Low-cost estimates of mortality rate from single tag recoveries: addressing short-term trap-happy and trap-shy bias
Conventional single tag-recovery data are widely available for stock assessments, notably of invertebrate fisheries, worldwide. Though not commonly used for this purpose, the times-at-large in single tag-recovery data provide (relatively) direct information about average mortality rate as a sample of survival times. Mortality rate is estimated using simple formulas given as functions of the mean time-at-large of tagged and recaptured animals. Here we extend an earlier time-at-large mortality estimator to address a potentially common source of bias: trap-happy or trap-shy behavior shortly following tag release. A maximum likelihood solution is derived, yielding an unbiased estimate of instantaneous mortality rate where the interval of usable times-at-large for observed recaptures may be truncated on both sides to any biologist-chosen experimental (recapture) time frame. In tests of the new doubly-truncated mortality estimator using simulated tag-recovery times-at-large, omitting the first 8 weeks of recaptures from the mortality estimate largely eliminated the bias introduced by simulated short-term trap-happy and trap-shy behavior. Bias in the mortality estimate declined by an order of magnitude more than the observed increase in standard error.