On Frege’s ‘Modes of Presentation’ in Signs

2014 ◽  
Vol 10 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Abraham Solomonick

AbstractGottlob Frege introduced a new dimension to the characterization of signs - that of ‘mode of presentation’. The same referent may be represented by different signs and in different manners, revealing it with dissimilar depth and profundity. The mode of presentation varies due to the fact that the same denoted object changes in the course of time and under alternating circumstances, but also because people designating it have unequal means for doing so. Herein I undertake to explicate these facts as they occur in semiotic reality.

2021 ◽  
Vol 18 (3) ◽  
pp. 309-335
Author(s):  
Paolo Bonardi

Abstract It is usually maintained that a subject with manifestly contradictory beliefs is irrational. How can we account, then, for the intuitive rationality of dialetheists, who believe that some manifest contradictions are true? My paper aims to answer this question. Its ultimate goal is to determine a characterization of (or rather a constraint for) rational belief approvable by both the theorists of Dialetheism and its opponents. In order to achieve this goal, a two-step strategy will be adopted. First, a characterization of rational belief applicable to non-dialetheist believers will be determined; this characterization will involve the semantic apparatus of Nathan Salmon’s Millian Russellianism but will get rid of the problematic and obscure notion of mode of presentation (guise in his own terminology), replacing it with a couple of novel devices, belief subsystems and cognitive coordination. Second, using ideas from Graham Priest, the leading proponent of Dialetheism, such a characterization will be modified, so as to devise a new one able to account for the intuitive rationality of both dialetheist and non-dialetheist believers.


1984 ◽  
Vol 59 (3) ◽  
pp. 959-965 ◽  
Author(s):  
Robert M. Godley ◽  
Robert E. Estes ◽  
Glenn P. Fournet

Researchers have continued to echo McGeoch and Irion's (1952) statement concerning the superiority of the auditory modality for young children and the visual modality for older children in paired-associate learning despite conflicting results. In the present study, in which the performance of second and fifth grade children on a paired-associate task under 6 different modes of presentation was compared, mode of presentation did not vary as a function of age. The picture/sound combined condition was superior to the sound and printed/spoken-word conditions but provided no advantage over the picture condition alone. No significant differences were found among the printed-word, spoken-word, and combined printed/spoken-word conditions. Difficulties in making comparisons among studies because methods differed and implications for further research were discussed.


Author(s):  
G. Neil Martin ◽  
Sharon J. Sadler ◽  
Clare E. Barrett ◽  
Alison Beaven

AbstractPsychological studies of responses to humor employ a variety of different recording methods and modes of presentation, but few have addressed whether these methodological differences affect people's responses to comedy. In the present study, participants' expressive (laughter and smiling) and cognitive (ratings of funniness and enjoyment) responses to a popular British comedy program presented via videotape, audiotape, or in script form were measured. Behavioral response was recorded either covertly or overtly by a video camera. Mode of presentation significantly affected behavioral response: the videotape and the audiotape conditions generated significantly greater laughter and smiling than did the script condition. Although the presence of the camera was not regarded as obtrusive, its presence did inhibit laughter and depressed enjoyment (but not amusement). The paper suggests that research using humorous material should carefully consider the mode of presentation and the behavioral recording conditions employed.


Author(s):  
Christopher McCarroll

When thinking about intentional states such as memory, there is a distinction drawn between “content” and “modes of presentation” of that content. How do field and observer perspectives relate to this distinction? By exploring the nature of first-personal de se thoughts, and how the self is represented in perspectival memory imagery, this chapter argues that field and observer perspectives are different ways of thinking about a particular past event. Field and observer perspective memories can have the same intentional object, in that they can be about the same past event, but they involve different modes of presentation of that past event. This chapter looks at how the mode of presentation affects the content of memory, and it shows that the self-presence of remembering from-the-outside is provided implicitly by the mode of presentation.


