On: “Proposed Attenuation‐Dispersion Pair for Seismic Waves” by J. E. White and D. J. Walsh (GEOPHYSICS, June 1972, p. 456–461)
Keyword(s):
In their paper, White and Walsh claim dispersion relations based upon an assumed minimum‐phase property of rock lead to such drastic low‐frequency behavior that any complex propagation function based upon dispersion relations is unacceptable. Since my power‐law model (Strick, 1967, 1970a) was placed in such a category, my response is as follows.