Jacket Reliability Design Considering Interacting Limit States

Author(s):  
B. F. Ronalds ◽  
R. Pinna ◽  
S. P. Ryan ◽  
J. A. Riordan ◽  
T. M. Radic ◽  
...  

The reliability of jacket structures is addressed by considering inter-relationships between ultimate strength, fatigue and progressive collapse limit states, for both intact and damaged structural configurations and a range of defect and collapse events, including accidents and gross errors. Simple robustness criteria for use in design are suggested based on the ratio of damaged-to-intact probabilities of failure, a progressive collapse indicator and damaged strength ratio (DSR) values. Their practicality is illustrated by detailed reliability assessments of two quite different jacket structures — a major 6-leg platform and a shallow water tripod. The strong interdependence between robustness and quality requirements is demonstrated, as is the potential importance of fatigue-driven progressive collapse for certain structures.

2004 ◽  
Vol 126 (4) ◽  
pp. 562-570 ◽  
Author(s):  
Xiaoping Du ◽  
Agus Sudjianto ◽  
Wei Chen

In this work, we propose an integrated framework for optimization under uncertainty that can bring both the design objective robustness and the probabilistic design constraints into account. The fundamental development of this work is the employment of an inverse reliability strategy that uses percentile performance for assessing both the objective robustness and probabilistic constraints. The percentile formulation for objective robustness provides us an accurate evaluation of the variation of an objective performance and a probabilistic measurement of the robustness. We can obtain more reasonable compound noise combinations for a robust design objective compared to using the traditional approach proposed by Taguchi. The proposed formulation is very efficient to solve since it only needs to evaluate the constraint functions at the required reliability levels. The other major development of this work is a new search algorithm for the Most Probable Point of Inverse Reliability (MPPIR) that can be used to efficiently evaluate percentile performances for both robustness and reliability assessments. Multiple strategies are employed in the MPPIR search, including using the steepest ascent direction and an arc search. The algorithm is applicable to general non-concave and non-convex performance functions of random variables following any continuous distributions. The effectiveness of the MPPIR search algorithm is verified using example problems. Overall, an engineering example on integrated robust and reliability design of a vehicle combustion engine piston is used to illustrate the benefits of our proposed method.


2011 ◽  
Vol 82 ◽  
pp. 344-349
Author(s):  
Daigoro Isobe ◽  
Thi Thai Thanh Le

In this paper, progressive collapse analyses were performed on a 30-story, seven-span tower that was exposed to fire. The Adaptively Shifted Integration (ASI)-Gauss technique was used to demonstrate the effects of fire patterns and structural parameters on collapse initiation time: the duration from the beginning of the fire until collapse initiation. Specifically, an outrigger truss system was placed on the roof of a model, and the influence of the system on the structural vulnerability of the tower was verified. The structural parameters that were varied in the analyses included the axial force ratio, the member joint strength ratio and the member strength ratio of the outrigger trusses to the strength of the beams on the first floor. From the numerical results, it is confirmed that collapse initiation times are significantly affected by the member joint strength ratio if the axial force ratio is small (floor loads are low) on the condition that the fire pattern is nearly symmetrical, and the load paths to and from the outrigger truss system are sufficiently protected.


Author(s):  
B. F. Ronalds ◽  
R. Pinna ◽  
D. J. Trench ◽  
D. G. Cosson ◽  
G. K. Cole

Moment magnification in platforms such as monopods and jack-ups may be addressed in a variety of ways in the design process. This paper investigates how differing treatments influence the reserve strength ratio (RSR) and hence structural reliability of sway platforms. Both WSD and LRFD versions of API RP2A are considered, together with several methods of estimating the moment magnification factor. The effect of varying topside weight is also incorporated — increasing topside load increases the second order moments but also increases the amount of steel provided by the Code to resist the loadings. It is found that the RSR varies widely for different structural configurations and may either increase or decrease with increasing topside weight. The RSR is also sensitive to the design approach adopted. As a result, a single set of partial load factors will not succeed in narrowing the spread of reliabilities across different configurations and design philosophies. Indeed, the use of a WSD format may result in more uniform reliability levels than API RP2A-LRFD for certain sway platforms.


1987 ◽  
Vol 14 (4) ◽  
pp. 447-454 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. H. Rainer

A derivation of force reduction factors for the seismic provisions of the National Building Code of Canada (NBCC), 1985, is presented. This includes the following: classification of seismic actions, applicable limit states, change in load factor, derivation of force reduction factors, and classification of structural configurations. Quantitative comparisons are made between the derived force reduction factors and the response modification factors of the Applied Technology Council and good agreement was found. It is suggested that seismic requirements should be considered as accidental actions with a load factor αQ = 1.0. These results can form the basis for possible modifications to the 1985 NBCC seismic provisions. Key words: earthquake resistant structures, building code, loads, load factors.


2013 ◽  
Vol 405-408 ◽  
pp. 731-734
Author(s):  
Ying Wu Zhou ◽  
Feng Xing ◽  
Li Li Sui

This paper has investigated the reliability of concrete filled FRP tube columns using the FRP confined concrete theory developed recently by the authors. The reliability index of the column is assessed by Monte Carlo method. The importance of the use of partial safety factors of FRP and concrete in the reliability design of concrete filled FRP tube columns is studied. The results indicate that the reliability index of concrete filled FRP tube columns increases remarkably as the FRP partial safety factor increased. It is concluded that the FRP partial safety factor is independent on the coefficient of variation of FRP strength but is highly sensitive to the coefficient of variation of concrete strength especially in the case of low confinement ratio. Considering the actual situation in engineering applications, to reach a target reliability index of 3.5, a partial safety factor of 1.4 is finally recommend for both FRP and concrete.


