Predator communities associated with brook stickleback (Culaea inconstans) prey: patterns in body size
Prey body size is often inversely correlated with largest size of coexisting predators, yet few studies have examined this relationship in the context of entire predator communities. Using field surveys and laboratory trials, this study tested whether a size relationship exists between brook stickleback (Culaea inconstans) prey and the largest coexisting predator in the context of nested predator communities at 26 sites across Michigan's upper peninsula. Small predators, limited to consuming small sticklebacks, were widely distributed and equally common in pond, breached pond, and stream habitats. Large predators consumed all stickleback sizes, occurred at fewer sites, and were found more frequently in stream than in pond and breached pond habitats in one of the two survey years. Predator communities were categorized as small-predator and mixed-predator communities. Small-predator communities included small, gape-limited predators only. Sticklebacks apparently reached a size refugia from predation (>42 mm standard length) in this community type. Mixed-predator communities included both small and large predators and had no size refugia for sticklebacks. Although predator distributions were nested in this system, prey size was correlated with the largest predator size at each site. Stickleback length was negatively correlated with maximum predator length and was smaller in mixed-predator than in small-predator communities.