Influence of Very Low Interfacial Tensions on Relative Permeability

1980 ◽  
Vol 20 (05) ◽  
pp. 391-401 ◽  
Author(s):  
D.G. Longeron

Abstract Laboratory studies have been conducted to determine the influence of the composition of gas and oil phases on the parameters involved in the description of two-phase flow in porous media when the compositions of the phases vary over a wide range. Relative permeabilities to gas and oil were determined under high pressure and temperature for binary systems (methane/n-heptane, methane/n-decane, etc.), leading to very wide variations of the interfacial tensions values. Investigations were focused specifically on mixtures involving low interfacial tensions, down to 0.001 mN/m. This study has shown that residual oil saturations and relative permeabilities determined from the displacement tests with a filtration velocity of about 20 cm/hr are affected strongly by interfacial tension, especially when it is lower than 10-2 mN/m. Introduction This study deals with the influence of the compositions of the liquid and vapor phases in equilibrium on displacements of oil by gas in porous media. One of the goals of high-pressure or enriched-gas injection is to obtain low interfacial tensions between the in-place oil and injected gas. During the displacement of gas in oil-bearing formations, multiple exchanges may take place between the liquid and vapor phases so that complete miscibility may be achieved. This phenomenon generally is called thermodynamic miscibility. During this process the interfacial tension is reduced progressively to zero. The resulting reduction in capillary forces makes it possible to decrease the residual oil saturation considerably. The same goal also is sought by other enhanced recovery techniques not examined here i.e., surfactant flooding or microemulsion flooding. The purpose of this study is to examine the influence of the thermodynamic conditions on the relative permeabilities in displacements of a liquid phase by a vapor phase when both phases are at equilibrium. The Problem The general equations describing the flows of two phases are the relative permeability equations. They show, for each phase, that the flow rate in a porous medium is a function of the absolute permeability, relative permeability to the fluid involved, fluid viscosity, pressure gradient in this phase, and gravity. In fact, relative permeabilities depend on a greater number of parameters.1 Some of them are the ratio of viscosities, µ2/µ1; the ratio of gravity to capillary forces (Bond number), (?2-?1)gk]/s; the ratio of the inertia forces to the viscosity forces (Reynolds number), (?1·u·k)/µ1; the ratio of the viscosity forces to the capillary forces (capillary number), (µ1·u)/s; and wettability. When they exist, exchanges between the phases can modify the physical and chemical properties of the fluids, especially at the interfaces. Under such conditions the influence of the capillary number (µ1·u)/s is by no means negligible, with the decrease in interfacial tension causing an increase in oil recovery.2 It may be thought that relative permeability to oil is closely dependent on this capillary number,3 especially when the value of s is small, and that this influence is principally apparent with low oil-saturation levels.

1982 ◽  
Vol 22 (03) ◽  
pp. 371-381 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jude O. Amaefule ◽  
Lyman L. Handy

