Comment on “Quick Estimation of the Magnitude and Epicentral Distance Using the P Wave for Earthquakes in Iran” by Reza Heidari

Author(s):  
Sahar Nazeri ◽  
Jamaledin Baniamerian ◽  
Zaher Hossein Shomali
Keyword(s):  
1983 ◽  
Vol 73 (6A) ◽  
pp. 1835-1850
Author(s):  
Robert B. Herrmann ◽  
Andrzej Kijko

Abstract The applicaton of the Nutli (1973) definition of the mbLg magnitude to instruments and wave periods other than the short-period WWSSN seismograph is examined. The basic conclusion is that the Nuttli (1973) definition is applicable to a wider range of seismic instruments if the log10(A/T) term is replaced by log10A. For consistency and precision, the notation mbLg should be applied only to magnitudes based upon 1.0 Hz observations. The mbLg magnitude definition was constrained to be consistent with teleseismic P-wave mb estimates from four Central United States earthquakes. In general, for measurements made at a frequency f, the notation mLg(f) should be used, where m L g ( f ) = 2.94 + 0.833 log ⁡ 10 ( r / 10 ) + 0.4342 γ r + log ⁡ 10 A , and r is the epicentral distance in kilometers, γ is the coefficient of anelastic attenuation, and A is the reduced ground amplitude in microns. Given its stability when estimated from different instruments, the mLg(f) magnitude is an optimum choice for an easily applied, standard magnitude scale for use in regional seismic studies.


Solid Earth ◽  
2012 ◽  
Vol 3 (2) ◽  
pp. 339-354 ◽  
Author(s):  
S. C. Stähler ◽  
K. Sigloch ◽  
T. Nissen-Meyer

Abstract. Triplicated body waves sample the mantle transition zone more extensively than any other wave type, and interact strongly with the discontinuities at 410 km and 660 km. Since the seismograms bear a strong imprint of these geodynamically interesting features, it is highly desirable to invert them for structure of the transition zone. This has rarely been attempted, due to a mismatch between the complex and band-limited data and the (ray-theoretical) modelling methods. Here we present a data processing and modelling strategy to harness such broadband seismograms for finite-frequency tomography. We include triplicated P-waves (epicentral distance range between 14 and 30°) across their entire broadband frequency range, for both deep and shallow sources. We show that is it possible to predict the complex sequence of arrivals in these seismograms, but only after a careful effort to estimate source time functions and other source parameters from data, variables that strongly influence the waveforms. Modelled and observed waveforms then yield decent cross-correlation fits, from which we measure finite-frequency traveltime anomalies. We discuss two such data sets, for North America and Europe, and conclude that their signal quality and azimuthal coverage should be adequate for tomographic inversion. In order to compute sensitivity kernels at the pertinent high body wave frequencies, we use fully numerical forward modelling of the seismic wavefield through a spherically symmetric Earth.


Author(s):  
Yulin Chen ◽  
Sidao Ni ◽  
Baolong Zhang

Abstract The core mantle boundary (CMB) features the most dramatic contrast in the physical properties within the Earth and plays a fundamental role in the understanding of the dynamic evolution of the Earth’s interior. Seismic core phases such as PKKP sample large area of the lowermost mantle and the uppermost core, thus providing valuable information of the velocity structures on both sides of the CMB. Diffraction Waves Well Beyond Cutoff Distance (PKKPab) is one branch of the triplicated PKKP that can be observed beyond its ray theoretical cutoff distance as a result of diffraction along the CMB. The travel time and slowness of the diffracted PKKPab (denoted as PKKPabdiff) can be used to constrain the P-wave velocities at the lowermost mantle, thus have been investigated in numerous studies. Previous results (Rost and Garnero, 2006) suggest that most of the observations of the PKKPabdiff waves are in the epicentral distance range of 95°–105° (minor arc convention) (PKKPabdiff diffraction length less than 10°). However, high-frequency (∼1 Hz) synthetic seismograms show that the PKKPabdiff waveforms could be observable at distance down to 65°, which indicates that the PKKPabdiff signals could be detected at distances less than 95° in observations. To explore the distance ranges in which PKKPabdiff is observable, we collected global three-component broadband waveforms from 246 events with source depth deeper than 100 km and magnitude above M 6 from 2007 to 2017 available at the Incorporated Research Institutions for Seismology Data Management Center. We analyzed the slowness, polarization, and amplitude of the candidate PKKPabdiff signals, and found 95 events with clear PKKPabdiffsignals, with nearly 60% of the events show PKKPabdiff diffraction lengths greater than 10°, and the longest diffraction distance is beyond 20°. These newly identified PKKPabdiff waves would substantially augment the dataset of core phases for improvements of the CMB velocity models.


1974 ◽  
Vol 64 (6) ◽  
pp. 1887-1899
Author(s):  
George A. McMechan ◽  
Warren G. Workman

abstract The observed behavior of P-wave relative amplitudes, as a function of epicentral distance, between 10° and 35°, is controlled primarily by the velocity-depth structure of the upper mantle. P-wave synthetic seismograms calculated by the new quantized ray theory technique are used to determine theoretical log (A/T) versus log Δ curves from a number of upper mantle models. Maximum amplitude arrivals show less model dependence than the first arrivals in the same wave trains, and hence are more consistent magnitude indicators for regions where the upper mantle structure is poorly known. Log (A/T) versus log Δ curves vary considerably, but predictably, from model to model. This model-dependent variation can account for a major part of the large standard deviations usually associated with the calculation of magnitudes from body waves.


