Five-year light, vegetation, and regeneration dynamics of boreal mixedwoods following silvicultural treatments to establish productive aspen–spruce mixtures in northeastern Ontario
Given the extent of boreal mixedwoods in Canada and the challenges of maintaining their conifer component following harvest, we investigated the effects of intimate mixtures versus a mosaic spatial arrangement on mixedwood establishment and growth in northeastern Ontario. The silvicultural treatments were preharvest aerial herbicide spray, postharvest ground herbicide in conifer corridors, partial cutting, conventional conifer plantation with postharvest aerial herbicide, and an untreated reference stand. Fifth-year results suggest that preharvest herbicide application followed by clearcutting controlled trembling aspen ( Populus tremuloides Michx.) regeneration density and height growth nearly as effectively as postharvest herbicide in conifer corridors or the conventional conifer plantation treatments. Partial cutting reduced aspen regeneration in both harvested and leave corridors but did not affect shrub cover. Survival of spruce regeneration did not differ among silvicultural treatments; however, more spruce seedlings progressed from small to intermediate height classes in the preharvest spray and partial cut than in the postharvest herbicide treatment plots. Based on short-term responses in light availability, vegetation cover, and regeneration as well as cost comparisons among options, the treatment objectives were generally met: the stand has the desired species density and composition of a healthy and productive mixedwood.