Abstract Relative permeabilities of systems containing low- tension additives are needed to develop mechanistic insights as to how injected aqueous chemicals affect fluid distribution and flow behavior. This paper presents results of an experimental investigation of the effect of low interfacial tensions (IFT's) on relative oil/water permeabilities of consolidated porous media. The steady- and unsteady-state displacement methods were used to generate relative permeability curves. Aqueous low-concentration surfactant systems were used to vary IFT levels. Empirical correlations were developed that relate the imbibition relative permeabilities, apparent viscosity, residual oil, and water saturations to the interfacial tension through the capillary number (Nc=v mu / sigma). They require two empirical, experimentally generated coefficients. The experimental results show that the relative oil/water permeabilities at any given saturation are affected substantially by IFT values lower than 10-1 mN/m. Relative oil/water permeabilities increased with decreasing IFT (increasing N ). The residual oil and residual water saturations (S, and S) decreased, while the total relative mobilities increased with decreasing IFT. The correlations predict values of relative oil/water permeability ratios, fractional flow, and residual saturations that agree with our experimental data. Apparent mobility design viscosities decreased exponentially with the capillary number. The results of this study can be used with simulators to predict process performance and efficiency for enhanced oil-recovery projects in which chemicals are considered for use either as waterflood or steamflood additives. However, the combined effect of decreased interfacial tension and increased temperature on relative permeabilities has not yet been studied. Introduction Oil displacement with an aqueous low-concentration surfactant solution is primarily dependent on the effectiveness of the solutions in reducing the IFT between the aqueous phase and the reservoir oil. With the attainment of ultralow IFT's (10 mN/m) and with adequate mobility controls, all the oil contacted can conceivably be displaced. When the interfacial tension is reduced to near zero values, the process tends to approach miscible displacement. However, most high-concentration soluble oil systems revert to immiscible displacement processes as the injected chemical traverses the reservoir. This is a result of the continual depletion of the surfactant by adsorption on the rock and by precipitation with divalent cations in the reservoir brine. The mechanism by which residual oil is mobilized by low-tension displacing fluids cannot be explained solely by the application of Darcy's law to both the aqueous and the oleic phases. On the other hand, in those reservoir regions in which water and oil are flowing concurrently as continuous phases, Darcy's law would be expected to apply and the relative permeability concept would be valid. If a low-tension aqueous phase were to invade a region in which the oil had not as yet been reduced to a discontinuous irreducible saturation, one would expect, also, that the relative permeability concept would be applicable. Under circumstances for which these conditions apply, relative permeabilities at low interfacial tensions would be required, The effect of IFT's on relative permeability curves has received limited treatment in the petroleum literature. Leverett reported a small but definite tendency for a water/oil system in unconsolidated rocks to exhibit 20 to 30% higher relative permeabilities if the IFT was decreased from 24 to 5 mN/m. Mungan studied interfacial effects on oil displacement in Teflons cores. The interfacial tension values varied from 5 to 40 mN/m. SPEJ P. 371^


2000 ◽  
Vol 3 (02) ◽  
pp. 171-178 ◽  
Author(s):  
G.A. Pope ◽  
W. Wu ◽  
G. Narayanaswamy ◽  
M. Delshad ◽  
M.M. Sharma ◽  
...  

