A study of the observable axial- and equatorial-2,4-dimethyl-2-adamantyl cations. Further examples of equilibrating nonclassical structures in "ordinary" tertiary carbocations
The title cations have been prepared insitu from the corresponding tertiary alcohols, using three different superacid systems. The 13C NMR spectra were measured at a number of different temperatures, using the structurally related 13C peaks of internal 2-methyl-2-adamantyl cation as a reference. Using this protocol, one finds that the 13C chemical shifts of the four β carbons are quite temperature dependent, two of them shifting to higher field and the other two on the opposite face shifting to lower field, or vice versa, as the temperature is increased or decreased. This behavior is uniquely ascribed to a rapid equilibration between two "structures" for each cation system. The two structures in question involve selective C–C hyperconjugative delocalization on one face or the other of the 2-adamantyl skeleton. In the case of the 4-equatorial-methyl isomer, a structure with C–C hyperconjugation on the methyl-substituted face is most stable, while for the 4-axial-methyl cation, the structure with delocalization from the face opposite the substituent is favored. The former preference is regarded as stereoelectronic in origin while the latter is ascribed to steric effects. Keywords: non-planar carbocations, temperature dependent NMR shifts, stereoelectronic effects.