On: “Ultrasonic velocity and anisotropy of hydrocarbon source rocks” by L. Vernik and A. Nur (May 1992 GEOPHYSICS, p. 727‐735)
Vernik and Nur have reported anisotropy parameters for the Bakken formation determined from ultrasonic measurements. Their paper showed that the Bakken shale is strongly anisotropic, exhibiting transverse isotropy with a vertical symmetry axis. A significant part of their conclusions were devoted to the apparently small values of Thomsen’s (1986) δ parameter for this rock, which is defined in terms of stiffness coefficients as [Formula: see text]For seismic exploration, δ is perhaps the most important of Thomsen’s three anisotropy parameters, since it influences both the P‐wave moveout velocity and the AVO slope near zero offset (Thomsen, 1986; Banik, 1987). However, as pointed out by Banik (1987), the numerical value of δ is highly sensitive to small errors in the elastic stiffnesses. Moreover, the magnitude of [Formula: see text], one of the required stiffness coefficients in (1), depends on the choice of phase or group velocity to interpret the measurements, as explained below.