Height and foliar responses of white spruce and lodgepole pine seedlings to deep tillage of Gray Luvisols
Seedlings of lodgepole pine (Pinus contorta Dougl. ex Loud. var. latifolia Engelm.) and white spruce (Picea glauca (Moench) Voss) were grown for 8 years under five different levels of deep tillage. These were, in increasing order of disturbance: control, vibration ripping, deep plowing, deep plowing plus residue, and Marttiini plowing. Five-year growth curves of each tree were partitioned into three orthogonal components: mean, linear, and quadratic trends. Nitrogen and phosphorus concentrations and mass of the current-year needles were analyzed. Deep plowing plus residue significantly reduced pine heights relative to both vibration ripping and the control, whereas spruce heights were less in the control treatment than in the vibration-ripped treatment. Tillage treatments did not affect nitrogen or phosphorus concentrations of current-year pine or spruce needles. In pine, deep plowing plus residue treatment resulted in the lightest needles, and Marttiini plowing, deep plowing and control treatments resulted in the heaviest needles. In spruce, needle mass was lowest for the deep plowing plus residue treatment and similar among the other treatments. Vibration ripping of medium-textured, well to imperfectly drained Gray Luvisols may be recommended to increase spruce seedling height growth, but any of the deep-tillage treatments used cannot be recommended for pine.