Phenotypic selection in Betulapapyrifera
Phenotypically superior trees of Betulapapyrifera Marsh, were identified on the basis of their breast height stem diameters in two even-aged stands in western Maine. The growth superiority of each of the candidate trees was evaluated further using one of three different selection methods. Two methods were based on mean annual volume increment and differed in regard to their use of comparison trees. Selected trees were those which grew the most volume throughout the life of the stand. In the third procedure, periodic basal area increment was compared with the estimated basal area increment using an equation incorporating crown surface area as an independent variable. Trees rated as most superior were those which produced the largest increment in relation to crown size. Open-pollinated progenies of selected and control trees were evaluated for height growth and stem diameter in a greenhouse trial. Although significant differences in height existed among the selection methods, no one method was successful in identifying trees whose progenies, as a group, were significantly taller than the average of the control progenies.