Summary Many gas-condensate wells show a significant decrease in productivity once the pressure falls below the dew point pressure. A widely accepted cause of this decrease in productivity index is the decrease in the gas relative permeability due to a buildup of condensate in the near wellbore region. Predictions of well inflow performance require accurate models for the gas relative permeability. Since these relative permeabilities depend on fluid composition and pressure as well as on condensate and water saturations, a model is essential for both interpretation of laboratory data and for predictive field simulations as illustrated in this article. Introduction Afidick et al.1 and Barnum et al.2 have reported field data which show that under some conditions a significant loss of well productivity can occur in gas wells due to near wellbore condensate accumulation. As pointed out by Boom et al.,3 even for lean fluids with low condensate dropout, high condensate saturations may build up as many pore volumes of gas pass through the near wellbore region. As the condensate saturation increases, the gas relative permeability decreases and thus the productivity of the well decreases. The gas relative permeability is a function of the interfacial tension (IFT) between the gas and condensate among other variables. For this reason, several laboratory studies3–14 have been reported on the measurement of relative permeabilities of gas-condensate fluids as a function of interfacial tension. These studies show a significant increase in the relative permeability of the gas as the interfacial tension between the gas and condensate decreases. The relative permeabilities of the gas and condensate have often been modeled directly as an empirical function of the interfacial tension.15 However, it has been known since at least 194716 that the relative permeabilities in general actually depend on the ratio of forces on the trapped phase, which can be expressed as either a capillary number or Bond number. This has been recognized in recent years to be true for gas-condensate relative permeabilities.8,10 The key to a gas-condensate relative permeability model is the dependence of the critical condensate saturation on the capillary number or its generalization called the trapping number. A simple two-parameter capillary trapping model is presented that shows good agreement with experimental data. This model is a generalization of the approach first presented by Delshad et al.17 We then present a general scheme for computing the gas and condensate relative permeabilities as a function of the trapping number, with only data at low trapping numbers (high IFT) as input, and have found good agreement with the experimental data in the literature. This model, with typical parameters for gas condensates, was used in a compositional simulation study of a single well to better understand the productivity index (PI) behavior of the well and to evaluate the significance of condensate buildup. Model Description The fundamental problem with condensate buildup in the reservoir is that capillary forces can retain the condensate in the pores unless the forces displacing the condensate exceed the capillary forces. To the degree that the pressure forces in the displacing gas phase and the buoyancy force on the condensate exceed the capillary force on the condensate, the condensate saturation will be reduced and the gas relative permeability increased. Brownell and Katz16 and others recognized early on that the residual oil saturation should be a function of the ratio of viscous to interfacial forces and defined a capillary number to capture this ratio. Since then many variations of the definition have been published,17–20 with some of the most common ones written in terms of the velocity of the displacing fluid, which can be done by using Darcy's law to replace the pressure gradient with velocity. However, it is the force on the trapped fluid that is most fundamental and so we prefer the following definition: N c l = | k → → ⋅ ∇ → ϕ l | σ l l ′ , ( 1 ) where definitions and dimensions of each term are provided in the nomenclature. Although the distinction is not usually made, one should designate the displacing phase l ? and the displaced phase l in any such definition. In some cases, buoyancy forces can contribute significantly to the total force on the trapped phase. To quantify this effect, the Bond number was introduced and it also takes different forms in the literature.20 One such definition is as follows: N B l = k g ( ρ l ′ − ρ l ) σ l l ′ . ( 2 ) For special cases such as vertical flow, the force vectors are collinear and one can just add the scalar values of the viscous and buoyancy forces and correlate the residual oil saturation with this sum, or in some cases one force is negligible compared to the other force and just the capillary number or Bond number can be used by itself. This is the case with most laboratory studies including the recent ones by Boom et al.3,8 and by Henderson et al.10 However, in general the forces on the trapped phase are not collinear in reservoir flow and the vector sum must be used. A generalization of the capillary and Bond numbers was derived by Jin 21 and called the trapping number. The trapping number for phase l displaced by phase l? is defined as follows: N T l = | k → → ⋅ ( ∇ → ϕ l ′ + g ( ρ l ′ − ρ l ) ∇ → D ) | σ l l ′ . ( 3 ) This definition does not explicitly account for the very important effects of spreading and wetting on the trapping of a residual phase. However, it has been shown to correlate very well with the residual saturations of the nonwetting, wetting, and intermediate-wetting phases in a wide variety of rock types.


1975 ◽  
Vol 15 (05) ◽  
pp. 376-384 ◽  
Author(s):  
R.M. Weinbrandt ◽  
H.J. Ramey ◽  
F.J. Casse

