and load conditions is worse than that of asphalt mixture. The main reason for the poor fatigue resistance of the SFP mixture is the poor deformation capacity and low strength of grouting materials. Furthermore, the performance difference between grouting material and the asphalt binder is large, which leads to the difference of fatigue cracking mechanism of the SFP mixture under different conditions. Under the fatigue load, the weak position of the SFP mixture at a low temperature is asphalt binder and its interface with other materials, while at medium and high temperatures, the weak position of the SFP mixture is inside the grouting material. The research provides a basis for the calculation of the service life of the SFP structure, provides a reference for the improvement direction of the SFP mixture composition and internal structure.


2016 ◽  
Vol 31 (2) ◽  
pp. 97-123 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alfred Krzywicki ◽  
Wayne Wobcke ◽  
Michael Bain ◽  
John Calvo Martinez ◽  
Paul Compton

AbstractData mining techniques for extracting knowledge from text have been applied extensively to applications including question answering, document summarisation, event extraction and trend monitoring. However, current methods have mainly been tested on small-scale customised data sets for specific purposes. The availability of large volumes of data and high-velocity data streams (such as social media feeds) motivates the need to automatically extract knowledge from such data sources and to generalise existing approaches to more practical applications. Recently, several architectures have been proposed for what we callknowledge mining: integrating data mining for knowledge extraction from unstructured text (possibly making use of a knowledge base), and at the same time, consistently incorporating this new information into the knowledge base. After describing a number of existing knowledge mining systems, we review the state-of-the-art literature on both current text mining methods (emphasising stream mining) and techniques for the construction and maintenance of knowledge bases. In particular, we focus on mining entities and relations from unstructured text data sources, entity disambiguation, entity linking and question answering. We conclude by highlighting general trends in knowledge mining research and identifying problems that require further research to enable more extensive use of knowledge bases.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document