Author(s):  
Korey Johnson ◽  
Steffen Werner

Current authentication strategies seek to increase security by requiring users to create more secure alphanumeric passwords. Unfortunately, the inverse relationship between alphanumeric password security and memorability prevents users from being able to create a password that is both secure and memorable. Graphical user authentication mechanisms have been explored as a means to maintain security while enhancing memorability of passcodes. Current approaches often use unrelated picture sets from which participants have to remember a subset, with mixed results. The study outlined in this paper seeks to further validate the Composite Scene Authentication (CSA) graphical passcode mechanism (Johnson & Werner, 2006). Extending retention intervals and increasing the variability of stimuli clearly demonstrated the superiority of CSA over alphanumerical passwords. In addition, we manipulated the mode of presentation (serial vs. composite) to assess the memorability of stimuli presented in different temporal formats. In the current study CSA passcodes consisting of nine categorical dimensions were compared to nine character alphanumeric passwords. Participants showed a strong advantage in passcode retention of graphical passcodes for both modes of presentation. This effect grew larger with increasing retention intervals. At the longest retention interval (6 weeks), only 10 (12%) participants were able to produce their alphanumerical password vs. 50 (60%) participants who were still able to produce the correct graphical passcode.


2015 ◽  
Vol 5 (10) ◽  
pp. 123
Author(s):  
Eduardo Antônio Pitt

Neste artigo daremos principal atenção aos dois critérios de identidade de conteúdo conceitual que estão presentes nos §§ 3 e 8 da Conceitografia de Gottlob Frege. Nosso propósito é analisar as características destes critérios da notação conceitual de Frege porque pretendemos delimitar a discussão em torno dos problemas relacionados às noções de identidade intensional e extensional. Dessa forma, pretendemos: (i) analisar os critérios de identidade de conteúdo conceitual presentes nos §§ 3 e 8 da Conceitografia com o objetivo de mostrar que Frege apresentou uma caracterização híbrida da noção de conteúdo conceitual (valor semântico) e (ii) fazer considerações a respeito de relações que podemos estabelecer entre os critérios intensionais e extensionais de Frege e Richard Kirkham presentes no livro Teorias da Verdade: Uma Introdução Crítica. Com tais comparações pretendemos averiguar: (iii) se o critério de identidade do § 8 da Conceitografia é idêntico ao critério extensional de equivalência material de Kirkham e (iv) se o critério de identidade do § 3 da Conceitografia é mais forte, mais fraco ou idêntico aos critérios intensionais de equivalência essencial e de equivalência de sinonímia de Kirkham.Abstract: In this paper we will give primary attention to two identity criteria of conceptual content that are present in §§ 3 and 8 of Gottlob Frege's Begriffsschrift. Our purpose is to analyze the characteristics of these criteria of conceptual notation of Frege because we want to delimit the discussion around problems related to the notions of intensional and extensional identity. Thus, we intend to: (i) analyze the identity criteria of conceptual content present in §§ 3 and 8 of Begriffsschrift aiming to show that Frege introduced a hybrid characterization of the notion of conceptual content (semantic value) and (ii) make considerations about the relationships that we establish between intensional and extensional criteria of Frege and Richard Kirkham present in the book Theories of Truth: A Critical Introduction. With such comparisons we intend to investigate: (iii) if the identity criterion of § 8 of Begriffsschrift is identical to the extensional criterion of material equivalence in Kirkham and (iv) if the identity criterion of § 3 of Begriffsschrift is stronger, weaker or identical to intensional criteria of essential equivalence and of synonyms equivalence of Kirkham. Key words: Identity, Intensional Criterion, Extensional Criterion.


1983 ◽  
Vol 56 (2) ◽  
pp. 387-396 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ron Gold

Stein and Glenn's (1979) story schema provided the framework for testing reading disabled adults' recall of stories that they had heard on tape, read orally, or read silently. For each category of proposition in the story schema, no significant difference was found in the proportion of statements recalled across the three modes of presentation. Further, the pattern of recall of different categories was similar to that which had been exhibited in previous research by normally reading children who heard stories on tape. The findings provide further evidence that the pattern of recall of story schema categories is similar across a variety of subject groups and situations. A possible explanation of this is discussed, as are possible explanations of the specific recall pattern obtained.


2020 ◽  
Vol 4 (Supplement_1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Jonathan Poirier ◽  
Catherine Alguire ◽  
Nadia Gagnon ◽  
Mathieu Latour ◽  
André Lacroix ◽  
...  

