Integrating a Hybrid Electric Drive Propulsion System With the Existing DDG 51 Class Machinery Control System

Author(s):  
Richard Halpin ◽  
Frank Sapienza

The destroyers of the USS Arleigh Burke Class all have 4 propulsion gas turbines and 3 gas turbine generators (GTGs). A typical at-sea “condition 3” operating profile consists of having 2 gas turbine generators running at approximately 50% capacity, and one propulsion gas turbine online at low to intermediate ship speeds. Having 2 GTGs online at all times at 50% load each provides the obvious advantage of maintaining all electric loads should one GTG shut down unexpectedly. This luxury does come at the cost of fuel efficiency, as gas turbines efficiency improves continuously as they move away from idle. On the propulsion end, a single gas turbine is capable of generating enough horsepower to propel the ship at speeds in excess of 20 knots. Depending upon the specific mission that the destroyer may be on, however, quite a bit of operating profile may be at speeds below 15 knots where the LM2500 is operating at less than 20% capacity. In this range of operation specific fuel consumption ratios are also relatively low. The proposed Hybrid Electric Drive (HED) system has the potential to address both of these inefficient ranges of operation. By installing one 2000 horsepower electric motor on each shaft, the electric motors can be used to propel the ship at speeds below 14 knots (projected) while running the GTGs up to 90% operating range where they are most efficient. The LM2500 is shut down completely at this range, and the potential fuel savings in this configuration is substantial. While there are many engineering challenges with installing such a HED system on board an in-service DDG, the focus of this paper is on how to integrate HED with the existing Machinery Control System (MCS). Such challenges include interfacing MCS to the HED supervisory controller, developing a new HED control interface for the propulsion control operator, integrating HED into the existing shaft speed control algorithm, transitioning to and from HED propulsion, and updating data logging to include HED. Managing the interface between current electric load, changing electric loads, and current available HED power will also be addressed.

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gianfranco Buonamici

Abstract With an increasing instability and cost fluctuation in the world energy markets, it has become more important to increase the US Navy fleet’s overall fuel efficiency. The Navy’s Energy Program for Security and Independence sets forth goals to reduce its overall consumption of energy and decrease its reliance on petroleum. One way that helps accomplish these goals is through the use of hybrid electric drive systems to replace gas turbine engines to accomplish lower ship speeds. Although gas turbines are power dense and fairly efficient at full load, their fuel efficiency decreases drastically at the lower power levels used when slower speeds are required to accomplish the ship’s mission. It is in this lower speed range where operating gas turbine generators closer to their optimum efficiency levels and powering an electric motor saves a significant amount of fuel. This paper will discuss two in-service systems developed for various US Navy ships: the Hybrid Electric Drive (HED) system for DDG 103 and the Auxiliary Propulsion System (APS) for LHD 8 and LHA 7. It will describe each of the two configurations and their histories, how they are implemented and increase the capability of the ship, and the resulting fuel efficiencies that have been realized with their use.


Author(s):  
Gianfranco Buonamici ◽  
Michael Schauble

This paper will discuss the development and testing of an electric drive option designed for the propulsion system of the US Navy’s DDG 51 Class ships. It will briefly explain the history of the Hybrid Electric Drive (HED) program, including that of its predecessor, Proof of Concept (PoC), and the HED’s planned shipboard installation schedule. Operating at lower ship speeds, in a range where the currently installed propulsion gas turbines are less fuel efficient, the HED is expected to increase the ship’s fuel economy, allowing the ship to remain on station accomplishing its mission for a longer period of time. This paper will discuss how the gas turbine propulsion system, in concert with the HED, will be used to provide the most fuel efficient drive combination for various operating scenarios. Also covered will be a description of the major stakeholders involved in the HED’s development and implementation along with some of the constraints and challenges that were encountered in the testing phase of the program, both at the OEM facilities and at the US Navy’s Land Based Engineering Site (LBES) in Philadelphia PA. Planned fuel economy testing results obtained at the LBES facility will also be presented, intended to determine an estimate of the fuel savings that can be expected when the system is first placed in service on USS TRUXTUN (DDG 103) July 2018.


