Reply by the authors to Nobes, Schneider, and Hodgson
We agree with Nobes et al. that our own bias, like theirs, is that “If at all possible equations relating one physical property to another should be based on some physical model,” but in addition we believe also that such a model must be correct, or at least physically sound. It is on the issue of the soundness of the traveltime average model that we fundamentally disagree with Nobes et al.
1980 ◽
Vol 102
(4)
◽
pp. 181-183
◽
Keyword(s):
1989 ◽
Vol 47
◽
pp. 778-779
Keyword(s):
2009 ◽
Vol 23
(2)
◽
pp. 63-76
◽
2010 ◽
Vol 48
(10)
◽
pp. 951-956
◽
Keyword(s):
2017 ◽
Vol 25
(101)
◽
pp. 177-192
2020 ◽
Vol 140
(1)
◽
pp. 1-8