Results and Outcome of Retroperitoneal Lymph Node Dissection for Clinical Stage I Embryonal Carcinoma–Predominant Testis Cancer

PURPOSE: To determine the incidence of metastatic disease and usage of chemotherapy (adjuvant or metastatic) after primary retroperitoneal lymph node dissection (RPLND) in patients with clinical stage (CS) I embryonal carcinoma (EC)–predominant testicular cancer. EC predominance was defined as the presence of EC at a level greater than that of any other histologic diagonsis. PATIENTS AND METHODS: All CS I patients with nonseminomatous germ cell tumors who underwent RPLND at Indiana University from 1990 to 1995 were reviewed retrospectively. RESULTS: Two-year follow-up was available for 292 of 320 patients. EC-predominant disease was found in 125 (42.8%) of 292. Eighty-five (68.0%) of 125 patients with EC-predominant disease had pathologic stage (PS) I, and 18 (21.2%) of this group of 85 relapsed. A significantly lower PS I relapse rate of 3% was found for patients who had non–EC-predominant disease (P < .0001). PS II disease was more frequent in patients with EC predominance, as 40 (32.0%) of 125 had retroperitoneal metastases, compared with 26 (15.6%) of 167 patients with a non–EC-predominant histologic diagnosis (P = .0024). Chemotherapy was administered to 48 (38.4%) of the 125 patients with CS I EC-predominant disease after RPLND. This included 25 CS I patients with PS II disease who received adjuvant chemotherapy in addition to 23 patients who subsequently required chemotherapy for relapse after RPLND. Ten (66.6%) of 15 PS II EC-predominant patients were cured by surgery alone. Currently, all 125 EC-predominant patients are disease-free. CONCLUSION: Patients with CS I EC-predominant disease are at a relatively high risk for metastatic disease.