Mechanical response of highly gap-graded mixtures of waste rock and tailings. Part II: Undrained cyclic and post-cyclic shear response

2010 ◽  
Vol 47 (5) ◽  
pp. 566-582 ◽  
Author(s):  
Dharma Wijewickreme ◽  
Ali Khalili ◽  
G. Ward Wilson

Mixing of waste rock and tailings as a homogeneous mixture (referred to as “paste rock”) has been suggested as a favourable approach to overcome deficiencies associated with traditional methods of mine waste disposal. In consideration of the current limited understanding of the fundamental mechanical response of paste rock, a laboratory research program was undertaken to investigate the monotonic and cyclic shear response of paste rock. This paper presents the findings from undrained cyclic triaxial shear testing conducted on saturated paste rock specimens reconstituted such that the tailings would “just fill” the void spaces between the coarse particles of the skeleton. During undrained cyclic loading, paste rock typically exhibited a cumulative decrease in effective stress along with a progressive degradation of shear stiffness. The material generally displayed a higher tendency for strain development under cyclic loading when compared with rock-only and tailings-only specimens subjected to similar consolidation and cyclic loading conditions. However, no strain-softening or loss of shear strength was observed, suggesting that the material is unlikely to experience flow failure under undrained cyclic loading. The cyclic shear resistance was relatively insensitive to the initial effective confining pressure ([Formula: see text]) for the tested stress levels of [Formula: see text] < 400 kPa.

2010 ◽  
Vol 47 (5) ◽  
pp. 552-565 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ali Khalili ◽  
Dharma Wijewickreme ◽  
G. Ward Wilson

The idea of mixing mine tailings and waste rock to form “paste rock” prior to disposal is now receiving significant attention from the point of view of sustainable mine waste management practices. This approach has been viewed as a favourable alternative to traditional methods of mine waste disposal because paste rock has the potential to overcome deficiencies (e.g., acid rock drainage and liquefaction-induced failures) associated with traditional methods. To advance the current limited knowledge, a laboratory research program was undertaken to study the mechanical response of paste rock. Testing was undertaken on paste rock specimens prepared so that the tailings would “just fill” the void spaces within the waste rock particle skeleton. The findings suggest that the material is unlikely to experience flow deformation under monotonic shear loading conditions, at least up to the tested initial effective confining stress conditions of 400 kPa. The monotonic shear response of paste rock was found to be similar to that of rock-only material; this finding is in agreement with previous observations from one-dimensional consolidation testing where it had been shown that the rock particle skeleton would carry almost 90% of the externally applied stress on a given paste rock mass.


Author(s):  
Huaning Zhu ◽  
Morteza M. Mehrabadi ◽  
Mehrdad Massoudi

The principal objective of this paper is to compare the mechanical response of a double shearing model with that of a hypoplastic model under biaxial compression and under cyclic shear loading. As the origins and nature of these two models are completely different, it is interesting to compare the predictions of these two models. The constitutive relations of the double shearing and the hypoplastic models are implemented in the finite element program ABACUS/Explicit. It is found that the hypoplastic and the double shearing constitutive models both show strong capability in capturing the essential behavior of granular materials. In particular, under the condition of non-cyclic loading, the stress ratio and void ratio predictions of the double shearing and the hypoplastic models are relatively close, while under the condition of cyclic loading, the predictions of these models are quite different. It is important to note that in the double shearing model employed in this comparison the shear rates on the two slip systems are assumed to be equal. Hence, the conclusions derived in this comparison pertain only to this particular double shearing model. Similarly, the hypoplasticity model considered here is that proposed by Wu, et al. [30] and the conclusions reached here pertain only to this particular hypoplasticity model.


Author(s):  
Eleni Stavropoulou ◽  
Christophe Dano ◽  
Marc Boulon

AbstractThe development and construction of offshore wind farms requires the correct estimation of the friction that can be mobilised at the rock/grout interface. In conventional studies, the shear behaviour of a joint is usually investigated with laboratory tests under constant normal load/stress (CNL), however, in engineering practice, direct shear testing under constant normal stiffness (CNS) has been proved to be more realistic in the assessment of the development of the side shear resistance in rock grouted pile design. In this work, an extensive experimental campaign on the shear response of a weak carbonate rock (limestone) interface with grout is presented, in the frame of offshore wind turbines. First, basic mechanical testing is performed on the two interface materials in order to evaluate their mechanical properties. The output of these tests reveals not only the contrasting properties of the two interacting materials, but also the decreased response of the limestone in the presence of water. A series of monotonic shear tests (both under CNL and CNS conditions) on wet rough limestone/grout interfaces reveal the high impact of adhesion between the two materials to the mechanical response. Based on the monotonic results, a number of CNS shear tests under cyclic loading takes place, where different failure modes are observed dilatant and contractant response. The variability of the failure mode is strongly related not only to the adhesion created with the cast grout, but also to the limestone’s micro-structural heterogeneity that manifests already after consolidation. The post-shear morphological state of the interface is analysed, while the variability of the failure surface and the presence of water gouge creation do not allow a clear correlation of the morphologfy to the mechanical response. Overall, the response of this type of weak rock interface where the properties of the grout are significantly higher, is governed by the behaviour of the rock.


