Defeating numts: Semi-pure mitochondrial DNA from eggs and simple purification methods for field-collected wildlife tissues

Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) continues to play a pivotal role in phylogeographic, phylogenetic, and population genetic studies. PCR amplification with mitochondrial primers often yields ambiguous sequences, in part because of the coamplification of nuclear copies of mitochondrial genes (numts) and true mitochondrial heteroplasmy arising from mutations, hybridization with paternal leakage, gene duplications, and recombination. Failing to detect numts or to distinguish the origin of such homologous sequences results in the incorrect interpretation of data. However, few studies obtain purified mtDNA to confirm the mitochondrial origin of the first reference sequences for a species. Here, we demonstrate the importance and ease of obtaining semi-pure mtDNA from wildlife tissues, preserved under various typical field conditions, and investigate the success of 3 commercial extraction kits, cesium-chloride gradient mtDNA purification, long-template PCR amplification, cloning, and more species-specific degenerate primers. Using more detailed avian examples, we illustrate that unfertilized or undeveloped eggs provide the purest sources of mtDNA; that kits provide an alternative to cesium-chloride gradient methods; and that long-template PCR, cloning, and degenerate primers cannot be used to produce reliable mitochondrial reference sequences, but can be powerful tools when used in conjunction with purified mtDNA stocks to distinguish numts from true heteroplasmy.