Author(s):  
Matthew G. Hoffman ◽  
Brian J. Connery ◽  
Helen J. Kozuhowski ◽  
Iva´n Pin˜eiro

The U.S. Navy operates Rolls Royce 501-K34 powered Gas Turbine Generators (GTGs) on DDG 51 Class destroyers. The design of these GTGs has evolved significantly over the course of the shipbuilding program. One significant change is that GTGs on DDG 51 to 90 are rated to provide 2,500 KW while those on DDG 91 and follow are rated at 3,000 KW. The 3,000 KW rating has been accepted by the Navy and demonstrated on several new GTGs during qualification testing. However, test results indicate that one area where very little performance margin exists is full load transient response. This paper discusses extensive transient testing performed on a DDG 51 Class GTG at the U.S. Navy’s Land Based Engineering Site (LBES) in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. It details control system modifications that optimize performance and explores changes to GTG transient response that result from operation with a new type of 501-K34 fuel nozzle.


Author(s):  
C. Kalathakis ◽  
N. Aretakis ◽  
I. Roumeliotis ◽  
A. Alexiou ◽  
K. Mathioudakis

The concept of solar steam production for injection in a gas turbine combustion chamber is studied for both nominal and part load engine operation. First, a 5MW single shaft engine is considered which is then retrofitted for solar steam injection using either a tower receiver or a parabolic troughs scheme. Next, solar thermal power is used to augment steam production of an already steam injected single shaft engine without any modification of the existing HRSG by placing the solar receiver/evaporator in parallel with the conventional one. For the case examined in this paper, solar steam injection results to an increase of annual power production (∼15%) and annual fuel efficiency (∼6%) compared to the fuel-only engine. It is also shown that the tower receiver scheme has a more stable behavior throughout the year compared to the troughs scheme that has better performance at summer than at winter. In the case of doubling the steam-to-air ratio of an already steam injected gas turbine through the use of a solar evaporator, annual power production and fuel efficiency increase by 5% and 2% respectively.


1991 ◽  
Vol 113 (2) ◽  
pp. 290-295 ◽  
Author(s):  
H. Kumakura ◽  
T. Matsumura ◽  
E. Tsuruta ◽  
A. Watanabe

A control system has been developed for a high-quality generating set (150-kW) equipped with a two-shaft gas turbine featuring a variable power turbine nozzle. Because this generating set satisfies stringent frequency stability requirements, it can be employed as the direct electric power source for computer centers without using constant-voltage, constant-frequency power supply systems. Conventional generating sets of this kind have normally been powered by single-shaft gas turbines, which have a larger output shaft inertia than the two-shaft version. Good frequency characteristics have also been realized with the two-shaft gas turbine, which provides superior quick start ability and lower fuel consumption under partial loads.


Author(s):  
Martin Quin˜ones ◽  
Steve Mason ◽  
Allan Green

The US Navy has pursued gas turbine electric start systems since 2003. Such a system has been extensively tested at the Naval Surface Warfare Center, Carderock Division (NSWCCD) Land Based Engineering Site (LBES) in Philadelphia, PA. It was demonstrated on a General Electric (GE) LM2500 main propulsion engine as well as a Rolls Royce (RR) MT30 engine. Presently, the system is being refined and repackaged to undergo U.S. Navy qualification for production use. Given the performance success of electric start the next logical step is to extend its application to other engine lines such as the Ship Service Gas Turbine Generators (SSGTG). In order to facilitate platform integration, the electric start concept has been evolved into the Electric Start and Generation System (ESGS). As expected, this system has the ability to start a gas turbine by purely electrical means. Once the engine has reached idle speed or above, the ESGS becomes a generator capable of producing power. This power may be harnessed to address dark start capability on Surface Combatants. The ESGS configuration simplifies integration of bulk energy storage such as a flywheel device or battery pack. This will ensure availability to the engine under a loss of platform power scenario thus providing self-sustainability to all the gas turbine’s electrical functions. Another alternative is to continuously provide ESGS generated power back to the electrical grid in continuous support of the engine auxiliary systems. In this case, flywheels and batteries may be replaced by advanced transfer switches that redirect power where it is needed on demand. This paper describes a program undertaken by NSWCCD to carry out land based testing of an advanced design ESGS. An overview of system requirements is given from a perspective of platform integration. The system architecture is fully described. It is an evolution of ESGS technology that has been extensively tested on RR MT30 and GE LM2500 gas turbines at NSWCCD LBES. Compared with existing air and alternative hydraulic gas turbine starter systems, this system is more compact and provides the benefits of simplified platform integration. It incorporates energy storage to provide black start capability for the gas turbine. Battery and inertial energy storage technologies are discussed in detail for use with the ESGS.