Abstract Context: Adrenocortical carcinoma (ACC) is a rare tumor with an incidence of 0.7-2 per million. Based on the ENSAT staging classification, tumor stage is the most important prognostic factor; the presence of lymph nodes involvement and metastases is an indicator of poor prognosis. Absence of any local or distant tumor invasion represents an early stage disease and is classified based on tumor size of <5 cm (stage I) or >5 cm (stage II). Advanced disease is confirmed if there is tumoral invasion, either locally in the surrounding tissues/nodes (stage III) or in other organs/vascular structures (stage IV). Objective: To describe patient characteristics, staging and modes of presentation at initial diagnosis in our cohort of ACC patients. Methods: We retrospectively reviewed paper and electronic charts of patients with pathology-confirmed ACCs who were treated at our referral center from 1995 to May 2019. Results: One hundred four patients were diagnosed with ACC: 28 were men (26.9%) and 76 (73.1%) were women and median age was 51 years. The overall modes of presentation were hormonal hypersecretion (40.4%), mass-related symptoms (36.5%), incidentalomas (17.3%) and unknown (1.9%). Hormonal profile was available for 71 tumors: 67,6 % were secreting [androgen and cortisol co-secretion (39.4%), cortisol only (28.2%)] and 18,3% were non-secreting. At initial diagnosis, sixty-four patients (61.5%) had tumors >10 cm including 32.7% between 10-14.9 cm (n:34), 19.2% were 15-20 cm (n:20) and 9.6% were >20cm (n:10). Initial ENSAT stages were I (6.7%), II (17.3%), III (28.8%) and IV (44.2%) and unknown (2,9%). The age repartition was similar for most patients (median ~50 yo) regardless of disease stage or tumor size except in the subgroup of very large tumors (>20 cm) for which the median age was 40 yo. The mode of presentation at initial diagnosis varied at various stages. Incidentaloma was a frequent mode of presentation of earlier ACC stages; Stage 1: 3/7 (42,9%), stage II: 7/18 (38,9%), stage III: 4/30 (13,3%) and stage IV: 4/46 (8,7%). Hormonal excess symptoms led to ACC diagnosis less frequently in early stages (stages I and II) (24%) than in later stages (stage III and IV) (47,3%), while the hormonal work up showed high prevalence of secreting tumors in both groups (58,8% and 88,7%). Mass-related initial symptoms were similar in both groups 36% vs 39%. Conclusions: In our cohort, 61.5% of ACC tumors were larger than 10 cm at initial diagnosis. Seventy-three percent of ACC patients had an advanced ENSAT stage III or IV disease which is associated with a 5 years survival of less than 50%. Incidentalomas is a frequent mode of presentation in stages I and II, while clinical hormonal excess symptoms were more frequent in later stages III and IV. Early stage diagnosis presents a difficult challenge in ACC and new biomarkers are needed to improve the odds against this deadly cancer.


1975 ◽  
Vol 40 (3) ◽  
pp. 955-960 ◽  
Author(s):  
Charles L. Fry

16 college males participated in a study exploring active and passive illusions in touch. Analogs to 2 primary and 2 secondary visual illusions were constructed for active and for passive tactual presentation. Tactual illusory effects similar to those one would predict from vision were found in the active mode of presentation of the Müller-Lyer, and horizontal-vertical conditions, while opposite effects were found in the active mode of presentation of a modification of Delboeuf circles and in the passive diamond-square and horizontal-vertical conditions ( ps < .02). Analogous primary and secondary illusory results interacted with the active and passive modes of presentation.


2021 ◽  
pp. 177-234
Author(s):  
Kenneth A. Taylor

This chapter champions the priority of objectual representations and reference to the world over fine-grained “inner” mental representations. The main argument rests upon demonstrating that our attitude ascriptions practices give priority to de re ascriptions of mental contents over de dicto ascriptions of mental contents. The argument thereby advances a rejection of the Fregean tradition that construes modes of presentations of objects as essential to the characterization of mental contents within attitude ascriptions. A novel argument is advanced invoking the evaluative commitments expressed with embedded referential slurring terms in argument position, showing them to reveal derogatory attitudes of the ascriber, not the ascribee, and then showing by analogy that the same obtains for existential and referential commitments: they do not typically invoke Fregean modes of presentation by which the ascribee cognizes the world. The chapter ends by reexamining substitution puzzles and the nature of de re belief.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document