Variation in field response of Pinussylvestris to nursery inoculation with four different ectomycorrhizal fungi
Pinussylvestris L. seedlings were inoculated in nursery containers with the assertive mycorrhizal formers Laccarialaccata (Scop, ex Fr.) Bk. & Br., Hebelomacrustuliniforme (Bull, ex Fr.) Quélet, and Cenococcumgeophilum Fr. After outplanting, seedling size and the frequency of mycorrhizal root tips were monitored over 6 years. Between 25 and 90% of the root tips of inoculated seedlings were mycorrhizal with the target fungi at outplanting, whereas the noninoculated control seedlings were spontaneously colonized by other fungi at rates between 25 and 50%. After 1.5 years the inoculated fungi were still present on the roots; however, they were slowly being replaced by indigenous forest species. In the nursery, most of the inoculations resulted in reduced seedling growth. This inhibition of growth rate was pronounced up to 1.5 years in the field, except for seedlings inoculated with C. geophilum. By this time, L. laccata and H. crustuliniforme inoculated seedlings were about 40 to 50% smaller in volume than the control seedlings, and the relative difference in size was maintained or slightly decreased during the following 4 years. The noninoculated nursery production seedlings were about 50% larger in volume than the corresponding control seedlings at outplanting. In the field, however, they grew relatively slower and consequently, were soon similar in volume to the control seedlings.