Author(s):  
Alan Metzger

With the approach of the 1990 Clean Air Act compliance limits, the race is on to produce a functional, low-emission gas turbine. While most prototype Dry Low NOx (DLN) gas turbines are based on existing designs, the leap in technology required to meet NOx abatement levels is significant. To meet these goals, significant testing is required before low-emission turbines are ready for commercial production. This paper describes the test procedure that was used to verify control system and modulating valve technology for Turbo Power & Marine’s FT8-2™ Dry Low NOx prototype turbine. In particular, dynamic turbine simulation before the actual engine test will be discussed. The method and benefits of this test procedure will be presented.


1990 ◽  
Vol 112 (2) ◽  
pp. 176-181 ◽  
Author(s):  
R. A. Sylvestre ◽  
R. J. Dupuis

The background and evolution of gas turbine fuel controls is examined in this paper from a Naval perspective. The initial application of aeroderivative gas turbines to Navy ships utilized the engine’s existing aircraft fuel controls, which were coupled to the ship’s hydropneumatic machinery control system. These engines were adapted to Naval requirements by including engine specific functions. The evolution of Naval gas turbine controllers first to analog electronic, and more recently, to distributed digital controls, has increased the system complexity and added a number of levels of machinery protection. The design of a specific electronic control module is used to illustrate the current state of the technology. The paper concludes with a discussion of the further need to address the issues of fuel handling, metering and control in Navy ships with particular emphasis on integration in the marine environment.


Author(s):  
Behnam Rezaei Zangmolk ◽  
Hiwa Khaledi

In this paper, development of a modular code for simulation of design and off-design performance of different gas turbines (with different shafts and technology) has been described. This interactive code will be used for different purposes in MPG Company. This turbomachinery and thermodynamic model is based on compressor and turbine maps and blade cooling has been considered with a cooling model. Component maps and effect of IGV have been developed from one of 1D, 2D or Q3d in-house codes. It is demonstrated that this model is accurate for prediction of gas turbine behavior at both design and off-design conditions. Effect of various control system — IGV constant, TIT constant and TET constant — is evaluated. These results show that IGV constant control system has the highest and TIT constant have the lowest efficiency for a simple cycle gas turbine. In contrast, the reverse is true in a combined cycle. Also the results show that the compressor is the most stable and away enough from surge line with IGV constant control system and has the highest efficiency.


Author(s):  
Koldo Zuniga ◽  
Thomas P. Schmitt ◽  
Herve Clement ◽  
Joao Balaco

Correction curves are of great importance in the performance evaluation of heavy duty gas turbines (HDGT). They provide the means by which to translate performance test results from test conditions to the rated conditions. The correction factors are usually calculated using the original equipment manufacturer (OEM) gas turbine thermal model (a.k.a. cycle deck), varying one parameter at a time throughout a given range of interest. For some parameters bi-variate effects are considered when the associated secondary performance effect of another variable is significant. Although this traditional approach has been widely accepted by the industry, has offered a simple and transparent means of correcting test results, and has provided a reasonably accurate correction methodology for gas turbines with conventional control systems, it neglects the associated interdependence of each correction parameter from the remaining parameters. Also, its inherently static nature is not well suited for today’s modern gas turbine control systems employing integral gas turbine aero-thermal models in the control system that continuously adapt the turbine’s operating parameters to the “as running” aero-thermal component performance characteristics. Accordingly, the most accurate means by which to correct the measured performance from test conditions to the guarantee conditions is by use of Model-Based Performance Corrections, in agreement with the current PTC-22 and ISO 2314, although not commonly used or accepted within the industry. The implementation of Model-based Corrections is presented for the Case Study of a GE 9FA gas turbine upgrade project, with an advanced model-based control system that accommodated a multitude of operating boundaries. Unique plant operating restrictions, coupled with its focus on partial load heat rate, presented a perfect scenario to employ Model-Based Performance Corrections.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document