Stability and reactivity of the benzyl and tropylium cations in the gas phase
A measurement of equilibrium [4]: t-C4H9+ + BzCl = t-C4H9Cl + C7H7+ led to equilibrium constants K4 which are in fair agreement with earlier work by Abboud etal. However, the present temperature dependence predicts a ΔS40 which is sufficiently different from that by Abboud etal. to put in question the indentification of C7H7+ as Bz+ on the basis of the measured ΔS40 value. Therefore experiments were made to confirm that C7H7+ produced in [4] is Bz+ and not the tropylium cation. A C7H7+ cation was produced by hydride abstraction from 1,3,5-cycloheptatriene. The behaviour of that C7H7+ ion was entirely different from C7H7+ produced by chloride abstraction from BzCl or hydride abstraction from toluene. While the benzyl derived C7H7+ engaged in a number of reactions like hydride abstraction, chloride abstraction, addition, condensation, etc., the C7H7+ from the heptatriene remained completely unreactive. On this basis the C7H7+ ions were identified as Bz+ and tropylium+, respectively. Rate constants for several reactions of Bz+ were determined. It is concluded that a rearrangement from benzyl to tropylium cations and vice versa does not occur at least up to 300 °C. The ions also retain their identity if they are produced with considerable internal excitation energy.