Long-Term Evaluation of the Bonding Strength of Composite Repairs

Author(s):  
Khalid Farrag ◽  
Kevin Stutenberg

The long-term performance of composite repair systems depends on their structural integrity and interaction with the carrier pipe. The adhesives used in the composites are critical components that not only bond the repair to the pipe, but also bond the individual layers of the repair to one another. The durability of the inter-laminate adhesive bond is required to ensure adequate load transfer between the pipe and the composite layers over the predicted lifetime of the repair. A testing program was performed to evaluate the shear strength of the adhesives used in composite repairs. The testing program evaluated the performance of seven commercially-available composite repair systems and it consisted of short-term and long-term shear tests on the adhesives and cathodic disbondment tests on the repair systems. The long-term shear tests were performed for 10,000 hours on samples submerged in a water solution with pH value of 9 and at various loading levels at temperatures of 70°F, 105°F and 140°F. The results of the long-term tests at elevated temperatures were extrapolated to predict the shear strengths at longer durations. The 20-year shear strengths of the composites were estimated using: (a) direct extrapolation of the best-fit curves and (b) the application of the rate process procedure. The results demonstrated the significant effect of temperature on the bond strength of the composites and provided a comparative analysis to evaluate the long-term shear strength and cathodic disbondment of the composite repair systems.

Author(s):  
Chris Alexander

Although composite materials are used to repair and reinforce a variety of anomalies in high pressure transmission gas and liquid pipelines, there continues to be widespread debate regarding what constitutes a long-term composite repair. The United States regulations require that composite repairs must be able to permanently restore the serviceability of the repaired pipeline, while in contrast the Canadian regulations take a more prescriptive approach by integrating the ASME PCC-2 and ISO 24817 composite repair standards along with a requirement for establishing a 50-year design life. In this paper the author provides a framework for what should be considered in qualifying a composite repair system for long-term performance by focusing on the critical technical aspects associated with a sound composite repair. The presentation includes a discussion on establishing an appropriate composite design stress using the existing standards, using full-scale testing to ensure that stresses in the repair do not exceed the designated composite design stresses, and guidance for operators in how to properly integrate their pipeline operating conditions to establish a design life. By implementing the recommendations presented in this paper, operators will be equipped with a resource for objectively evaluating the composite repair systems used to repair their pipeline systems.


Author(s):  
Chris Alexander ◽  
Jim Souza ◽  
Casey Whalen

For the better part of the past 20 years composite materials have been used to repair damaged piping and pressurized components in plants, refineries, and pipelines. The use of composite materials has been accompanied by comprehensive research programs focused on the development and assessment of using composite technology for restoring integrity to damaged piping and pressurized components. Of particular interest are composite repair standards such as ISO 24817 and ASME PCC-2 that provide technical guidance in how to properly design composite repair systems. The vast body of research completed to date has involved assessments at ambient conditions; however, at the present time there is significant interest in evaluating the performance of composite repair materials at elevated temperatures. This paper is focused on the topic of high temperature composite repairs and addresses the critical role of utilizing temperature-based mechanical properties to establish a composite repair design. The backbone of this effort is the development of composite performance curves that correlate change in strength as a function of temperature. A discussion on supporting full-scale pressure test results are included, along with guidance for users in how to properly design composite repair systems for applications at elevated temperatures.


Author(s):  
Colton Sheets ◽  
Robert Rettew ◽  
Chris Alexander ◽  
Tanya Axenova