MEMBERS SPE-AIME Abstract Equipment was constructed to perform dynamic displacement experiments on small core samples under conditions of elevated temperature. Oil-water flowing fraction and pressure drop were recorded continuously for calculation of both the relative permeability ratio and the individual relative permeability ratio and the individual relative permeabilities. Imbibition relative permeabilities permeabilities. Imbibition relative permeabilities were measured for five samples of Boise sandstone at room temperature and at 175deg.F. The fluids used were distilled water and a white mineral oil. The effect of temperature on absolute permeability was investigated for six Boise sandstone samples and two Berea sandstone samples. Results for all samples were similar. The irreducible water saturation increased significantly, while the residual oil saturation decreased significantly with temperature increase. The individual relative permeability to oil increased for all water saturations below the room-temperature residual oil saturation, but the relative permeability to water at flood-out increased with permeability to water at flood-out increased with temperature increase. Absolute permeability decreased with temperature increase. Introduction Test environment is generally acknowledged to have a significant effect on measurement of relative permeability. The environment consists not only permeability. The environment consists not only of the temperature and pressure, but also of the fluids used and the core condition. Several workers have used the approach of completely simulating the reservoir conditions in the laboratory experiment. Such methods are termed "restored state." Restored state data are generally different from "room condition" data; since several variables are involved, it is difficult to determine the importance of each variable. Another approach used attributes the changes in relative permeability to changes in the rock-fluid interaction or wettability. Wettability, however, depends on many variables. Specifically, wettability depends on the composition of the rock surface, the composition of the fluids, the saturation history of the rock surface, and the temperature and pressure of the system. The purpose of this study is to isolate temperature as a variable in the relative permeability of a given rock-fluid system. Work on isolation of temperature as a variable in relative permeability has been conducted since the early 1960s. Edmondsons established results in 1965 for a Berea sandstone core using both water/refined oil and water/crude oil as fluid pairs. He showed a change in the relative permeability ratio accompanied by a decrease in the residual oil saturation with temperature increase. Edmondson showed no data for water saturations below 40 percent, and his curves show considerable scatter in the middle saturation ranges. Edmondson's work was the only study to use consolidated cores to investigate the effect of temperature on relative permeability measurements. Poston et al. presented waterflood data for sand packs containing 80-, 99-, a nd 600-cp oil, and packs containing 80-, 99-, a nd 600-cp oil, and observed an increase in the individual relative permeabilities with temperature increase. The permeabilities with temperature increase. The increase in the oil and the water permeability was accompanied by an increase in irreducible water saturation and a decrease in the residual oil saturation with temperature increase. Poston et al. was the only work to present individual oil and water permeability. Davidsons presented results for displacement of No. 15 white oil from a sand pack by distilled water, steam, or nitrogen. However, he found little permeability-ratio dependence in the middle permeability-ratio dependence in the middle saturation ranges. Davidson, too, found a decrease in the residual oil saturation with temperature increase, but he did not include data on irreducible water saturation. SPEJ P. 376


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Subodh Gupta

Abstract The objective of this paper is to present a fundamentals-based, consistent with observation, three-phase flow model that avoids the pitfalls of conventional models such as Stone-II or Baker's three-phase permeability models. While investigating the myth of residual oil saturation in SAGD with comparing model generated results against field data, Gupta et al. (2020) highlighted the difficulty in matching observed residual oil saturation in steamed reservoir with Stone-II and Baker's linear models. Though the use of Stone-II model is very popular for three-phase flow across the industry, one issue in the context of gravity drainage is how it appears to counter-intuitively limit the flow of oil when water is present near its irreducible saturation. The current work begins with describing the problem with existing combinatorial methods such as Stone-II, which in turn combine the water-oil, and gas-oil relative permeability curves to yield the oil relative permeability curve in presence of water and gas. Then starting with the fundamentals of laminar flow in capillaries and with successive analogical formulations, it develops expressions that directly yield the relative permeabilities for all three phases. In this it assumes a pore size distribution approximated by functions used earlier in the literature for deriving two-phase relative permeability curves. The outlined approach by-passes the need for having combinatorial functions such as prescribed by Stone or Baker. The model so developed is simple to use, and it avoids the unnatural phenomenon or discrepancy due to a mathematical artefact described in the context of Stone-II above. The model also explains why in the past some researchers have found relative permeability to be a function of temperature. The new model is also amenable to be determined experimentally, instead of being based on an assumed pore-size distribution. In that context it serves as a set of skeletal functions of known dependencies on various saturations, leaving constants to be determined experimentally. The novelty of the work is in development of a three-phase relative permeability model that is based on fundamentals of flow in fine channels and which explains the observed results in the context of flow in porous media better. The significance of the work includes, aside from predicting results more in line with expectations and an explanation of temperature dependent relative permeabilities of oil, a more reliable time dependent residual oleic-phase saturation in the context of gravity-based oil recovery methods.


