Structures and stabilities of C2H2F3+ cations: an abinitio molecular orbital study
Eleven stationary points on the singlet C2H2F3+ potential energy surface have been calculated using the 3-21G basis set, and characterized as minima (four structures) or first-order saddle points (seven structures) by vibrational analysis. To check the reliability of this basis set, three of the structures have also been optimized at the 6-31G* level; although the geometries change somewhat, the relative energies and nature (maxima, minima) of the structures remain the same. For CF3CH2+ the minimum energy structure has one C—F bond coplanar with the vacant p-atomic orbital at the cationic centre. The structure is 16.4 kcal/mol less stable than the lowest energy conformation of FCH2CF2+, and the barrier for the 1,2 fluorine migration which connects the two structures is low. The cation F2CHCHF+ has a conformation that is a minimum on the potential energy surface that is 16.9 kcal/mol higher in energy than FCH2CF2+; the two structures are separated by a barrier for 1,2 hydrogen migration of 23.5 kcal/mol. The electronic effects in the various structures have been studied using a quantitative PMO analysis of the interactions between the two carbon fragments of the ions. For CF3CH2+ the net effect of the fluorine is highly destabilizing; the principal stabilizing interactions between CF3+ and CH2 consist of π donation from CF3+ to CH2 and homoconjugation of a fluorine lone pair with the cationic centre. No net stabilization attributable to fluorine bridging could be found.