Genetic and ecological differences between two Utah endemics: US federally threatened Townsendia aprica and its close congener, T. jonesii var. lutea (Asteraceae)
We used genetic data from isozymes, along with soil analysis and ecological niche models to characterize two rare, morphologically similar Utah endemic Townsendias (Asteraceae). Townsendia aprica Welsh & Reveal and Townsendia jonesii (Beaman) Reveal var. lutea S.L. Welsh are herbaceous perennials endemic to adjacent areas of the Colorado Plateau region in southern Utah. Both are rare (T. aprica is listed as threatened under the Endangered Species Act, USA), and the validity of recognizing them as separate has been questioned. Populations of both taxa were scored for nine informative isozyme loci. High levels of genetic variation were found in each, with little variation among populations within taxa and low but significant divergence estimated between the taxa (FST = 0.119). Neighbor-joining analysis revealed two moderately supported clusters of populations corresponding to the two taxa. Characteristics of the soils on which the two taxa occur differed significantly in percentage sand (higher for T. aprica), percentage clay, and CaCO3 (both higher for T. jonesii var. lutea). Furthermore, ecological niche modeling using 19 climatic variables suggests that the two taxa occupy distinct niches. Taken together, these results support recognition of the two taxa as distinct, and suggest that they are equally imperiled based on their genetic and ecological features.