The increasing use of composite repair systems in critical and complex applications has brought greater scrutiny to their design and performance. This has been especially true in high-temperature, immersed environment applications where ambient temperature test results with industry standard de-rating factors are all that is available for design. Since this approach does not always adequately capture environmental effects or the performance of composite systems at elevated temperatures, it is beneficial to perform full-scale testing which accurately replicates the in-situ application. In order to accomplish this, a full-scale testing program was developed that subjected multiple composite repair systems to internal and external loads at temperatures up to 120 °C with and without water immersion. This program involved the reinforcement of 12.75-inch × 0.375-inch pipe samples that had simulated corrosion defects. Full-scale load and pressure testing was conducted to simulate the long-term performance of the composite repair systems in the environmental conditions of the application. A strain based performance threshold of 0.4% strain at 120 °C and 100% SMYS was used to develop a competitive program that ranked the participating systems and reduced the number of acceptable repairs from six down to three. This approach increased the efficiency of the full-scale testing and allowed for more in-depth analysis of the top-performing systems. The results of the full-scale testing of six composite repair systems at elevated temperature allowed for a quantitative measure of their effectiveness under in-situ conditions. Several of the systems were shown to provide inadequate reinforcement under these conditions; however, it was also observed that appropriately designed and installed systems are capable of meeting the intense demands of elevated temperature, harsh-service conditions.


2021 ◽  
Vol 1035 ◽  
pp. 870-877
Author(s):  
Lian Xun Ming ◽  
Deng Zun Yao ◽  
Bin Chen ◽  
Zhen Heng Teng ◽  
Lin Wang

Composite repair systems of buried pipeline will be affected by moisture and other factors due to anti-corrosion and construction problems. These environmental factors will reduce the service life of the composite system. In this paper, the performance of composite and interface between composite and steel under the action of water were studied. It was found that the formation of micro-cracks on the surface of composite materials and the hydrolysis of epoxy resin were the important reasons for the Performance degradation. Moreover, the aging properties of composite materials and their interfaces under water immersion were analyzed by residual strength theory, and the life prediction equation of composite materials and interfaces were obtained, which can be useful to the field application of composite repair systems.


Author(s):  
Robert A. Denzine ◽  
Davion M. Hill

Composites have seen increased usage for repair of pipelines. The performance of the entire metal-composite system has not been extensively addressed with regard to corrosion of the substrate and adhesion loss when the conditions are wet and the substrate is cathodically protected. In this work we have investigated the influence of corrosive environments on the performance of composite repair systems for pipelines. Earlier in this work we used FEA models to evaluate a composite patch for pipelines and the present research includes the experimental results for both patch and full-wrap composite repairs in simulated and field environments. The effect of impacts, cathodic protection, long term immersion, and soil corrosivity have been investigated by monitoring variables related to potential and conductivity of the electrolyte. We have also tested mechanical properties via four point bend on specimens intentionally exposed to ASTM cathodic disbondment tests. We have also evaluated the performance of these repairs in a modified ASTM G8 cathodic disbondment test with the addition of high pressure cyclic loading. By monitoring these variables, loss of adhesion and integrity in the composite-metal system is addressed.


Author(s):  
M. Singh ◽  
Edgar Lara-Curzio

Various issues associated with the design and mechanical evaluation of joints of ceramic matrix composites are discussed. The specific case of an affordable, robust ceramic joining technology (ARCJoinT) to join silicon carbide (CG-Nicalon™) fiber-reinforced-chemically vapor infiltrated (CVI) silicon carbide matrix composites is addressed. Experimental results are presented for the time and temperature dependence of the shear strength of these joints in air up to 1200°C. From compression testing of double-notched joint specimens with a notch separation of 4 mm, it was found that the apparent shear strength of the joints decreased from 92 MPa at room temperature to 71 MPa at 1200°C. From shear stress-rupture testing in air at 1200°C it was found that the shear strength of the joints decreased rapidly with time from an initial shear strength of 71 MPa to 17.5 MPa after 14.3 hours. The implications of these results in relation to the expected long-term service life of these joints in applications at elevated temperatures are discussed.


2017 ◽  
Vol 891 ◽  
pp. 25-32
Author(s):  
Kritsayanee Saelor ◽  
Panyawat Wangyao