1982 ◽  
Vol 22 (01) ◽  
pp. 37-52 ◽  
Author(s):  
Jorge E. Puig ◽  
Elias I. Franses ◽  
Yeshayahu Talmon ◽  
H. Ted Davis ◽  
Wilmer G. Miller ◽  
...  

Abstract Surfactant waterflooding processes that rely on ultralow interfacial tensions suffer from surfactant retention by reservoir rock and from the need to avoid injectivity problems. New findings reported here open the possibility that by delivering the surfactant in vesicle form, more successful low-concentration, alcohol-free surfactant waterflooding processes can be designed. Basic studies of low concentration (less than 2 wt %) aqueous dispersions of lamellar liquid crystals of a model surfactant, Texas No. 1, have established the role of dispersed liquid crystallites in the achievement of ultralow tensions between oil and water. Recent work, including fast-freeze, cold-stage transmission electron microscopy (TEM), reveals that sonication both in the absence and the presence of sodium chloride converts particulate dispersions of Texas No. 1 into dispersions of vesicles, which are spheroidal bilayers or multilayers, less than 0.1 mum in diameter filled with aqueous phase. Vesicles ordinarily revert only very slowly to the bulk liquid crystalline state. We find, however, that their stability depends on their preparation and salinity history, and that contact with oil can accelerate greatly the reversion of a vesiculated dispersion and enable it to produce low tensions between oil and water. Tests with Berea cores show that surfactant retention and attendant pressure buildup can be reduced greatly by sonicating Texas No. 1 dispersions to convert liquid crystallites to vesicles. In simple core-flooding experiments both the unsonicated liquid crystalline dispersions and the sonicated vesicle dispersions are able to produce substantial amounts of residual oil. We point out implications and directions for further investigation. Introduction Methods of enhancing, petroleum recovery, especially tertiary recovery, following the primary and secondary stages, are under intense research and development. Among these are at least two classes of surfactant-based recovery methods-surfactant waterflooding and so-called micellar or microemulsion flooding. Gilliland and Conley suggest that of the various enhanced-recovery methods, surfactant waterflooding has the potential for the widest application in the U.S. Residual oil is trapped as blobs in porous rock by capillary forces. The number of mechanisms is limited both for reducing entrapment and for mobilizing that residual oil remaining entrapped, there by improving the microscopic displacement efficiency of a petroleum recovery process. Taber and Melrose and Brandner established that tertiary oil recovery by an immiscible flooding process is possible by increasing the capillary number, which measures the ratio of Darcy flow forces of mobilization to capillary forces of entrapment. In practice this can be achieved by lowering the oil-water interfacial tension to about 10 mN/m or less. That this is feasible in the surfactant waterflooding range-i.e. at surfactant concentration less than those characterizing the microemulsion flooding range-and in the absence of cosurfactants or cosolvents that typify microemulsions is well established. Gale and Sandvik suggested four criteria for selecting a surfactant for a tertiary oil-recovery process:low oil-water interfacial tension,low adsorption.compatibility with reservoir fluids, andlow cost. For a given oil and type of surfactant, it has been shown that the interfacial tensions are extremely sensitive to surfactant molecular weight. SPEJ P. 37^


1998 ◽  
Author(s):  
J.T. Edwards ◽  
M.M. Honarpour ◽  
R.D. Hazlett ◽  
M. Cohen ◽  
A. Membere ◽  
...  

2000 ◽  
Vol 3 (06) ◽  
pp. 473-479 ◽  
Author(s):  
R.E. Mott ◽  
A.S. Cable ◽  
M.C. Spearing