1989 ◽  
Vol 60 (3) ◽  
pp. 95-100 ◽  
Author(s):  
S.E. Hough ◽  
K. Jacob ◽  
R. Busby ◽  
P.A. Friberg

Abstract We present analysis of a magnitude 3.5 event which occurred at 9 km epicentral distance from a digital strong motion instrument operated by the National Center for Earthquake Engineering Research. Although the size of this isolated event is such that it can scarcely be considered to be a significant earthquake, a careful analysis of this high quality recording does yield several interesting results: 1) the S-wave spectra can be interpreted in terms of a simple omega-squared source spectrum and frequency-independent attenuation, 2) there is the suggestion of a poorly-resolved resonance in the P-wave spectrum, and perhaps most importantly, 3) the apparently simple S-wave spectra can be fit almost equally well with a surprisingly wide range of seismic corner frequencies, from roughly 5 to 25 Hz. This uncertainty in corner frequency translates into uncertainties in inferred Q values of almost an order of magnitude, and into uncertainties in stress drop of two orders of magnitude. Given the high quality of the data and the short epicentral distance to the station, we consider it likely that resolution of spectral decay and corner frequency will be at least as poor for any other recording of earthquakes with comparable or smaller magnitudes.


1982 ◽  
Vol 72 (4) ◽  
pp. 1351-1366
Author(s):  
J. R. Murphy ◽  
T. J. Bennett

abstract A new seismic discriminant based on spectral differences of regional phases from earthquakes and explosions recorded at a single station has been tested and found to work remarkably well. The test data consisted of a well-constrained set of 30 Nevada Test Site (NTS) explosions and 21 earthquakes located within about 100 km of NTS which were recorded on short-period seismographs at the Tonto Forest Observatory in central Arizona at an epicentral distance averaging 530 km. The events in the data set cover a magnitude range from 3.3 to 4.8 (mb) for which Pn, Pg, and Lg phases have been analyzed. We found that, although Lg phases from earthquakes are typically more prominent than for explosions with comparable P-wave amplitude levels, simple time-domain Lg/P amplitude ratios do not result in a separation of the earthquake and explosion samples consistent enough to provide reliable discrimination. However, spectral analyses of the data over the frequency band from 0.5 to 5.0 Hz revealed significant differences in the spectra of certain regional phases which proved to be a quite reliable discriminant. In particular, both the Pg and Lg spectra from earthquakes have been found to be richer in high-frequency content than corresponding explosion spectra. A discriminant measure, defined as the ratio of average Lg spectral amplitude level in the 0.5- to 1.0-Hz passband to that in the 2.0- to 4.0-Hz passband, provides good separation of earthquake and explosion populations.


1979 ◽  
Vol 69 (6) ◽  
pp. 1733-1744
Author(s):  
George A. McMechan

abstract A P-wave velocity profile for the upper mantle at depths between 200 and 800 km beneath Eastern United States has been constructed from a combination of data from natural and artificial sources. Data for this part of the upper mantle are scarce, particularly beyond 20° epicentral distance, because of the sparse distribution of relevant sources and stations. Nevertheless, this study is the first to use amplitude constraints in a model determination for this region, and the model that has been chosen can account for the main observed amplitude features as well as travel times. The resulting velocity profile is similar to those previously determined for the regions to the north and west, but has a broadening of velocity transitions relative to those in the western United States. Evidence is found for the existence of lateral velocity inhomogeneity within the mantle.


Author(s):  
Jingbao Zhu ◽  
Shanyou Li ◽  
Jindong Song

Abstract Accurately estimating the magnitude within the initial seconds after the P-wave arrival is of great significance in earthquake early warning (EEW). Over the past few decades, single-parameter approaches such as the τc and Pd methods have been applied to EEW magnitude estimation studies considering the first 3 s after the P-wave onset. However, these methods present considerable scatter and are affected by the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and epicentral distance. In this study, using Japanese K-NET strong-motion data, we propose a machine-learning method comprising multiple parameter inputs, namely, the support vector machine magnitude estimation (SVM-M) model, to determine earthquake magnitudes and resolve the aforementioned problems. Our results using a single seismological station record show that the standard deviation of the magnitude prediction errors of the SVM-M model is 0.297, which is less than those of the τc (1.637) and Pd (0.425) methods. The magnitudes estimated by the SVM-M model within 3 s after the P-wave arrival are not obviously affected by the SNR or epicentral distance, and not overestimated for MJMA≤5. In addition, in an offline EEW application, the magnitude estimation error of the SVM-M model gradually decreases with increasing time after the first station is triggered, and the underestimation of event magnitudes for 6.5≤MJMA gradually improves. These results demonstrate that the proposed SVM-M model can robustly estimate earthquake magnitudes and has potential for EEW.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document