Udimet 520 is a low precipitation strengthened nickel-based superalloy, which was designed and developed to be gas turbine blades at elevated temperatures. However, after long-term service under high stresses and temperatures, the microstructure of the turbine blades could be continually degraded. Therefore, the mechanical properties could be worse than the new ones. The rejuvenation heat treatment of degraded turbine blades, which were made of cast Udimet 520, was following by solution treatment at 1,121oC / 4 hours and then double aging processes including primary aging at 843 oC / 24 hours and secondary aging at 760oC / 16 hours, respectively. However, in practical reheat treatment processes, the temperature during solution treatment could be dropped by error or malfunction of high temperature heating furnace because the furnace has to be operated continually at very high temperature for very long time resulting in final reheat treated microstructures in many nickel base superalloys. To simulate this effect, the droppings of temperature during solution treatment are chosen and performed for 3 levels; 840oC, 800oC and 760oC, which could happen in practical working then heated up again immediately to solution temperature level. The maximum number of temperature dropping during the single solution treatment is up to 3 times. Received results show that the effect of temperature dropping during solution treatment has influenced on the final rejuvenated microstructures slightly due to the low precipitation behavior of the alloy. The long term heating at 800oC and 900oC / 1000 hours provided much effect in gamma prime particle coarsening.


Author(s):  
Ibrahim A. Alnaser ◽  
Mahdi Kiani ◽  
Roger Walker ◽  
Michael W. Keller

Abstract Bonded composite repairs are commonly used as both a temporary and permanent repair method to restore damaged pressure vessels and pipelines. This repair approach is used in a wide variety of industries, including the oil and gas industry. Design and qualification of repair method have been standardized by the ASME post-construction codes. Significant literature has been generated to understand the behavior of these repairs under a variety of loading conditions, both static and dynamic. However, this repair type has typically only been investigated at or near room temperature. As the application possibilities for these repairs expand, higher service temperatures have become a focus for both repair manufacturers and operators. High temperatures (> 250°F) have a number of impacts on polymer composites, including reducing the elastic modulus of the repair material, which tends to reduce the repair strength. Therefore, it is critical to understand the effect of temperature on both the individual composite components, as well as the overall composite repair system. The research presented here studies the influence of temperature on bonded composite repair systems at service pressure (3000 psi) and high temperature conditions. This high temperature is generated using a heating element inside the repaired vessel while contained inside an insulated oven. Strain measurements of the repair are also investigated during a quasi-static testing.


2020 ◽  
Vol 70 (1) ◽  
pp. 115-121
Author(s):  
Rajendra Soti ◽  
Cody Knight ◽  
Shanmathi Mageshwar ◽  
Srikar D. Valluri ◽  
Arijit Sinha

Abstract Structural wall sheathing such as oriented strand board (OSB) and plywood have been heavily used in residential and commercial timber frame construction. The response of these wood-based composites under elevated temperatures between 100°C and 200°C (herein referred to as elevated temperatures) and exposure time needs to be characterized to assess residual strength of the materials in the existing structures. The main objective of this work is to study the effect of temperature and exposure time on shear strength and shear modulus of plywood and OSB. A total of 110 test specimens was tested in shear after exposure to five different temperatures and two exposure durations, followed by cooling to ambient temperature. The results indicated that the plywood and OSB behaved differently after exposure to elevated temperatures and exposure duration. Plywood showed a consistent degradation of shear strength with elevated temperature and time, while OSB did not exhibit a clear picture of thermal degradation. The results further indicated that the shear modulus of plywood and OSB remained unaffected after exposure to elevated temperatures.


Author(s):  
Chris Alexander ◽  
Jim Souza

In response to inquiries from pipeline operators regarding the long-term performance of composite materials, manufacturers have performed additional tests to evaluate the performance of their composite repair systems. Insights were gained through these additional tests that demonstrated the long-term worthiness of the composite system. Of particular importance were two types of tests. The first involved the application of strain gages between layers of the composite repair system that was used to reinforce a corroded pipe test sample. As the sample was pressurized the strain gages permitted a comparison between the measured values and design stresses per the ASME PCC-2 design code. The second series of tests involved pressure cycling a 75% corroded sample to failure. In addition to the inter-layer strain measurements, the pressure cycling provides an important insight regarding the long-term performance of the composite repair. This paper addresses how the ASME PCC-2 Code, along with additional well-designed tests, can be used to design a composite repair system to ensure that it adequately reinforces a given defect. As composite materials are being used to repair pipeline anomalies beyond the corrosion-only defects, it is essential that pipeline operators utilize a systematic approach for ensuring the long-term performance of composite repair systems.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document