2005 ◽  
Vol 42 (5) ◽  
pp. 1408-1421 ◽  
Author(s):  
Dharma Wijewickreme ◽  
Maria V Sanin ◽  
Graham R Greenaway

The mechanical response of three different types of fine-grained mine tailings is examined using data from constant-volume cyclic direct simple shear (DSS) tests. Under cyclic DSS loading, fine-grained tailings typically exhibit a cumulative decrease in effective stress along with progressive degradation of shear stiffness. The observed shear strain development due to cyclic mobility is similar in form to that of the previously observed cyclic shear response for natural silts. The cyclic resistance ratio (CRR) of laterite tailings is observed to increase with an increase in the initial effective confining stress (σ′vc). For this material, the dilative tendency due to stress densification seems to have overridden the contractive tendency due to the increase in confining stress. In contrast, the CRR of copper–gold–zinc tailings is insensitive to the initial effective confining stress, suggesting a response similar to that of normally consolidated clay. The postcyclic maximum shear strength ratio (Su-PC /σ′vc) obtained from constant-volume monotonic DSS tests is noted to increase with a decrease in the void ratio. For the fine-grained tailings considered in this study, the liquefaction susceptibility predicted using commonly used empirical criteria is not always in agreement with the liquefaction triggering determined from cyclic DSS tests.Key words: tailings, liquefaction, cyclic stress ratio, postcyclic shear strength, direct simple shear testing.


2005 ◽  
Vol 42 (2) ◽  
pp. 550-561 ◽  
Author(s):  
Dharma Wijewickreme ◽  
Somasundaram Sriskandakumar ◽  
Peter Byrne

Cyclic loading response of loose Fraser River sand was investigated, as input to numerical simulation of centrifuge physical models, using constant-volume direct simple shear tests conducted with and without initial static shear stress condition. Although the observed trends in mechanical response were similar, air-pluviated specimens were more susceptible to liquefaction under cyclic loading than their water-pluviated counterparts. Densification due to increasing confining stress (stress densification) significantly increased the cyclic resistance of loose air-pluviated sand, with strong implications for the interpretation of observations from centrifuge testing. The stress densification effect, however, was not prominent in the case of water-pluviated specimens. The differences arising from the two specimen reconstitution methods can be attributed to the differences in particle structure and highlight the importance of fabric effects in the assessment of the mechanical response of sands. The initial static shear stresses appear to reduce the cyclic shear resistance of loose air-pluviated sand in simple shear loading, in contrast to the increases in resistance reported on the basis of data from triaxial testing. Data from laboratory element tests that closely mimic the soil fabric and loading modes of the centrifuge specimens are essential for meaningful validation of numerical models.Key words: liquefaction of sands, air-pluviation, cyclic loading, direct simple shear testing, specimen preparation, fabric.


Author(s):  
Trần Thanh Nhàn

In order to observe the end of primary consolidation (EOP) of cohesive soils with and without subjecting to cyclic loading, reconstituted specimens of clayey soils at various Atterberg’s limits were used for oedometer test at different loading increments and undrained cyclic shear test followed by drainage with various cyclic shear directions and a wide range of shear strain amplitudes. The pore water pressure and settlement of the soils were measured with time and the time to EOP was then determined by different methods. It is shown from observed results that the time to EOP determined by 3-t method agrees well with the time required for full dissipation of the pore water pressure and being considerably larger than those determined by Log Time method. These observations were then further evaluated in connection with effects of the Atterberg’s limit and the cyclic loading history.


Author(s):  
Teemu Karlsson ◽  
Lena Alakangas ◽  
Päivi Kauppila ◽  
Marja Liisa Räisänen

AbstractThe mobility of contaminants from mine waste can be assessed using different extraction methods. Aqua regia (AR) extraction is the most commonly used method in Finland. Another method is the analysis of leachate from net acid generation (NAG) tests, which is primarily designed for acid production potential assessment. We investigated the performance of single-addition NAG test leachate analysis and AR extraction in drainage quality prediction, using waste rock and drainage water samples from several Finnish waste rock sites. Our objective was to improve interpretation of the AR and single-addition NAG test leachate analysis results in drainage quality prediction. The AR extraction effectively reflected elements that occurred in elevated concentrations in drainage water, though it over-predicted Al, As, Cd, Co, Cu, and Ni in some circumneutral drainages, and Cr in general. The single-addition NAG test leachate analysis also performed well in assessing the mobility of contaminants including Al and Cr at acid mine drainage sites. As the contaminants tend to precipitate in neutral NAG test solution, the usability of the method in neutral mine drainage cases should be further investigated. Furthermore, the conclusions presented in this study are limited to waste rock samples collected from the surface of piles; future work will examine waste rock history, dump cores, drainage quality changes, etc. in more detail.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document