Author(s):  
D. Sanderson ◽  
A. Nelson ◽  
A. Stacey

Current offshore inspection practice relies on the detection of gross damage, such as flooded member detection. Such an inspection philosophy relies upon the structure’s ability to withstand gross damage for an inspection interval based on the large reserve factors on the jacket design strength in both the undamaged and damaged conditions. This requires a demonstration of the structure’s strength in all of the possible damaged conditions with the most critical member removed. However, the load originally carried by the critical member is redistributed to other neighbouring members which must consequently have an impact on the design fatigue lives of other members and increase the probability of more members failing. Ignoring the effects of stress redistribution due to member failure could therefore result in under-prediction of the probability of a second member failing and hence an optimistic prediction of platform reliability. This paper aims to quantify the effects of stress redistribution on the prediction of platform reliability. Stress and ultimate strength analyses were performed on three platforms in 45m water depth with bracing configurations of varying structural redundancies, namely, single diagonal, inverted K and X-braced, to calculate the stress enhancement in all members due to the individual failure of all other members. These stress enhancements were input into probabilistic fracture mechanics models to calculate the increase in failure probability of these second members due to the failure of a first member. More than 1000 pushover analyses were performed to calculate the ultimate strength of the structures in all single-member failed conditions and many hundreds of dual member failed permutations for each jacket. A cross-correlation of the most significant stress redistribution results and pushover results was used to perform platform reliability assessments. The effect of including stress redistribution and dual member pushover results was shown to reduce the predicted platform reliability for all bracing configurations, mainly due to a number of dual-member failed conditions that weakened the jackets significantly. It is recommended that, in addition to performing single member failed pushover analyses, there is a need to assess dual-member failed conditions that drastically reduce platform strength.


Vestnik MGSU ◽  
2021 ◽  
pp. 1462-1472
Author(s):  
Vitaly I. Kolchunov ◽  
Pavel A. Korenkov ◽  
Dinh Quoc Phan

Introduction. The increasing number of domestic and foreign publications on structural safety and survivability of buildings and structures evidences a great interest in the study of the problem of protecting bearing systems from progressive collapse. The relevance of these studies is determined by the ongoing rise in the number of man-induced, natural and terrorist impacts on buildings and structures. In this regard, the decisive factor is the expansion of experimental and theoretical studies, focused on ensuring the required level of survivability of bearing systems under such special impacts and, respectively, developing methods for protection from progressive collapse. Materials and methods. This work presents new results of experimental studies on models of a fragment of a multi-storied building made of monolithic reinforced concrete, whose nodes, connecting the girder and the column, are reinforced with laterally reinforced meshes designed to resist operational static loads and a special emergency impact caused by the failure of one ground-floor column in the framework. Results. The article presents the results of experimental and theoretical studies on the stress-strain state and crack resistance of reinforced concrete frames or fragments of multi-storied frameworks of buildings, made of monolithic reinforced concrete. Nodes of these buildings are laterally reinforced. The data on force-induced resistance of structures were obtained for cases of the static operational loading of a structure and special emergency impacts caused by the instantaneous withdrawal of one column on the ground floor. A comparative analysis of the pace of cracking, crack development and opening is made. The co-authors have made a benchmark assessment of parameters of limit and beyond-the-limit states, as well as elements of structural systems, having nodes with/without laterally reinforced meshes. Conclusions. The co-authors have identified the nature of actual deformation and destruction of elements in the bearing system, whose nodes are laterally reinforced. The co-authors have experimentally identified the principal properties of structural elements to allow for a more rigorous assessment of deformability and the bearing capacity of the effect produced by the lateral reinforcement on the resistance of structural systems in beyond-the-limit states.


2014 ◽  
Vol 578-579 ◽  
pp. 1353-1356
Author(s):  
Liu Lei Shen ◽  
Qi Gao Hu ◽  
Fan Zhen Zhang

A progressive collapse of a RC frame structure may be initiated by an event that damages one member of the structure. FRP is widely used in the field of structural reinforcement for its high strength ratio, convenient construction and corrosion resistance. In this paper, the collapse scene of a RC frame specimen with the failure mid-column in three programs has been simulated by LS-DYNA. We can infer the ultimate bearing capacity of the structure is raised about 10% (retrofitted by CFRP), 15% (retrofitted by GFRP) by comparing the results of finite element analysis.


2002 ◽  
Vol 29 (5) ◽  
pp. 799-805 ◽  
Author(s):  
M S Cheung ◽  
W C Li

The current practice of highway bridge design in Canada is based on limit states design. Ideally, by means of the properly calibrated load and resistance factors specified in the applicable design code, limit states design will yield a consistent and uniform safety level for all designed bridge structures. Some factors neglected in the standard design procedures, however, may have unexpected effects on the reliability of a particular design. In this case, to follow a design code exactly may still lead to a certain degree of underdesign or overdesign. Therefore, the reliability assessment is recommended for each particular design, and a simulation-based approach for this assessment is proposed in this study. Examples are presented to support the afore-mentioned recommendation.Key words: highway bridges, reliability, design code, simulation, finite strip method.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document