Summary Well deliverability in many gas-condensate reservoirs is reduced by condensate banking when the bottomhole pressure falls below the dewpoint, although the impact of condensate banking may be reduced due to improved mobility at high capillary number in the near-well region. This paper presents the results of relative permeability measurements on a sandstone core from a North Sea gas-condensate reservoir, at velocities that are typical of the near-well region. The results show a clear increase in mobility with capillary number, and the paper describes how the data can be modeled with empirical correlations which can be used in reservoir simulators. Introduction Well deliverability is an important issue in the development of many gas-condensate reservoirs, especially where permeability is low. When the well bottomhole flowing pressure falls below the dewpoint, condensate liquid may build up around the wellbore, causing a reduction in gas permeability and well productivity. In extreme cases the liquid saturation may reach values as high as 50 or 60% and the well deliverability may be reduced by up to an order of magnitude. The loss in productivity due to this "condensate banking" effect may be significant, even in very lean gas-condensate reservoirs. For example, in the Arun reservoir,1 the productivity reduced by a factor of about 2 as the pressure fell below the dewpoint, even though the reservoir fluid was very lean with a maximum liquid drop out of only 1% away from the well. Most of the pressure drop from condensate blockage occurs within a few feet of the wellbore, where velocities are very high. There is a growing body of evidence from laboratory coreflood experiments to suggest that gas-condensate relative permeabilities increase at high velocities, and that these changes can be correlated against the capillary number.2–8 The capillary number is a dimensionless number that measures the relative strength of viscous and capillary forces. There are several gas-condensate fields where simulation with conventional relative permeability models has been found to underestimate well productivity.1,9,10 To obtain a good match between simulation results and well-test data, it was necessary to increase the mobility in the near-well region, either empirically or through a model of the increase in relative permeability at high velocity. This effect can increase well productivity significantly, and in some cases may eliminate most of the effect of condensate blockage. Experimental Data Requirements Fevang and Whitson11 have shown that the key parameter in determining well deliverability is the relationship between krg and the ratio krg/ kro. When high-velocity effects are significant, the most important information is the variation of krg with krg/k ro and the capillary number Nc. The relevant values of krg/kro are determined by the pressure/volume/temperature (PVT) properties of the reservoir fluids, but typical values might be 10 to 100 for lean condensates, 1 to 10 for rich condensates, and 0.1 to 10 for near-critical fluids. There are various ways of defining the capillary number, but in this paper we use the definition (1)Nc=vgμgσ, so that the capillary number is proportional to the gas velocity and inversely proportional to interfacial tension (IFT). The capillary numbers that are relevant for well deliverability depend on the flow rate, fluid type, and well bottomhole pressure, but as a general rule, values between 10?6 and 10?3 are most important. Experimental Methods In a gas-condensate reservoir, there are important differences between the flow regimes in the regions close to and far from the well. These different flow regimes are reflected in the requirements for relative permeability data for the deep reservoir and near-well regions. Far from the well, velocities are low, and liquid mobility is usually less important, except in reservoirs containing very rich fluids. In the near-well region, both liquid and gas phases are mobile, velocities are high, and the liquid mobility is important because of its effect on the relationship between krg and krg/kro. Depletion Method. Relative permeabilities for the deep reservoir region are often measured in a coreflood experiment, where the fluids in the core are obtained by a constant volume depletion (CVD) on a reservoir fluid sample. Relative permeabilities are measured at decreasing pressures from the fluid dewpoint, and increasing liquid saturation. In this type of experiment, the liquid saturation cannot exceed the critical condensate saturation or the maximum value in a CVD experiment, so that it is not possible to acquire data at the high liquid saturations that occur in the reservoir near to the well. The "depletion" experiment provides relative permeability data that are relevant to the deep reservoir, but there can be problems in interpreting the results due to the effects of IFT. Changes in liquid saturation are achieved by reducing pressure, which results in a change of IFT. The increase in IFT as pressure falls may cause a large reduction in mobility, and Chen et al.12 describe an example where the condensate liquid relative permeability decreases with increasing liquid saturation. Steady-State Method. The steady-state technique can be used to measure relative permeabilities at the higher liquid saturations that occur in the near-well region. Liquid and gas can be injected into the core from separate vessels, allowing relative permeabilities to be measured for a wide range of saturations. Results of gas-condensate relative permeabilities measured by this technique have been reported by Henderson et al.2,6 and Chen et al.12 .


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document